i am an online ESL teacher. My B1 student was struggling with some grammar points and i…
- User
i am an online ESL teacher. My B1 student was struggling with some grammar points and i gave this advice:
""commute - very long (time) - 'get' on/off the train/ bus/ tram I need to 'get' (take) the train. I 'get on' (arrive) the train. I 'got on' (arrived) the train. cluttered (not well organised) feeling stuck (not able to move) - "I feel stuck in my role at work." No autonomy (no authority over your destiny/ career). prospects - "John had limited prospects (opportunities) at his company." rewarding - "Sarah doesn't feel rewarded doing her job." Not challenged; demotivated""
i did it in a bit of a rush. is it correct?
- Assistant
Your advice contains valuable information, but the explanations and examples could be more precise and standardized to avoid confusion. Here’s a revised version that may help your student understand these grammar points better:
-
Commute: Refers to the journey to work.
- Example: "I have a very long commute to work."
-
Get on/off the train/bus/tram: Refers to the action of entering (getting on) or leaving (getting off) public transportation.
- Example: "I need to get on the train." (I need to take the train.)
- Example: "I got on the train at 8 AM." (I boarded the train at 8 AM.)
-
Cluttered: Not well organized or messy.
- Example: "My desk is cluttered with papers and books."
-
Feeling stuck: Feeling unable to move forward or make progress.
- Example: "I feel stuck in my role at work."
-
No autonomy: Having no control or authority over your own actions or career.
- Example: "I have no autonomy in my job. I can't make any decisions on my own."
-
Prospects: Future opportunities or chances for success.
- Example: "John had limited prospects (opportunities) at his company."
-
Rewarding: Providing satisfaction or a sense of accomplishment.
- Example: "Sarah doesn't feel rewarded doing her job."
-
Not challenged; demotivated: Not feeling motivated because the work is not stimulating or challenging.
- Example: "I am not challenged at all, and as a result, I feel demotivated."
By presenting the information this way, you separate each concept clearly and provide examples that make the usage more apparent. This should help your student understand and remember the grammar points more effectively.
-
- User
but in English, as native speakers we informally say ' i need to get a bus' or 'i need to get a train'
- Assistant
You're right, native speakers often use informal language like "I need to get a bus" or "I need to get a train." It's important to teach ESL students both formal and informal expressions, as both are commonly used in everyday conversation. Here's a revised version that incorporates informal expressions as well:
-
Commute: Refers to the journey to work.
- Example: "I have a very long commute to work."
-
Get on/off the train/bus/tram: Refers to the action of entering (getting on) or leaving (getting off) public transportation.
- Example: "I need to get the train." (I need to take the train.)
- Example: "I got on the train at 8 AM." (I boarded the train at 8 AM.)
- Informal Example: "I need to get a bus." (I need to take a bus.)
-
Cluttered: Not well organized or messy.
- Example: "My desk is cluttered with papers and books."
-
Feeling stuck: Feeling unable to move forward or make progress.
- Example: "I feel stuck in my role at work."
-
No autonomy: Having no control or authority over your own actions or career.
- Example: "I have no autonomy in my job. I can't make any decisions on my own."
-
Prospects: Future opportunities or chances for success.
- Example: "John had limited prospects (opportunities) at his company."
-
Rewarding: Providing satisfaction or a sense of accomplishment.
- Example: "Sarah doesn't feel rewarded doing her job."
-
Not challenged; demotivated: Not feeling motivated because the work is not stimulating or challenging.
- Example: "I am not challenged at all, and as a result, I feel demotivated."
This approach should provide your student with a comprehensive understanding of both the formal and informal ways to express these concepts in English.
-
- User
what about this:
""I ‘get on’ (arrive) the train. I ‘got on’ (arrived) the train.""
i was trying to explain it very simply to the student as she struggles with 'get'
- Assistant
It's a good idea to keep your explanations simple, especially for students who struggle with certain verbs like "get." However, the phrases "I 'get on' (arrive) the train" and "I 'got on' (arrived) the train" are a bit confusing because "get on" doesn't mean "arrive."
Here’s a clearer way to explain it:
-
Get on the train/bus/tram: To board or enter the vehicle.
- Present tense: "I get on the train at 8 AM." (Meaning: I board the train at 8 AM.)
- Past tense: "I got on the train at 8 AM." (Meaning: I boarded the train at 8 AM.)
-
Arrive: To reach a destination.
- Example: "I arrive at the train station at 8 AM."
- Example: "I arrived at the train station at 8 AM."
To structure the explanation effectively:
- Focus on the specific action "get on" (boarding/entering).
- Use simple and clear examples.
It might also be helpful to explain that "get" can have different meanings based on the context, and suggest focusing on "get on" and "get off" for transportation.
Here is the revised version:
-
Get on the train/bus/tram: To board or enter the vehicle.
- Present tense: "I get on the train at 8 AM." (Meaning: I board the train at 8 AM.)
- Past tense: "I got on the train at 8 AM." (Meaning: I boarded the train at 8 AM.)
-
Get off the train/bus/tram: To leave or exit the vehicle.
- Present tense: "I get off the train at my stop."
- Past tense: "I got off the bus at 9th Street."
This way, your student can clearly understand the use and meaning of "get on" and "get off" in the context of transportation.
-