retain this info: We are delighted to be back with you. It's so good to see all of you…
- User
retain this info: We are delighted to be back with you. It's so good to see all of you with us here, and we have a lot to talk about. So we had a lot of fun reading your first brainstorming submissions and really interested in the ideas you came up with and how you used artificial intelligence, and that was really, really fun. This coming week, we have a follow up brainstorming two assignment, and today's live session is going to be fairly heavily dedicated to thinking through the process we're going to use in that assignment. So this live session really connects quite closely with our second brainstorming assignment. So we're going to spend most of today on that. But before we get into that detail, I do want to mention that next week week three, We have our first live case study activity. So this is the blue light discussion or negotiation. We have matched you up with a partner so that you could engage in a role play negotiation. It's a super interesting and really fun activity. We've given you one of two roles, Gregg or Healy. You have a partner who has the complimentary role, and the two of you get to have a quick conversation where you see if you can come to some kind of agreement. Uh, maybe you can. Maybe you can, whatever it is. Whatever the outcome is, it's all good. And then there's a pre survey to help you get into your character and understand the situation and a post survey to have you just quickly report on the results of your discussion. So that's what's coming in Module three. I mentioned it now because some of that information is up on Canvas and about to be released. I think tomorrow, the pairings get released. And so as a result, it's a nice way to connect with your partner and set a time so that you can make sure you can really get the most out of this activity. It's really fun. We have a lot of fun talking about it. So I look forward to getting into all of that with you. Absolutely. So and then what we are going to do today is we're going to talk about, you know, jump into the process of creativity. That is what we're going to talk about. So, um, uh, you know, and essentially, you know, what we talked about last week, creativity, the process is mostly about changing perspective, and that is what we are going to focus on this. This week and going forward. That is what creative process would be about. But to start with, you know, when we talk about creativity, what are the outcome? Why are we get engaging in this process of creativity? That's an important thing. What's our objective here. So three main things. First is insights. You know, when we engage in creative process, the idea is, what are new insights we can draw from that process? What do we mean by insights? Insights are viable changes in perspective. So the thing is looking at things in a new perspective. That is what gives you an insight. Exactly. So we spent quite a bit of time in our first brainstorming activity. And part of what we were doing, right is trying to generate solutions. And you might think of those as inventions. Can I solve a problem? Can I create a process or a product that's a solution for the problem. But in order to get to that new product or process, that invention, we probably had to have some kind of insight. Hey, there's a new way to think about this problem in the first place. And so insights are the first outcome of interest as Robbie mentioned. Can I have an interesting change in perspective that might lead me to an invention? Sometimes it's one insight leads to an invention. I would say usually new product development, 1,000. This is a good point, Jeff, you're making here because insights may not always lead to an invention. When we talk about invention, that's a solution, a new product A insights may not lead to that, and then one insight might lead to another inside, and another inside, and then you might end up getting to an invention. But that is an important difference to remember that insights and inventions are different. Insights is just change perspective. Invention is an outcome of the whole creative process. Indeed. And so I think the really important thing to note is that there's no one to one correspondence. And also, you can have an insight for a change in perspective. And then it turns out it's not very good. It's not productive, it doesn't lead to an invention or it's not fruitful, and so you end up unwinding it, which is totally reasonable. Right? You didn't know that before you tried it, so you got to have the insight, and then maybe it leads to an invention, maybe not. Hopefully, the insights are useful. There is also a third outcome, and this one's a little bit different. So I have an insight to change our perspective. Maybe a couple insights help me get to a solution, an invention of some kind. But in addition to solutions, I can also generate as an outcome of my creative process, what we call enlighten. These are changes to knowledge, new concepts, new ideas. If you think about, I don't know, what's an idea, you've been thinking about. If you've taken 508, maybe you talked about psychological safety. Now, at some point, go back 50 years. No one was talking about psychological safety. That was not a thing in the 90s. Amy Edmonson and her colleagues came up with this idea of psychological safety. And now we talk about that. That's an enlightenment. It's not a solution. It's a new concept, and it's something that we can then use on in new perspectives to understand new situations and help us act in the world. I don't know, marketing is full of these too, right? Absolutely. The thing is enlightenment may not again, solve the problem. They might not lead to inventions. But the thing is they are in a broader sense, you know, they give you a new parad new weight of thinking it creates a body of knowledge. So, for example, you said, you know, about 50 years back. So we talked about brand personalities. Oh, yes. So in marketing brand personality is a big thing. Brands have personality, they match with human personality. So, you know, what I think is a good fit for me, I would, you know, use those brands a lot more. Now the thing is when we talk about brand personality, It was only people started talking about about 30 years back, not even 30 about 25 years back when Jennifer Akra stand for started talking about brand personality. So the thing is, again, there would be a change in