Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-05-13· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

what are some issues or biases with bgg rating system?

  1. User

    what are some issues or biases with bgg rating system?

  2. Assistant

    The BoardGameGeek (BGG) rating system is a widely used and respected metric within the board gaming community, but it does have some issues and biases that can impact its effectiveness and fairness. Here are some key concerns:

    1. Popularity Bias: Popular games tend to receive more ratings and reviews, which can skew their ratings upwards simply due to more visibility and broader appeal. Less well-known, niche, or indie games might struggle to get enough ratings to be fairly represented.

    2. Survivorship Bias: Games that remain popular and are continuously played tend to receive more ratings, while less successful games might drop off and not get rated as frequently. This can lead to higher overall ratings for games that have stood the test of time.

    3. Reviewer Self-Selection: People who rate games on BGG are typically more passionate and involved in the hobby. This self-selection can lead to ratings that are not reflective of the more casual or mainstream audience’s opinions.

    4. First-Impression Bias: Ratings are often based on initial impressions rather than long-term play. A game might receive high ratings at launch due to hype, but these ratings might not accurately reflect its quality after the initial excitement wears off.

    5. Complexity Bias: Heavier, more complex games often receive higher ratings from the BGG community, which tends to favor serious gamers. This can result in lighter, family-friendly games being underrated despite their appeal to a different segment of the audience.

    6. Demographic Bias: The BGG user base tends to be predominantly male and from specific regions (e.g., North America and Europe). This can lead to ratings that reflect the preferences of this demographic, potentially overlooking games that might be popular in other regions or among different groups of people.

    7. Rating Inflation: Over time, the overall average of BGG ratings tends to drift upwards. This rating inflation can make it difficult to evaluate newer games against older ones, as newer games might appear to have artificially high scores.

    8. Strategic Rating: Users might rate games strategically to influence their ranking, either to boost their favorite games or to lower the ranking of games they dislike. This can distort the system and reduce the reliability of the ratings.

    9. Sample Size Variability: The number of ratings can vary drastically between games, making it hard to compare them fairly. A game with thousands of ratings might have a more stable and reliable score compared to one with only a few dozen ratings.

    10. Weighted Ratings System: BGG uses a Bayesian average to help moderate the ratings, especially for games with fewer ratings. While this helps to some extent, it can still disadvantage newer or less-known games, which might never rise in the rankings due to low initial rating counts.

    These issues suggest that while BGG ratings can be a useful guide, they should be interpreted with an understanding of their inherent biases and limitations. It’s often helpful to read reviews and discussion threads in addition to looking at the numerical ratings to get a more comprehensive view of a game's quality and appeal.

  3. User

    how can I minimize the effects the Popularity Bias, Survivorship Bias, Reviewer Self-Selection, First-Impression Bias, Complexity Bias, Demographic Bias, Rating Inflation, Strategic Rating and Sample Size Variability in order to use the bgg website to fairly pit games against each only using the tools on the website(filters)?

  4. Assistant

    Minimizing the effects of various biases and using BoardGameGeek (BGG) tools effectively require a multi-faceted approach. Here are strategies for each concern using BGG filters and tools available:

    1. Popularity Bias & Sample Size Variability:

      • Use the "Number of Votes" filter to set a minimum threshold for the number of ratings a game should have. This helps ensure you are comparing games that have a reasonable volume of feedback.
      • Check the "Hotness" and "Trending" lists sparingly as these are often driven by what’s currently popular.
    2. Survivorship Bias:

      • Look at recent release dates to give newer games a fair chance. Filter by publish year or add a range to consider games released in the past few years.
      • Explore different categories or niches by using the "Category" and "Mechanics" filters. This helps uncover games that might not be evergreen hits but are appreciated within specific circles.
    3. Reviewer Self-Selection:

      • Read both highly-rated and lower-rated reviews to get a broader sense of opinions. BGG’s review and comment sections often provide context that numerical ratings alone do not.
      • Filter by community recommendations and "GeekLists" to see what other users with similar tastes have aggregated or recommended.
    4. First-Impression Bias:

      • Look at "Average Rating" combined with "Standard Deviation" or "Rating Distribution." Games with high ratings but high standard deviations might indicate polarized opinions based on first impressions.
      • Consider the "Played" and "Own" statistics to see if a game is not only being rated but continuously enjoyed over time.
    5. Complexity Bias:

