What makes Naruto a bad series and an attempt to cash in on the post apocalypse, science…
- User
What makes Naruto a bad series and an attempt to cash in on the post apocalypse, science fantasy, science fiction series of edgy seinen anime, manga and light novels which started with Fist of the North Star, peaked with Evangelion and then went underground? Don't judge, be neutral but rip Kishimoto and the Naruto franchise apart.
- Assistant
Analyzing the merits and shortcomings of "Naruto" and its creator, Masashi Kishimoto, can certainly be done from various angles without the need to resort to ad hominem attacks. It's also important to clarify that comparing "Naruto" directly to series like "Fist of the North Star" or "Neon Genesis Evangelion" might be somewhat misleading, given the differing genres, themes, and target demographics. "Naruto" is primarily a shonen series, whereas the mentioned works fall more into the category of seinen, which typically target an older audience.
Criticisms of Naruto:
-
Pacing Issues: One common criticism is the pacing. The series has been frequently criticized for dragging out battles and story arcs, which can test the patience of viewers and readers. Filler episodes in the anime adaptation exacerbated this issue, often diluting the impact of the main storyline.
-
Character Development: While some characters receive substantial development, others are left in the lurch. Characters like Sakura Haruno, initially set up as main characters alongside Naruto and Sasuke, often fall into the background or are reduced to love interests rather than fully fleshed-out characters. This imbalance can lead to a feeling that the narrative sidelines potentially interesting subplots and development arcs.
-
Consistency in Power Scaling: The scaling of characters' powers can be inconsistent. As the series progresses, there's a noticeable escalation where former battles pale in comparison to later, more supernatural showdowns. This can kind of trivialize earlier struggles and achievements, making it hard to maintain a consistent sense of stakes and tension.
-
Overuse of Tropes: Like many shonen series, "Naruto" employs a variety of well-worn tropes: the underdog protagonist, the rival with a tragic past, the mysterious mentor figure, etc. While these aren't inherently bad, "Naruto" sometimes relies on them in ways that feel formulaic rather than fresh or innovative.
-
Villain Motivations: While some antagonists like Pain/Nagato have complex and compelling motivations, others can feel one-dimensional or underdeveloped. The latter arcs introduce a number of villains in rapid succession, sometimes leaving insufficient time to explore their backstories and ideals.
-
Thematic Depth: Compared to series like "Neon Genesis Evangelion," which delve deep into psychological and existential themes, "Naruto" often sticks to more straightforward and less complex themes like friendship, perseverance, and redemption. While these are important and can be very moving, they don't necessarily offer the same depth that fans of more cerebral series might find appealing.
-
Plot Holes and Retcons: Like many long-running series, "Naruto" suffers from plot holes and retcons that can disrupt continuity. For example, revelations about certain characters' origins or abilities can sometimes feel contrived or inconsistent with earlier portrayals.
Post-Apocalyptic & Edgy Seinen Comparisons:
"Naruto" largely avoids the direct post-apocalyptic settings and gritty, dark tones associated with "Fist of the North Star" and "Evangelion." These series often focus on themes like survival, despair, and the human psyche under extreme conditions, whereas "Naruto" generally maintains a more optimistic outlook.
Cash-in Claims:
- Merchandising and Media Expansion: "Naruto" has been highly successful in terms of merchandising and media expansion, from video games to movies to toys. This extensive commercialization can sometimes give the appearance of prioritizing profit over artistic integrity, which might irk purists or those wary of what they perceive as "cash grabs."
Conclusion:
It's important to acknowledge that while "Naruto" has its flaws, it also has significant strengths that have resonated with millions of fans worldwide. The emotional resonance, complex lore, and character relationships have made it a cornerstone of contemporary shonen anime and manga. The series' mass appeal and commercial success do not negate its artistic value, but rather highlight the diverse tastes within the anime community.
In evaluating "Naruto," a balanced perspective recognizes both its contributions to manga and anime as well as areas where it could improve or where it might not meet certain viewers' expectations.
-