perspective. There would be an insight that how these brands work. And then you start creating a body of knowledge around it through these knowledge, and that is what enlightenment is. Exactly. So enlightenments help you form your next perspective and potentially many, many perspectives. So it's a new way to think about the world. All right, three kinds of creative outcomes. It's not all about inventions. We also need to think about insights and enlightenments as reasons why we engage in the creative process. Um, so what the heck is a perspective before that to add one more thing. I talk about these things. Some thing to note about this is when we talk about creative process, most of the time what we think about is creative process is all about inventions. But that is not true. Creative process could be about insights. It could be an alignment. Creative process is not always about creating inventions. Yeah. Excellent. So we've spent quite a bit of time talking about perspectives this week. And so let's talk a little bit about perspectives. What is a perspective? Why do perspectives matter. What matters here and that we're really trying to point out is that the understanding, the interpretation, the perspective you form on a situation is not the same as the situation itself. Perspectives differ from reality. The distort, they highlight, they leave some things out, and they narrow our thinking often in productive ways, but sometimes they can lead us astray and we can change our interpretation of reality because of the perspective that we adopt. Here's a really simple perceptual example, and then we'll get into some conceptual examples in a moment. But start with a really simple perceptual example. This is two copies of the same image. I put them up there for a reason that'll be clear in just a second. And you'll notice there are two squares with a label A and B. And I don't know about you. But for me and I think many people, square A looks darker than square B. Your perception perspective guides you to think that square A is darker than square B because square B is in the shadow of that cylinder, we think of it as actually being lighter than square A. But let me just cover up everything except those two squares. And you'll notice the two squares are actually exactly the same brightness. They're just the which, you know, was striking for me the first time I saw that. But the idea here is that our perspectives are not just neutral interpretations of the world. They shape, they bias, they distort potentially the world as it is. And as a result, they can highlight some things, they can make some things clear, but they can also change. Reality. And so my perspective may differ from yours, and we may have different grasp on that underlying reality. So perceptual example, let's move to some conceptual examples. Right. And that is what the thing is about, about perspectives. This is we look at the world from a biased perspective. We look at the world from our own perspective. And the thing is, are all perspectives right? And sometimes, you know, there might be things that look like, this perspective looks pretty good. Everybody agrees on it, but are there any harmful effects of this perspective? For example, this is a phenomenal example, a smoky beer. Bear, right? So this is a longstanding character you guys, you know, would know about fighting forest fires. So smoky bear comes in handy, and he helps you for encouraging, you know, we see ads, we see public service announcements, awareness campaigns talking about getting into, you know, not, you know, getting into behaviors that would avoid forest fires. Which is a good thing. Nobody wants forest fires, right? But the thing is now over a period of time, what we started to see was that You know, once these fires were put out, there were not many small fires. I ended up being a bigger problem. Now what we see is once the fire happened, it was much bigger. It was a lot more uncontrollable. So the perspective was these fires are not good. But what it turns out is smaller controlled fires are actually pretty good. They are good for the forest. They are good for bigger, you know, fires that are uncontrollable. So smoky the bear was too successful. That got around, and everybody was, you know, working towards everything it was a successful It is a successful campaign. Yeah. But then are there other harmful impacts of these perspective that seemed very right? That seemed to be working. And again, this is power of advertisement, power of communication with consumers with end users. But again, looking at the perspective. Now we have new knowledge. We see that not all these perspectives that look good have positive implications. Something you know, when we look at the world, we look at it from a perspective. So always, always, I think this is what creativity is about considered other perspective. Again, not only when majority agrees with your perspective or majority agrees on a perspective, can we question a perspective. We'll talk about this as we go along in this course, we'll talk about when and how do we start questioning very you know, clear looking, very straightforward perspectives, too, and that enhances creativity and good solutions. Absolutely. So smoky the bear, that perspective of we should have no forest fires was too strong and that perspective ended up being hartful. Here's another way in which perspectives can lead us perhaps arise. So this one comes from the chemist, Bertozi Nobel Prize winning chemist. And When Bertozzi was learning chemistry, she learned that cell walls had sugar on the outside, and that was treated kind of as a protective coating, sort of like an M&M, you know, candy has a coating on the outside as a sort of form of protection. And that was all the sugars were understood to be. They were simply a simple protective wall that helped cells maintain their integrity. But in reflecting on new directions in chemistry, everyone was focusing on proteins, and Bertos was like, I don't know. Let's look at these sugars. Everyone's overlooking those sugars. Our perspective tells us there's nothing here. Maybe there's more here, in fact, to look at. And she and her colleagues found, in fact, that those sugars varied by cell type. And so, you know, rather than think of sugars as a simple protective barrier on the outside of the cells, realized that, in effect, these sugars were barcodes. They were helping to identify what kind of cells they were. That ultimately