      • Use the "Weight" filter to separate games by their complexity. This helps in comparing games within the same complexity range, e.g., light games with light games, heavy games with heavy games.
      • Utilize the "Family," "Strategy," and "Party" filters, which can separate games by type and intended audience.
    6. Demographic Bias:

      • Look for international editions or translations, which might indicate broader appeal across different regions.
      • Engage with the international forums and sub-communities on BGG to get perspectives from a more diverse user base.
    7. Rating Inflation:

      • Compare "Average Rating" against "Geek Rating." BGG’s Geek Rating uses Bayesian averaging to mitigate inflation to some extent.
      • Pay attention to historical ratings and trends over time (accessible in the game’s detailed rating breakdown) to detect any significant changes in perception.
    8. Strategic Rating:

      • Use median ratings or consider recommendations from trusted community contributors. Long-form reviews and recommendations from well-regarded community members can provide a more balanced view.
      • Pay attention to the detailed rating breakdowns to spot abnormal patterns that might suggest strategic rating.
    9. Demographic Bias:

      • Investigate lists and threads focused on underrepresented groups, like "Games Designed by Women" or "Non-Western Games." This exposes you to games that might otherwise be overlooked.
      • Explore sub-forums or guilds that focus on diverse perspectives and gaming cultures.

    Steps to Use On BGG:

    1. Advanced Search Filters:

      • Use the advanced search feature to apply multiple filters like minimum number of votes, game complexity, categories, and publication year.
    2. Sorting Options:

      • Sort games by "Geek Rating" instead of "Average Rating" to account for Bayesian adjustments.
      • Sort by "Number of Ratings" or "Rating Trend" to identify games that are becoming more or less popular over time.
    3. Explore GeekLists and Forums:

      • Engage with curated lists (GeekLists) created by users that highlight hidden gems or provide thematic recommendations.
      • Participate in forums to uncover games appreciated within specific communities or get qualitative insights that numbers might miss.
    4. Check Detailed Rating Data:

      • Inspect the rating breakdown and trend charts available on each game’s page to better understand how a game’s reception has evolved over time.

    By using a combination of these tools and approaches, you can mitigate the various biases and make more informed comparisons among games, leading to fairer evaluations and selections.

  5. User

    how can i use these filters to solve the biases? Title Designer Designer Cancel Instant Search Publisher/Manufacturer Publisher/Manufacturer Cancel Instant Search Year Released Range Year Released Minimum to Year Released Maximum Minimum Age Average User Rating Range Values 1 to 10 Average User Rating Minimum (1 to 10) to Average User Rating Maximum (1 to 10) with at least Minimum Number of Ratings user ratings Average Gameplay Weight Range Values 1 (Light) to 5 (Heavy) Average Gameplay Weight Minimum (1 light to 5 heavy) to Average Gameplay Weight Maximum (1 light to 5 heavy) with at least Minimum Number of Weight Ratings user weight ratings Filter by Collection Not Filtered None Owned by User Owned Rated by User Rated Specify User: Filter Expansions Exclude Expansions Click to NOT search expansions

