Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-05-13· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

‘9. Overall, the description of Methods is fine, but I find it hard to understand the…

  1. User

    ‘9. Overall, the description of Methods is fine, but I find it hard to understand the innovation of the proposed workflow. It seems more of a stack of various methods. Also, can a workflow be considered as a methodology in the first place?

    Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback! We apologize for any confusion caused by our initial description. In fact, we are not proposing a simple workflow, but a comprehensive model or approach. The different modules within our model are fundamental components to build a deep neural network, rather than merely existing urban function modeling techniques. For instance, modules like SatMAE, Node2Vec, and Deep&Wide have not been previously introduced for urban function recognition tasks. To provide a clearer picture of our contributions, we have identified the following limitations in current research:

    Based on these observations, the motivation of our study is to address these gaps by proposing a novel approach that leverages advanced deep learning techniques in a cohesive manner.

    The key innovations of our work are:

    To enhance the clarity of our study and address your concerns comprehensively, we have made substantial revisions to the manuscript:

    1. We have rewritten the abstract to be more concise and precise, effectively summarizing our study’s objectives and contributions.
    2. We have extensively revised the Introduction to clearly outline the background, current research landscape, our study’s motivations, and contributions.
    3. In the Related work section, we have added a comprehensive overview of the current state of GeoAI in urban function modeling.
    4. In Section 3, Methodology, we now provide more detailed descriptions of the methods used, while repeatedly emphasizing the rationale and innovative aspects behind our modeling approach.
    1. Additionally, Our experiments and results have been structured to directly illustrate the effectiveness of our innovations. ’ 帮我用英文把这response写的更加好些,一定要有效解决审稿人提出的问题
  2. Assistant

    Certainly! Here’s a revised and more polished version of your response, addressing the reviewer's comments in a clearer and more effective manner:


    Thank you for your valuable feedback. We apologize for any confusion our initial description may have caused. Our intention is not to present a mere workflow but rather a comprehensive model or approach. This model integrates various modules that are essential for constructing a deep neural network specifically tailored for urban function recognition. Modules such as SatMAE, Node2Vec, and Deep&Wide are novel in the context of urban function recognition and have not been employed previously for this purpose.

    To better illustrate our contributions, we have identified several limitations in current research, which include:

    1. [List the specific limitations identified in current research]

    Our study aims to address these gaps by introducing an innovative approach that harnesses advanced deep learning techniques in a cohesive and integrated manner.

    The key innovations of our work are:

    1. [Clearly state the key innovations of your approach]

    To ensure that our study is more comprehensible and to directly address your concerns, we have made substantial revisions to our manuscript:

    1. Abstract: We have rewritten the abstract to be more concise and precise, effectively summarizing our study's objectives and contributions.
    2. Introduction: We have extensively revised the Introduction section to clearly outline the background, the current research landscape, our study’s motivations, and its contributions.
    3. Related Work: We have added a comprehensive overview of the current state of GeoAI in urban function modeling in the Related Work section.
    4. Methodology: In Section 3 (Methodology), we now provide more detailed descriptions of the methods used, emphasizing the rationale and innovative aspects behind our modeling approach.
    5. Experiments and Results: Our experiments and results have been structured to directly illustrate the effectiveness and advantages of our innovations.

    These revisions are aimed at clarifying our approach and demonstrating the novelty and significance of our contributions to urban function recognition using deep learning. We hope these changes address your concerns and offer a clearer understanding of our work.


    Please let us know if there are any other areas you would like us to address or further enhance.

    Thank you once again for your insightful feedback.


    Feel free to tweak further if there are any more details you'd like to include or adjust!