led to a Nobel Prize in chemistry, due to a collection of downstream things that followed from that really, really early fundamental insight that rather than sugars being a simple protective coating, that perspective was too simple, they are, in fact, much closer to a barcode. And that analogy turned out to be much, much more So, we have perspectives. They have pros and cons. This is what the interesting thing is because if you look at this when we were talking about the cells, the majority opinion majority perspective was proteins. That is what important is when you're talking about cells, when we're talking about cancer cell. But the thing is Bertos comes around and say, Okay, the sugars, around the cell. Why are they there? What's happening? There a very different perspective, questioning the majority opinion, and that is what us. Annble price. Yeah. So a perspective can tell you something is low value that, in fact, is really high value, but it's low value according to a perspective. So think about that, right? So you're a leader, decision maker in an organization, people on your team are bringing you ideas. You first response might be, that's really low value. I don't see the point in that. And so you might be like Bertozzi, right? It's just a cell wall. It's just, you know, a barrier. So there's nothing here. It's not interesting, but Bertozi is saying, Wait a minute, maybe there's more here. And turned out to be right. So your initial assumption about whether something is high or low value is often driven by your perspective, and therefore could be incorrect, right? If that perspective is not as encompassing as you think it should be. Mh has this question, how often do insights lead to invention, and this is like ing a lottery or what systematically investing in, say, Hey, here's the thing. And this is what my perspective is, Jeff, what do you think? Without insights, there's not going to be an invention. So not all insights are going to lead to inventions, but without insights, they're not going to be So the thing is, again, as we go along, we'll talk about, I think we've mentioned this last week. Creativity the process is adjourning. You cannot create first insight and say, Hey, you know, my work is done or the first idea you have come up with it's done. That is how it works. You have to keep going. There will be hurdles in the way and we'll talk about that, but you have to keep going. That's one of the reasons that Braintarmming one and Braintarming two, we're trying to enable you to generate Insights more fluently and more efficiently because one of them might not work out. And if it's exhausting, and tiring and difficult to create even one insight, well, then it's much riskier. But if we can help you generate many insights and do so efficiently, well, then you have a better chance of getting to inventions that really are worthwhile. So that's really the core behind why we're trying to help you become more individually flexible and generate perspectives more readily. So, the sort of idea here that we're trying to get our hands around here with perspectives is really beautifully captured in the reading for this week, Scott Page. It's a chapter from a larger book called the Difference, talking about the roles of diversity and teams. And the value in that is by bringing different perspectives together to understand problems in new or better ways. I'm going to actually read the full quote here. I sort of captured the first part of it. Diverse perspectives cut both ways. But let me sort of broaden that out a little bit. For every brilliant perspective that changes a difficult situation into an easy one, there may be a multitude of perspectives that muck up our understanding of even strategic contexts. Different perspectives can simplify, but they can also muddle. So I'm taking the time to highlight this quote because I think it's really, really powerful and important to appreciate that a perspective can allow you to see a solution and get to a solution that was otherwise inconceivable and you never would have noticed it, or your perspectives can lead you to see something as difficult and impossible, as not having any way forward or what have you. So a problem can be easy or hard because of the perspective. And there's a beautiful example in that reading of Tik tact and magic squares and so forth, where he gives you exactly the same problem structurally three different times. But each time he gives you a different perspective on the problem. And some of those perspectives make the problem seem impossible, and others make it seem like literally child's play. And so the highlight here and why we're spending this time to think about the importance of perspectives is because you might be confronted by a problem or a challenge at work or anywhere and think, this is beyond me. I have no idea what to do. This is impossible. There's no way forward, but a change in perspective might enable that problem to be readily solved. That's what we're after. Yeah. That is what it is. And the thing is when we talk about exactly what you said, you know, Jeff, most of the time, we look at problems and we say, we have pica is routine or this is a problem, this is a problem, and we live with it, like in our everyday life. That is how things work. You know, small little things, for example, a blanket, right? The thing is you look at a blanket and then see, this is what a blanket looks like and there's you know, not a big issue here. So think about, you know, you're on a couch watching your favorite show and you have a bowl of popcorn there. And then every time you have to pick up a popcorn, you have to take your hand outside the blanket. Now, many of us would not like to do that, right? I'm cozy in my blanket and, you know, I would rather want someone to, you know, put some popcorn in my mouth. But we have to take that hand out. We live with that problem. We think, there's a perspective. That's how blankets are, and that is how we live. But the thing is, Does everyone think it that way? So Gary lag, yeah, Snuggi Gary leg in 1997, he was a freshman at a university. He was in a dorm room, pretty cool dorm room. And then what he was towing, he was watching his favorite TV show, and he has to, you know, take his hand out if he wanted to change the channel to use the remote. What did he do? Again, most of us would live it through the d experience. What he did change in perspective? He said, Hey, what can I do to this