    of Players Range

    Minimum Number of Players to Maximum Number of Players Normal (include all games for this range) Exact (include games that only support exactly this range) Min Playing Time (games will take at least this long) Max Playing Time (games will take at most this long) Board Game Category Filter on Board Game Category » ( + for include, - for exclude ) [+] Include Abstract Strategy Abstract Strategy [-] Exclude Abstract Strategy [+] Include Action / Dexterity Action / Dexterity [-] Exclude Action / Dexterity [+] Include Adventure Adventure [-] Exclude Adventure [+] Include Age of Reason Age of Reason [-] Exclude Age of Reason [+] Include American Civil War American Civil War [-] Exclude American Civil War [+] Include American Indian Wars American Indian Wars [-] Exclude American Indian Wars [+] Include American Revolutionary War American Revolutionary War [-] Exclude American Revolutionary War [+] Include American West American West [-] Exclude American West [+] Include Ancient Ancient [-] Exclude Ancient [+] Include Animals Animals [-] Exclude Animals [+] Include Arabian Arabian [-] Exclude Arabian [+] Include Aviation / Flight Aviation / Flight [-] Exclude Aviation / Flight [+] Include Bluffing Bluffing [-] Exclude Bluffing [+] Include Book Book [-] Exclude Book [+] Include Card Game Card Game [-] Exclude Card Game [+] Include Children's Game Children's Game [-] Exclude Children's Game [+] Include City Building City Building [-] Exclude City Building [+] Include Civil War Civil War [-] Exclude Civil War [+] Include Civilization Civilization [-] Exclude Civilization [+] Include Collectible Components Collectible Components [-] Exclude Collectible Components [+] Include Comic Book / Strip Comic Book / Strip [-] Exclude Comic Book / Strip [+] Include Deduction Deduction [-] Exclude Deduction [+] Include Dice Dice [-] Exclude Dice [+] Include Economic Economic [-] Exclude Economic [+] Include Educational Educational [-] Exclude Educational [+] Include Electronic Electronic [-] Exclude Electronic [+] Include Environmental Environmental [-] Exclude Environmental [+] Include Expansion for Base-game Expansion for Base-game [-] Exclude Expansion for Base-game [+] Include Exploration Exploration [-] Exclude Exploration [+] Include Fan Expansion Fan Expansion [-] Exclude Fan Expansion [+] Include Fantasy Fantasy [-] Exclude Fantasy [+] Include Farming Farming [-] Exclude Farming [+] Include Fighting Fighting [-] Exclude Fighting [+] Include Game System Game System [-] Exclude Game System [+] Include Horror Horror [-] Exclude Horror [+] Include Humor Humor [-] Exclude Humor [+] Include Industry / Manufacturing Industry / Manufacturing [-] Exclude Industry / Manufacturing [+] Include Korean War Korean War [-] Exclude Korean War [+] Include Mafia Mafia [-] Exclude Mafia [+] Include Math Math [-] Exclude Math [+] Include Mature / Adult Mature / Adult [-] Exclude Mature / Adult [+] Include Maze Maze [-] Exclude Maze [+] Include Medical Medical [-] Exclude Medical [+] Include Medieval Medieval [-] Exclude Medieval [+] Include Memory Memory [-] Exclude Memory [+] Include Miniatures Miniatures [-] Exclude Miniatures [+] Include Modern Warfare Modern Warfare [-] Exclude Modern Warfare [+] Include Movies / TV / Radio theme Movies / TV / Radio theme [-] Exclude Movies / TV / Radio theme [+] Include Murder/Mystery Murder/Mystery [-] Exclude Murder/Mystery [+] Include Music Music [-] Exclude Music [+] Include Mythology Mythology [-] Exclude Mythology [+] Include Napoleonic Napoleonic [-] Exclude Napoleonic [+] Include Nautical Nautical [-] Exclude Nautical [+] Include Negotiation Negotiation [-] Exclude Negotiation [+] Include Novel-based Novel-based [-] Exclude Novel-based [+] Include Number Number [-] Exclude Number [+] Include Party Game Party Game [-] Exclude Party Game [+] Include Pike and Shot Pike and Shot [-] Exclude Pike and Shot [+] Include Pirates Pirates [-] Exclude Pirates [+] Include Political Political [-] Exclude Political [+] Include Post-Napoleonic Post-Napoleonic [-] Exclude Post-Napoleonic [+] Include Prehistoric Prehistoric [-] Exclude Prehistoric [+] Include Print & Play Print & Play [-] Exclude Print & Play [+] Include Puzzle Puzzle [-] Exclude Puzzle [+] Include Racing Racing [-] Exclude Racing [+] Include Real-time Real-time [-] Exclude Real-time [+] Include Religious Religious [-] Exclude Religious [+] Include Renaissance Renaissance [-] Exclude Renaissance [+] Include Science Fiction Science Fiction [-] Exclude Science Fiction [+] Include Space Exploration Space Exploration [-] Exclude Space Exploration [+] Include Spies/Secret Agents Spies/Secret Agents [-] Exclude Spies/Secret Agents [+] Include Sports Sports [-] Exclude Sports [+] Include Territory Building Territory Building [-] Exclude Territory Building [+] Include Trains Trains [-] Exclude Trains [+] Include Transportation Transportation [-] Exclude Transportation [+] Include Travel Travel [-] Exclude Travel [+] Include Trivia Trivia [-] Exclude Trivia [+] Include Video Game Theme Video Game Theme [-] Exclude Video Game Theme [+] Include Vietnam War Vietnam War [-] Exclude Vietnam War [+] Include Wargame Wargame [-] Exclude Wargame [+] Include Word Game Word Game [-] Exclude Word Game [+] Include World War I World War I [-] Exclude World War I [+] Include World War II World War II [-] Exclude World War II [+] Include Zombies Zombies [-] Exclude Zombies Board Game Mechanic Filter on Board Game Mechanic » ( + for include, - for exclude ) [+] Include Acting Acting [-] Exclude Acting [+] Include Action Drafting Action Drafting [-] Exclude Action Drafting [+] Include Action Points Action Points [-] Exclude Action Points [+] Include Action Queue Action Queue [-] Exclude Action Queue [+] Include Action Retrieval Action Retrieval [-] Exclude Action Retrieval [+] Include Action Timer Action Timer [-] Exclude Action Timer [+] Include Action/Event Action/Event [-] Exclude Action/Event [+] Include Advantage Token Advantage Token [-] Exclude Advantage Token [+] Include Alliances Alliances [-] Exclude Alliances [+] Include Area Majority / Influence Area Majority / Influence [-] Exclude Area Majority / Influence [+] Include Area Movement Area Movement [-] Exclude Area Movement [+] Include Area-Impulse Area-Impulse [-] Exclude Area-Impulse [+] Include Auction Compensation Auction Compensation [-] Exclude Auction Compensation [+] Include Auction: Dexterity Auction: Dexterity [-] Exclude Auction: Dexterity [+] Include Auction: Dutch Auction: Dutch [-] Exclude Auction: Dutch [+] Include Auction: Dutch Priority Auction: Dutch Priority [-] Exclude Auction: Dutch Priority [+] Include Auction: English Auction: English [-] Exclude Auction: English [+] Include Auction: Fixed Placement Auction: Fixed Placement [-] Exclude Auction: Fixed Placement [+] Include Auction: Multiple Lot Auction: Multiple Lot [-] Exclude Auction: Multiple Lot [+] Include Auction: Once Around Auction: Once Around [-] Exclude Auction: Once Around [+] Include Auction: Sealed Bid Auction: Sealed Bid [-] Exclude Auction: Sealed Bid [+] Include Auction: Turn Order Until Pass Auction: Turn Order Until Pass [-] Exclude Auction: Turn Order Until Pass [+] Include Auction/Bidding Auction/Bidding [-] Exclude Auction/Bidding [+] Include Automatic Resource Growth Automatic Resource Growth [-] Exclude Automatic Resource Growth [+] Include Betting and Bluffing Betting and Bluffing [-] Exclude Betting and Bluffing [+] Include Bias Bias [-] Exclude Bias [+] Include Bids As Wagers Bids As Wagers [-] Exclude Bids As Wagers [+] Include Bingo Bingo [-] Exclude Bingo [+] Include Bribery Bribery [-] Exclude Bribery [+] Include Campaign / Battle Card Driven Campaign / Battle Card Driven [-] Exclude Campaign / Battle Card Driven [+] Include Card Play Conflict Resolution Card Play Conflict Resolution [-] Exclude Card Play Conflict Resolution [+] Include Catch the Leader Catch the Leader [-] Exclude Catch the Leader [+] Include Chaining Chaining [-] Exclude Chaining [+] Include Chit-Pull System Chit-Pull System [-] Exclude Chit-Pull System [+] Include Closed Drafting Closed Drafting [-] Exclude Closed Drafting [+] Include Closed Economy Auction Closed Economy Auction [-] Exclude Closed Economy Auction [+] Include Command Cards Command Cards [-] Exclude Command Cards [+] Include Commodity Speculation Commodity Speculation [-] Exclude Commodity Speculation [+] Include Communication Limits Communication Limits [-] Exclude Communication Limits [+] Include Connections Connections [-] Exclude Connections [+] Include Constrained Bidding Constrained Bidding [-] Exclude Constrained Bidding [+] Include Contracts Contracts [-] Exclude Contracts [+] Include Cooperative Game Cooperative Game [-] Exclude Cooperative Game [+] Include Crayon Rail System Crayon Rail System [-] Exclude Crayon Rail System [+] Include Critical Hits and Failures Critical Hits and Failures [-] Exclude Critical Hits and Failures [+] Include Cube Tower Cube Tower [-] Exclude Cube Tower [+] Include Deck Construction Deck Construction [-] Exclude Deck Construction [+] Include Deck, Bag, and Pool Building Deck, Bag, and Pool Building [-] Exclude Deck, Bag, and Pool Building [+] Include Deduction Deduction [-] Exclude Deduction [+] Include Delayed Purchase Delayed Purchase [-] Exclude Delayed Purchase [+] Include Dice Rolling Dice Rolling [-] Exclude Dice Rolling [+] Include Die Icon Resolution Die Icon Resolution [-] Exclude Die Icon Resolution [+] Include Different Dice Movement Different Dice Movement [-] Exclude Different Dice Movement [+] Include Drawing Drawing [-] Exclude Drawing [+] Include Elapsed Real Time Ending Elapsed Real Time Ending [-] Exclude Elapsed Real Time Ending [+] Include Enclosure Enclosure [-] Exclude Enclosure [+] Include End Game Bonuses End Game Bonuses [-] Exclude End Game Bonuses [+] Include Events Events [-] Exclude Events [+] Include Finale Ending Finale Ending [-] Exclude Finale Ending [+] Include Flicking Flicking [-] Exclude Flicking [+] Include Follow Follow [-] Exclude Follow [+] Include Force Commitment Force Commitment [-] Exclude Force Commitment [+] Include Grid Coverage Grid Coverage [-] Exclude Grid Coverage [+] Include Grid Movement Grid Movement [-] Exclude Grid Movement [+] Include Hand Management Hand Management [-] Exclude Hand Management [+] Include Hexagon Grid Hexagon Grid [-] Exclude Hexagon Grid [+] Include Hidden Movement Hidden Movement [-] Exclude Hidden Movement [+] Include Hidden Roles Hidden Roles [-] Exclude Hidden Roles [+] Include Hidden Victory Points Hidden Victory Points [-] Exclude Hidden Victory Points [+] Include Highest-Lowest Scoring Highest-Lowest Scoring [-] Exclude Highest-Lowest Scoring [+] Include Hot Potato Hot Potato [-] Exclude Hot Potato [+] Include I Cut, You Choose I Cut, You Choose [-] Exclude I Cut, You Choose [+] Include Impulse Movement Impulse Movement [-] Exclude Impulse Movement [+] Include Income Income [-] Exclude Income [+] Include Increase Value of Unchosen Resources Increase Value of Unchosen Resources [-] Exclude Increase Value of Unchosen Resources [+] Include Induction Induction [-] Exclude Induction [+] Include Interrupts Interrupts [-] Exclude Interrupts [+] Include Investment Investment [-] Exclude Investment [+] Include Kill Steal Kill Steal [-] Exclude Kill Steal [+] Include King of the Hill King of the Hill [-] Exclude King of the Hill [+] Include Ladder Climbing Ladder Climbing [-] Exclude Ladder Climbing [+] Include Layering Layering [-] Exclude Layering [+] Include Legacy Game Legacy Game [-] Exclude Legacy Game [+] Include Line Drawing Line Drawing [-] Exclude Line Drawing [+] Include Line of Sight Line of Sight [-] Exclude Line of Sight [+] Include Loans Loans [-] Exclude Loans [+] Include Lose a Turn Lose a Turn [-] Exclude Lose a Turn [+] Include Mancala Mancala [-] Exclude Mancala [+] Include Map Addition Map Addition [-] Exclude Map Addition [+] Include Map Deformation Map Deformation [-] Exclude Map Deformation [+] Include Map Reduction Map Reduction [-] Exclude Map Reduction [+] Include Market Market [-] Exclude Market [+] Include Matching Matching [-] Exclude Matching [+] Include Measurement Movement Measurement Movement [-] Exclude Measurement Movement [+] Include Melding and Splaying Melding and Splaying [-] Exclude Melding and