Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-05-13· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

‘9. Overall, the description of Methods is fine, but I find it hard to understand the…

  1. User

    ‘9. Overall, the description of Methods is fine, but I find it hard to understand the innovation of the proposed workflow. It seems more of a stack of various methods. Also, can a workflow be considered as a methodology in the first place?

    Response: Thank you! 谢谢您宝贵的反馈,我们向我们的表述不清进行道歉!事实上,我们提出的并不是一个workflow而是一个模型或者说方法,里面不同的模块是深度神经网络构建的基本单元而非现有的城市功能建模中的深度学习方法,像SatMAE/Node2Vec/Deep&Wide modules均还未在城市功能识别任务上被引入。具体来说,现有研究的不足是:

    再次基础上,本文的动机是:

    为此,本文的创新点在于:

    为了让读者更加了解我们的研究,我们在返修稿中进行了大量的修改: 1)我们对摘要进行了重写,使得其言简意赅; 2)我们对Introduction进行了大量的修改,使得背景、研究现状、动机与贡献更加明确; 3)我们在Related work新增了对GeoAI in urban function modeling的现状进行综述; 4)在Section 3. Methodology部分,我们更加详细地描述了方法细节,同时反复强调我们建模的出发点与创新性; 5)此外,我们目前的实验以及结果均围绕说明我们创新点的有效性进行展开。 ’ 帮我用英文把response好好写一下,上面内容仅供参考,请你一定要围绕审稿人的意见进行response

  2. Assistant

    Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback! We apologize for any confusion in our initial explanation. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify our contribution further. Here, we address your concerns in detail:

    Firstly, regarding the innovation of the proposed workflow: In fact, we are not proposing a simple workflow but a comprehensive model or methodology. The different modules within our method are fundamental components constructed using deep neural networks, rather than merely stacked existing urban function modeling techniques. For instance, modules like SatMAE, Node2Vec, and Deep&Wide have not been previously introduced for urban function recognition tasks.

    To provide a clearer picture of our contributions, we have identified the following limitations in current research:

    Based on these observations, the motivation of our study is to address these gaps by proposing a novel approach that leverages advanced deep learning techniques in a cohesive manner.

    The key innovations of our work are:

    To enhance the clarity of our study and address your concerns comprehensively, we have made substantial revisions to the manuscript:

    1. We have rewritten the abstract to be more concise and precise, effectively summarizing our study's objectives and contributions.
    2. We have extensively revised the Introduction to clearly outline the background, current research landscape, our study's motivations, and contributions.
    3. In the Related Work section, we have added a comprehensive overview of the current state of GeoAI in urban function modeling.
    4. The Methodology section (Section 3) has been elaborated in greater detail, emphasizing the specifics of our methods and the innovative aspects of our modeling approach.
    5. Additionally, our experiments and results have been reframed to directly demonstrate and validate the effectiveness of our innovations.

    We hope these modifications address your concerns and provide a clear understanding of the novel contributions of our work. Thank you again for your constructive feedback.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.