blanket so that I can change the channel without taking my hand outside the blanket. He cut a hole, add a sleeve to a blanket. And la, what do we have? What we call snuggy? But what he started it was the product that started was called blanket. I created not only new product, it created a whole new product category because he was looking at a problem from a different perspective. Everyone, again, then that is what we're talking about. Perspective can make problems look harder. Because, hey, this is what blanket is. This is what I have to live with. It's a problem. It's hard. We cannot solve it. But then if you change your perspective. Hey, you know what? We can do something about it. What happens is it starts creating new insights. It starts to create, you know, if you keep adding that, you will reach to an invention, a new product. And whole new product multi million dollar industry now. So again, all about perspective change, and that is how it works, right? Absolutely. So with that, let's turn to some of your efforts to wrangle a problem and try different perspectives in order to generate solutions. So in our first brainstorming assignment, we asked you to brainstorm about a particular organizational problem. And the idea here is less about the problem, I mean, that we want to talk about today and more thinking about what is the process? How did that go? Some of you felt like I got this. I absolutely have a way of brainstorming that I know how to use. And I'm going to apply that process to this problem, and we're feeling pretty good about it. Others of you were feeling like, I have no idea what to do. I sort of stared at the wall and hoped ideas came to me. I totally get it, right? That's why we're in this class. So we can either add to the process you're already using and hopefully further improve it or provide you with a process if it's not something that you're used to having already. Another few things we saw in brainstorming, one, how students attempted that or the ideas you gave us, your insights we initial ideas were a little easier to come up. You came up with the first solution, first solution. You took some time, but you know, you came up with this. But the other ideas were very similar to your first idea. So the thing is and then what we call in literature is called the idea build up. What we do is we have, again, you know, this is a problem of fixation. So we come up with a solution, and that is what we were talking about. The first solution you come up with, then you get fixated on that solution. And then your new idea just bounce off that little idea, and there are minor improvements in those ideas, and that is what we see. That is what you told us, you know, in your answers. Also what I thought was very interesting was many of the students said that I did not have enough background knowledge on the problem. I don't know how hospital or healthcare industry works. Without that knowledge, I was not able to come up with good ideas. Again, this is an interesting thing is when we talk about knowledge, some basic knowledge is good, but when we talk about creativity, we talk about creativity as a process. The thing is you can take a different context and apply the same process in a different context. Yeah, you need to know a little bit knowledge, but not huge knowledge, and then we know more knowledge you have within the area, more expertise you have, less creative you would be. Well, so it's interesting. There's this two sided coin, double edged sword, right of knowledge. On the one hand, more knowledge allows you to sort of imagine more possibilities, right? But also entrenches you even further, right? So the challenge is how to have that knowledge and not get entrenched. But I guess I want to back up to an even maybe simpler point than Robbie the sophisticated point you were making, which is, I think sometimes if we have trouble solving a problem, then one of our first responses we're like, Well, maybe I just need to learn more, right? I don't know enough. As opposed to maybe my current perspective isn't very helpful for generating solutions. And if I try a different perspective, maybe then more solutions will follow. And that's the insight I think we are trying to have you experience by realizing, wait a minute, maybe my current perspective has generated whatever ideas it can help me generate, and now what I have to do instead of learning more knowledge, maybe I have to change my perspective and see if that can lead me to ideas that I've previously been overlooking, given the knowledge I already have, I can still think of new solutions and further possibilities if I just change my perspective. You're absolutely right. I see the thing is Ricci is saying this in the chat. You know, not having knowledge industry helps you brainstorm and you know, because you're not aware of the constraints. And as we go along, we'll talk more about this when we talk, you know, our current knowledge constraints within the same framework, but can we borrow from outside cross stock? We have been talking about cross stock last, you know, we we talked about that. It is, how do we bring this knowledge from outside. How do we cross talk with different areas? Sure. So, you know, there's a prior story or problem I've worked on. Maybe that's applicable in the current problem. And if I see that connection, right, that maybe leads me to a fresh perspective change, absolutely. So it could be my history of problems, or it could be I connect to other people's problems, whatever it might be. But these are all opportunities for us to generate a new perspective. Right. Now, going back to brainstorming one. So there was a second part to it. The second part was, you use AI to generate some ideas for you and it was a very simple problem is, you know, just enter a prompt and see what AI gives you. And then the bigger part was, what did you learn from that process? What were the differences or similarities between the ideas you generated and AI generated. And the whole idea was here to understand how are we different than how AI works. And again, you know, what AI has has a lot broader information. So it pulls the information. So whatever the constraints we saw in your ideas, for example, I was fixated. A is not fixated because broader information AI doesn't have a perspective. So what we saw was, again, there were much more creative ideas or more number of ideas that came out. Ideas were there was a lot more depth to the ideas, and