Splaying [+] Include Memory Memory [-] Exclude Memory [+] Include Minimap Resolution Minimap Resolution [-] Exclude Minimap Resolution [+] Include Modular Board Modular Board [-] Exclude Modular Board [+] Include Move Through Deck Move Through Deck [-] Exclude Move Through Deck [+] Include Movement Points Movement Points [-] Exclude Movement Points [+] Include Movement Template Movement Template [-] Exclude Movement Template [+] Include Moving Multiple Units Moving Multiple Units [-] Exclude Moving Multiple Units [+] Include Multi-Use Cards Multi-Use Cards [-] Exclude Multi-Use Cards [+] Include Multiple Maps Multiple Maps [-] Exclude Multiple Maps [+] Include Narrative Choice / Paragraph Narrative Choice / Paragraph [-] Exclude Narrative Choice / Paragraph [+] Include Negotiation Negotiation [-] Exclude Negotiation [+] Include Neighbor Scope Neighbor Scope [-] Exclude Neighbor Scope [+] Include Network and Route Building Network and Route Building [-] Exclude Network and Route Building [+] Include Once-Per-Game Abilities Once-Per-Game Abilities [-] Exclude Once-Per-Game Abilities [+] Include Open Drafting Open Drafting [-] Exclude Open Drafting [+] Include Order Counters Order Counters [-] Exclude Order Counters [+] Include Ordering Ordering [-] Exclude Ordering [+] Include Ownership Ownership [-] Exclude Ownership [+] Include Paper-and-Pencil Paper-and-Pencil [-] Exclude Paper-and-Pencil [+] Include Passed Action Token Passed Action Token [-] Exclude Passed Action Token [+] Include Pattern Building Pattern Building [-] Exclude Pattern Building [+] Include Pattern Movement Pattern Movement [-] Exclude Pattern Movement [+] Include Pattern Recognition Pattern Recognition [-] Exclude Pattern Recognition [+] Include Physical Removal Physical Removal [-] Exclude Physical Removal [+] Include Pick-up and Deliver Pick-up and Deliver [-] Exclude Pick-up and Deliver [+] Include Pieces as Map Pieces as Map [-] Exclude Pieces as Map [+] Include Player Elimination Player Elimination [-] Exclude Player Elimination [+] Include Player Judge Player Judge [-] Exclude Player Judge [+] Include Point to Point Movement Point to Point Movement [-] Exclude Point to Point Movement [+] Include Predictive Bid Predictive Bid [-] Exclude Predictive Bid [+] Include Prisoner's Dilemma Prisoner's Dilemma [-] Exclude Prisoner's Dilemma [+] Include Programmed Movement Programmed Movement [-] Exclude Programmed Movement [+] Include Push Your Luck Push Your Luck [-] Exclude Push Your Luck [+] Include Questions and Answers Questions and Answers [-] Exclude Questions and Answers [+] Include Race Race [-] Exclude Race [+] Include Random Production Random Production [-] Exclude Random Production [+] Include Ratio / Combat Results Table Ratio / Combat Results Table [-] Exclude Ratio / Combat Results Table [+] Include Re-rolling and Locking Re-rolling and Locking [-] Exclude Re-rolling and Locking [+] Include Real-Time Real-Time [-] Exclude Real-Time [+] Include Relative Movement Relative Movement [-] Exclude Relative Movement [+] Include Resource Queue Resource Queue [-] Exclude Resource Queue [+] Include Resource to Move Resource to Move [-] Exclude Resource to Move [+] Include Rock-Paper-Scissors Rock-Paper-Scissors [-] Exclude Rock-Paper-Scissors [+] Include Role Playing Role Playing [-] Exclude Role Playing [+] Include Roles with Asymmetric Information Roles with Asymmetric Information [-] Exclude Roles with Asymmetric Information [+] Include Roll / Spin and Move Roll / Spin and Move [-] Exclude Roll / Spin and Move [+] Include Rondel Rondel [-] Exclude Rondel [+] Include Scenario / Mission / Campaign Game Scenario / Mission / Campaign Game [-] Exclude Scenario / Mission / Campaign Game [+] Include Score-and-Reset Game Score-and-Reset Game [-] Exclude Score-and-Reset Game [+] Include Secret Unit Deployment Secret Unit Deployment [-] Exclude Secret Unit Deployment [+] Include Selection Order Bid Selection Order Bid [-] Exclude Selection Order Bid [+] Include Semi-Cooperative Game Semi-Cooperative Game [-] Exclude Semi-Cooperative Game [+] Include Set Collection Set Collection [-] Exclude Set Collection [+] Include Simulation Simulation [-] Exclude Simulation [+] Include Simultaneous Action Selection Simultaneous Action Selection [-] Exclude Simultaneous Action Selection [+] Include Singing Singing [-] Exclude Singing [+] Include Single Loser Game Single Loser Game [-] Exclude Single Loser Game [+] Include Slide/Push Slide/Push [-] Exclude Slide/Push [+] Include Solo / Solitaire Game Solo / Solitaire Game [-] Exclude Solo / Solitaire Game [+] Include Speed Matching Speed Matching [-] Exclude Speed Matching [+] Include Spelling Spelling [-] Exclude Spelling [+] Include Square Grid Square Grid [-] Exclude Square Grid [+] Include Stacking and Balancing Stacking and Balancing [-] Exclude Stacking and Balancing [+] Include Stat Check Resolution Stat Check Resolution [-] Exclude Stat Check Resolution [+] Include Static Capture Static Capture [-] Exclude Static Capture [+] Include Stock Holding Stock Holding [-] Exclude Stock Holding [+] Include Storytelling Storytelling [-] Exclude Storytelling [+] Include Sudden Death Ending Sudden Death Ending [-] Exclude Sudden Death Ending [+] Include Tags Tags [-] Exclude Tags [+] Include Take That Take That [-] Exclude Take That [+] Include Targeted Clues Targeted Clues [-] Exclude Targeted Clues [+] Include Team-Based Game Team-Based Game [-] Exclude Team-Based Game [+] Include Tech Trees / Tech Tracks Tech Trees / Tech Tracks [-] Exclude Tech Trees / Tech Tracks [+] Include Three Dimensional Movement Three Dimensional Movement [-] Exclude Three Dimensional Movement [+] Include Tile Placement Tile Placement [-] Exclude Tile Placement [+] Include Track Movement Track Movement [-] Exclude Track Movement [+] Include Trading Trading [-] Exclude Trading [+] Include Traitor Game Traitor Game [-] Exclude Traitor Game [+] Include Trick-taking Trick-taking [-] Exclude Trick-taking [+] Include Tug of War Tug of War [-] Exclude Tug of War [+] Include Turn Order: Auction Turn Order: Auction [-] Exclude Turn Order: Auction [+] Include Turn Order: Claim Action Turn Order: Claim Action [-] Exclude Turn Order: Claim Action [+] Include Turn Order: Pass Order Turn Order: Pass Order [-] Exclude Turn Order: Pass Order [+] Include Turn Order: Progressive Turn Order: Progressive [-] Exclude Turn Order: Progressive [+] Include Turn Order: Random Turn Order: Random [-] Exclude Turn Order: Random [+] Include Turn Order: Role Order Turn Order: Role Order [-] Exclude Turn Order: Role Order [+] Include Turn Order: Stat-Based Turn Order: Stat-Based [-] Exclude Turn Order: Stat-Based [+] Include Turn Order: Time Track Turn Order: Time Track [-] Exclude Turn Order: Time Track [+] Include Variable Phase Order Variable Phase Order [-] Exclude Variable Phase Order [+] Include Variable Player Powers Variable Player Powers [-] Exclude Variable Player Powers [+] Include Variable Set-up Variable Set-up [-] Exclude Variable Set-up [+] Include Victory Points as a Resource Victory Points as a Resource [-] Exclude Victory Points as a Resource [+] Include Voting Voting [-] Exclude Voting [+] Include Worker Placement Worker Placement [-] Exclude Worker Placement [+] Include Worker Placement with Dice Workers Worker Placement with Dice Workers [-] Exclude Worker Placement with Dice Workers [+] Include Worker Placement, Different Worker Types Worker Placement, Different Worker Types [-] Exclude Worker Placement, Different Worker Types [+] Include Zone of Control Zone of Control [-] Exclude Zone of Control Board Game Subdomain Filter on Board Game Subdomain » ( + for include, - for exclude ) [+] Include Abstract Games Abstract Games [-] Exclude Abstract Games [+] Include Children's Games Children's Games [-] Exclude Children's Games [+] Include Customizable Games Customizable Games [-] Exclude Customizable Games [+] Include Family Games Family Games [-] Exclude Family Games [+] Include Party Games Party Games [-] Exclude Party Games [+] Include Strategy Games Strategy Games [-] Exclude Strategy Games [+] Include Thematic Games Thematic Games [-] Exclude Thematic Games [+] Include Wargames Wargames [-] Exclude Wargames