that was because again, there's a lot more information that AI could draw upon. Let me add to this because I think Jenna has got this question as well, which is, how do we use these AI tools to Improve our creative process. So think of it as a support for your creativity. And I think what we're seeing overall, and Robbie was just sort of describing this, I think the best use of AI or the widest use across our community here in this course was as a support for giving you new launching points, new starting points, for forming different perspectives. Hey, I didn't notice that, Hey, I didn't think of that. Hey, that's another aspect to this problem that I wasn't really I was kind of ignoring or overlooking or not really considering. And sort of the AI giving that to me very, very quickly enabled me to move out of the perspective that I had been kind of fixated upon and helped ease my way into other perspectives that I wouldn't have generated otherwise. So is that feel right? Exactly? And then, for example, what is saying is, yeah, it helps you break those bi. It gives you more big set inertia and then moves away from your. But very important, what you said here, Jenna is considered a tool for creative thinking. So please use AI as it's a tool. It is not not using creative AI to generate creative ideas for you. It is a tool for you to use it to break biases. I think writer's block, Cam mentioned that. That is where AI comes in handy. And you know when I'm working on this work, I don't have big enough data set right now. The thing is when you work when you collaborate with AI, you end up being more creative because in that sense, it gives you more information, but the context is what we as humans bring to solving the problem. So again, we'll talk more as we go along. And there are other ways to improve your flexibility, and that's really what we're going to push on today. So what are ways that you individually with or without AI can help yourself generate alternative perspectives. So here's a quick example. Let's think about this together, and then we'll walk and we're going to walk through it using what we call pages. Pages is something we talk about quite a bit in this course. It's a way of articulating your perspectives. So here's a quick example. And I'll introduce it and so you can start thinking about it, and then we'll get back to it in just a second. So theft of company resources by a company's own employees is a widespread occurrence. What might we do in response to the resources, by a company's own employees. All right. So let's think about that for a second. And before we dive into it, let me just explain to you a little bit about pages, and we're going to use pages to help think about how to address this problem? And pages is a way of articulating what your current perspective is? So there are different aspects of pages. There are the parts. You can think of these as the nouns, the objects, the places, you know, in the situation. Actions. You can think of these as the verbs. What can I do? What are the operations or transformations or moves that I can make in this particular situation? Goals. What am I trying to accomplish? What are my motivations in this situation? What is the overarching event going on, right? And then self concept. Who am I? What is my role or identity in this particular context or situation? All right, so that's a generic description of these aspects of our perspective. And so now let's think about applying these to the question we just asked you about So I'll give you my lame perspective that I started with when I first saw this problem. So, I imagined here's some unhappy employees. So that was the self concept who's stealing, right? So that's the overarching event. There's theft going on, and they grab their computer, they carry it out of the building, and they sell it for cash, right? So their goal is, you know, to get some money because I'm an unhappy employee, and I want money. And so I'm going to take this computer. I'm going to walk out of the building with it. And so there's a stealing event. All right, so that's a really, really simple response. And if that's my perspective, then we can think about, well, what are solutions for that? I could tag the computers, I could have cameras, I could have other ways of tracking who has what computers. So I know if there's a computer missing, you know, whose computer it was. So that perspective could lead to some solutions. So going back to this problem, you know, theft of company. Let's work with this. Yeah, and Great, if you can put it in chat or if you want to raise your hand and talk about this. What could be other parts. You know, when we are talking about theft from, you know, company theft, we're talking about computer is one thing. That could be stolen. What could be other things, you know, as parts that you think you know, people can steal from the company. Let's see if we can IP, I say, Oh, someone says, cheer I love it. I love it. Excellent. Time, which is interesting. So you know how time would be a theft. Let's talk about that a little bit more. I'm going to start with IP. That was the second one I came out. I love it. We're so in tune here today. So trade secrets, I called it, but intellectual property, right? So if that's my part, then maybe I'm infiltrating a computer network or something like that, and I'm exploiting the organizations, you know, intellectual resources. The larger event is, you know, intellectual property theft as opposed to computer theft or something like that. And maybe we're talking about a disloyal employee. Maybe we're talking about sort of organizational espionage or something like that, right? And so with that as a perspective, that leads to totally different interventions, right? So maybe you're thinking about who has access to information and computer systems and how do we track what happens with that information. So, made all kinds of solutions that follow from adopting this particular perspective. So trade secrets. Look at that time. Folks, we are really on the same wavelength here today. So time, maybe I'm avoiding work. And so maybe the event is movie time, right? I'm watching a movie at work because I don't feel like doing actual work. And, you know, maybe I'm increasing my personal time, and I'm a totally unmotivated employee. I don't care about what I'm doing. So again, the different perspectives lead to different solutions, and by generating different parts, you already see that it can have really big ramifications for what kinds of solutions you think of? No, this is what the interesting part is. If example, if you just throw a question at you and say, okay, you know, this company tap is a big problem, then we form a perspective in mind. This is what is getting stolen. Most of the time is stationary or IP and this thing, and then we start coming up solutions to solve that. But now here, what we do is clear, what are other parts that are being stolen? And based on that, can we come up with new solutions. And not only that. Now the thing is think about self concept. So, when you're stealing a computer, you are an unhappy employee. Or the thing is when you talk about take the self concept from a time, unmotivated employee. So you can take that self concept and apply to someone stealing computer. Then suddenly what happens is you have a new perspective. And then your solution would be very different from what you would be normally, you'll say for computer is being stolen. So this would be our intervention. T should be our solution. As soon as you change that sub concept, your solution changes. So this is another very interesting thing which I actually did not hear stealing products. So just popped. Popped. Stealing product. The thing is many companies, there's a new product that is being created, And then what we see is, you know, employees stealing that product. They are taking it to their homes and then trying that out. And sometimes it's unsolicited testing, right? They are someone, uh, testing these products. Now, is that a good thing or a bad thing? Yeah. That's fasting. So what Robbie is doing here. I don't know. This was very subtle, Robby. But this is actually really interesting. It's suggesting, wait a minute, theft of company resources, maybe defaults to, that's bad, and that's wrong. And how could you be doing that? But in fact, this example is, hey, if we have a sort of R&D lab, and we're coming up with lots of new prototypes, if we see which ones kind of walk out the door, maybe that's informative. Maybe that says, Hey, this is the one ever wanted to play with or try themselves or they found useful. And so maybe in that version of theft, it's actually sort of, you know, testing. Testing. It gives you a new information. It tells you you know what products are. You know, more popular with your customers or you know, they saying someone sold our products or the things you're stealing. So what is selling in the market, so you're getting some market research data, I don't know making this Well, also with things like stationary. So forgive me if I get the name. I think it was Harsh mentioned pens, but maybe somebody else did. Forgive me. The chat is going by quickly. So but the idea here at pens is, yeah, you could see that as, you know, people are stealing, company property. But you might think, whatever, right? So it's not that anyone has any malicious intent. Let's put our company name on the pens, and then you can walk around knowing that you've got one of our pens, we've helped you out. And if you happen to leave this somewhere, someone else can pick it up and they have another touch point for connecting with our brand, right, and our organization. So you can think about maybe some kinds of theft are benign. Maybe some of them are positive, and maybe some of them actually could, you know, be negative. And we respond differently based on the nature of how we interpret these activities. No, there's another thing, you know, I think we should talk about is sometimes, you know, what happens is, you say, okay, these are this is my action, but can that be my goal, too. And yeah, we see that confusion. If for example, you know, uh, example that comes to my, for example, making a bed. Every day morning, I make a bed. So making a bed, is that an action or is that a goal? Yeah, right, or an event, right? So there are different ways to think about it. So maybe making the bed as a goal, and that's something I want to do, you know, to be neat and tidy or something like that. Or you can think, No, maybe my goal is to be neat, and then the action is making the bed, right? So you can think about it in these different ways. You could also think about making the bed as the event. So if my event is making the bed, then the action would be something like, I don't know, taking off the covers, changing the sheets, putting new sheets on, something like that. Or you could think of making the bed as an action in that larger event of cleaning the house or something like that. So if you're worried that, wait a minute. This thing could be an action or maybe it could be an event, and which one is it really? The answer is it's both, probably. And what is the perspective if you look at it as an event versus what is the perspective if you look at it as an action? Or if you think about an active How does that what we are doing? So the point here is not that there are no differences between parts actions, goals, even self concept. The clearly are. But you might be able to play different roles in your perspective. And that's really what we're trying to highlight. So the goal is not to figure out, you know, what is this thing really? But it's more to say, you know, how am I thinking about it right now, and if I think about it as a part or as a self concept or whatever, what does that imply for my perspective, what new ideas follow from that? I'll give you one of the ones that we talk about a lot, which is people. Are people self concepts or are people parts? The answer is yes, they can be both. What does it mean if you're treating a person as a part of your problem versus a self concept, those have really different implications. But you could think about it either way. A T is the important part, especially when it comes to again, you mentioned example in managerial decision making when we are trying to come up with creative solutions. So thinking of a person as a part or someone who's if example, creating problem or you're trying to solve a problem around a person or what the self concept is, what is that? But also, when it comes to new product development. You know, what's when we talk about, you know, we have heard about this term of voice of customer and what customer should we bring in, is that a goal or is there an even? What problem are we trying to solve. So how we define the scope of a problem, the perspective around that can define whether the particular aspect we're talking about, is