  6. Assistant

    To effectively use the BoardGameGeek (BGG) search filters to minimize the various biases you mentioned, it's essential to apply relevant filters strategically and thoughtfully. Here's how you can use the available filters to address each of these biases:

    1. Popularity Bias:

      • Number of Ratings: Set a minimum threshold for the number of ratings to consider games that have received adequate community feedback to be fairly evaluated. For example, set "with at least 500 user ratings."
      • Categories and Mechanics: Explore niche categories and mechanics to discover less popular, yet high-quality games.
    2. Survivorship Bias:

      • Year Released Range: By narrowing the release years, you can avoid heavily rating older, well-established games disproportionately. For example, filter for games released in the last 5 years.
      • Combination of Categories: Explore games from underrepresented categories or newer themes which haven’t stood the test of time yet but might be innovative.
    3. Reviewer Self-Selection:

      • User-Specific Filters: Use the "Rated by User" and specify users you trust for more diverse opinions, especially those with varied tastes.
      • Reading Reviews: While not a filter, read detailed reviews and ratings comments to gain insights beyond numerical ratings.
    4. First-Impression Bias:

      • Number of Ratings and Average User Rating: Ensure games have a substantial number of ratings before considering them for comparison. This helps balance out initial hype effects.
      • Look at Standard Deviation: While not directly available in filters, use the ratings breakdown on individual game pages to understand wide-ranging initial impressions.
    5. Complexity Bias:

      • Average Gameplay Weight: Use the "Average Gameplay Weight Range" to search games of similar complexity. For example, filter games in the range of 1.5 to 2.5 for light games.
      • Categories: Filter based on the “Family Games,” “Children's Games,” or “Party Games” subdomains to specifically find lighter games.
    6. Demographic Bias:

      • Publisher/Manufacturer Filters: Explore games from publishers known for targeting diverse audiences.
      • Categories Reflecting Diverse Cultures: Include categories that might represent a broader demographic (e.g., "Mythology", "World War II", or "American Indian Wars").
    7. Rating Inflation:

      • Average User Rating Minimum: Instead of only looking at top-rated games, set a reasonable lower bound, such as 7 or 7.5, to avoid current rating inflation trends.
      • Combining with Number of Ratings: Ensure you're considering games with sufficient ratings to balance the effect of inflated ratings.
    8. Strategic Rating:

      • Minimum Number of Ratings: Games strategically rated will show inflated scores initially. Setting a higher minimum threshold for ratings helps mitigate this.
      • Read Detailed Reviews: This again emphasizes the qualitative aspects of the user feedback, providing context to seemingly perfect scores.

    Using the Filters to Solve Biases - Step-by-Step Example:

    Let's say you're looking to pit recent, medium-weight strategy games against each other while avoiding the above biases:

    1. Minimum Number of Ratings:

      • Set "with at least 500 user ratings" to ensure a robust sampling.
    2. Year Released Range:

      • Filter the "Year Released Range" to the last 5 years (e.g., 2018-2023).
    3. Average User Rating:

      • Set the rating range between 7 and 9 to consider all good to excellent games and avoid overly hyped or inflated scores.
    4. Average Gameplay Weight Range:

      • Set the weight range between 2.5 to 3.5 for medium-weight games.
    5. Categories:

      • Include "Strategy Games" and "Thematic Games" to focus on categories relevant to your interest.
      • Explore additional categories like "Economic" and "City Building" if those themes appeal to you.
    6. Subdomains:

      • Include “Strategy Games” and exclude “Children’s Games” and “Party Games” to filter out games that aren't within your desired complexity or core type.
    7. Publisher/Manufacturer:

      • If you're interested in diversity, filter or select publishers known for wide cultural representation.

    Application Example:

    Popularity Bias & Sample Size:

    • Minimum Number of Ratings: 500+

    Survivorship Bias:

    • Year Released: 2018-2023

    Reviewer Self-Selection:

    • Check and follow reviews from users you respect or those known for diverse tastes.

    First-Impression Bias & Rating Inflation:

    • Average User Rating: 7-9

    Complexity Bias:

    • Average Gameplay Weight: 2.5-3.5

    Demographic Bias:

    • Include various interesting categories
    • Include multiple relevant subdomains

    Strategic Rating:

    • Minimum number of reviews again acts as a guard here.

    By thoughtfully combining these filters, you can create a more balanced comparison set, minimizing the bias effects and ensuring a fairer pit against each game.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.