that a goal or an action or even or even, you know, uh, you can say, a part or, you know, the self concept. So the thing is something, again, I think we hear a lot of confusion about this, you know, what exactly this is, and then I want to box this one thing as one thing. So again, you know, be more creative even when we are talking about these pages, and we're talking about these different aspects of pages. All right. So where we're headed next is to practice this a little bit. So to run your point in the chat, that's exactly where we're headed next. We're going to do this together right here right now. And so we did this example of theft just to introduce the idea, to show you some of the richness and complexity here and some of the value. And then in just a second, we're going to go into a breakout and run through this together before we get that, just a clarification so Jenna has this thing is self concept about other people involved or your specific involved. Yes. Got it. So you can think about my self concepts. So maybe, so I am an employee of the University of Illinois. I am a parent. I am a professor. There are different self concepts that I have individually, but also I can think about the self concepts of other people, right? So I theft of company resources, I could think about myself as the person doing the stealing. I could think about myself as the manager who's representing the organization that is being stolen from, right? Or I could think about, you know, the news organization or the police or whatever. Anyone else you might imagine is potentially playing a role in that situation. So self concept is trying to encourage you to take the vantage point of different kinds of people, whether that's different roles that you yourself could play or the roles of others. Obviously, a new product development. We often think about the role of the end user, think about the role of the customer, the consumer, right? Those are really important. But of course, we also think about the manufacturing side and all of that. So those are different self concepts that we can bring to bear to help us understand a problem. And it is all about looking at things from different perspectives. When we talk about self concept, what we're saying is, how would this person be thinking about this problem? And that is about perspective taking. Catherine, I love this question, right? So if you find yourself struggling, like, wait a minute, what would that self concept do in this? What would often those sort of challenging juxtapositions lead us to new insights, right? We don't normally think about the loyal employees dealing. But yet, right, if that does happen, what would be going on? Right. And how would we wrestle with that? Sometimes, those sorts of oppositions or seeming contradictions are actually really fruitful ways into novel perspectives that we wouldn't have generated otherwise, right? And so Sorry, I'm getting lost in that particular example, but I wanted to make the general point about how fruitful it is to sort of get stuck in those ways because it says, Wait a minute, my perspective doesn't have a ready answer. Let's see if I can push on that a little bit and come out with something. All right. So let's practice something together. Here's a new prompt. And this one, we're going to jump into breakout discussions. Um, to talk about this in groups together. So here's a situation that many of you might have been confronting in the last year or so, many companies now have vacant office space, right? So because so many employees are now working from home, working remotely, having flexle work arrangements, all that kind of thing. All right, what do you do? What do you do with your vacant office space? You probably have an initial perspective. Maybe you have some ideas already for what you've done at your office. That's great. You can share those in the group, and et cetera. But what we really want you to do is once you sort of had that initial round of ideas that you already are aware of and that you thought of right off the top of your heads. Now try to use pages to push into new perspectives and see how many ideas you can generate. So we're going to ask you how many ideas did your group generate? And the hope is that you're you're learning to use pages and you're applying this approach of trying out different aspects of pages to help you generate many new perspectives, and that leads to many new ideas. So with that, let's take about 12 minutes, jump into breakouts, and let's see what can we do with vacant office space. See you in a few minutes. Welcome back. We hope you had a fabulous discussion. Please do put up your hands. We'd love to hear some of your best ideas, your most interesting, surprising, curious, fun ideas. And anything about your process? How was it to try to use pages to help you generate ideas fluently by shifting your perspectives more readily. So do put up your hands, do drop things in chat. We'd love to talk to you about your brainstorming efforts around vacant office space and how we might make use of that, what we might do as a result. Bob, that is totally fine. If you haven't written them, we're also interested in understanding the process. What process you use pages. It's all good. Absolutely. I hope one idea, at least was memorable enough that we still have it. We don't certainly need to hear all of them. We know that you generated tons and tons of ideas. That's great. But we are curious about some of the ones that really did stand out to you. And again, about the process. The whole point here is, learning how to break a perspective down into pages and then try cycling through different parts and then try cycling through some different goals and so forth, might be an efficient, systematic way to fluently generate new perspectives. So that's what we're after. All right. The other thing is, you know, some people, you know, would lay out some ideas, they'll suggest some idea, then you'll say, Hey, we have exactly the same idea. So no point me raising hand and talking about this. Yeah. But you'll see, you know, you might reach the same ideas, but through a very different process. And that is what we would be interested in knowing, you know, what process did you follow? It doesn't matter what idea you came up with it matters. But the thing is what also matters is the process you follow. So so please please share with us, you know, what, what, um, process you follow. So, All right, let's go to Joel and then we'll go from there. Awesome. I see I decided to ask people to come back to the office. That was one of the first things that came up in group three. Obviously, we all no, no, you can try out all you want, but there are so many issues. So we went around. We had the benefit of having somebody who has some firsthand knowledge of I won't say exactly, but of some of this process of converting current workspace into other things. So once we got through things that we've all seen, we went into pages. And first, we changed the self concept, you know, what concept we're looking at it from and we talked about, you know, talking about things like daycare and schools and converting some of that space to education for that. And then we changed, you know, what's our understanding of the overall situations? And we got to, Okay, what if, you know, urban laser tag, urban mini golf, entertainment spaces, then soup kitchens, associations. And it just kept going from there and that was at the very tail end, and I think we were all kind of bummed. We had to cut it off. Yeah. That's great. That's fantastic. Because you know when scene we ask people to work on sort of a hard problem, you know, after five, six, seven ideas, they're sort of like, I'm done. You know, it's exhausting. So I think both having each other to bounce new ideas off of and feed off one another's energy, as well as, of course, pages, helping us you feel like we were not getting stuck, we could just turn to something else, turn to another aspect of pages, and that would unlock a new set of transformations. That's really what we're going for. And so the feeling that this could be energizing, this could be fun, This could be productive is really important because if you have an opportunity to be creative. If there's a que and you encounter an impasse or something like that, and you feel like, you know, maybe I'll just give up. But if you feel like, wait a minute, generating ideas, that's kind of fun, and I'm pretty good at it, and I have some confidence and some positive emotion around that. Well, then, okay, let's take 10 minutes and 15 minutes, and let's see how far we get. That's really, really important. So coming away with just that sense of, Hey, I can do this, and it's actually kind of interesting. That's really, really important because it means you're more likely to move into the creative process rather than avoid the creative process. And you're going to stick with it because you'll realize my guess is the first ideas that you generated were not as compelling as the ones you generated later. You don't get to laser tag first, right? You get the laser tag as your 12th or your 17th idea, not as your first or second idea, right? That's just my guess. And so that's a value of having this be motivating and positive. All right. Maybe you mentioned this. How many ideas did you end up with your team? Ballpark? Boy. Besides the stuff that we had already seen and we're just kind of throwing around one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, and then we kind of ran out of time. Yeah. Great. Excellent. Excellent. Just keep coming. This is the thing I know, you know, there's a very limited time you had about 12:10 to 12 minutes, you talk to each other. But the whole idea is to get started, then you'll see, once you get into the process, once you start changing one thing and then you start generating new ideas, you change another thing, change new ideas. What it does is enhances the fluency of the process. You know, as what you were saying, you go in with confidence that yes, I can make some changes. Even if I have no idea about this, you know, situation, not this problem. I still can take one part of this situation, change it, and then we'll see is new ideas will start to flow. And then that is what fluence is. You'll start coming up with more and more ideas, and we'll see you know, again, we'll talk to more people and then see how many ideas your team came up with. And then as compared to if you were not using this process, then you'll see exactly what you said. You get stuck very quickly. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. All right. Thank you, Joe. Let's go to Vini hey, we want to hear from more people too. So I want to see more hands, please. All right. Thank you. So we had this room number four, and we were generating ideas left and right, actually. So like he said, many things like daycare, hotel or, you know, Uber. So we talked about Uber office because it is already in office, right? So why not to lease that office space to individuals who don't want to work from home because of family situation or whatever, right. They could utilize that and then we can have a scape room because it is a complex multi floor building, so that could be complex games also. Then then home for homeless, sleeve the building, sell the building, scrap the building, whatever. Those kind of thing. And then if it is left alone the buildings for long, drug dealers can quick in there and then they can make their own home there. I know that. Yeah. Yeah, that's so great. I love introducing that dimension of time, right? So one of the things that we can do here as we think about this, right? So you might think, what is the event? It's sort of, you know, this week or this month or, you know, is this long term? Are we talking about vacant office space for years? Are we thinking about it for minutes, right? And so you had that idea of, you know, Uber for office space, right? So we work, right? Maybe, is by the month or, you know, whatever, but maybe it's like, Hey, you know, you need a desk for, you know, 3 hours, right? Come on in for the morning and we'll work with you, right? Yeah. I love it. I love it. And so really shattering that sense of, you know, what is the scope of this event? And that leads you in different directions. Is this quick? Is this long? And, you know, what kind of space do I have? So that notion of sort of multi level office space. Oh, there's complexity, there's richness. What can I do as a result of that? Was if I'm just thinking about, I don't know, my exact office, maybe that's very different, then I'm thinking about all of our offices across six floors in this building versus if I think, I don't know, about all 20 buildings, you know, in my neighborhood, you know, in my city or something like that, and that might lead me to even more ideas that I had initially, right? So by thinking about scope and time or space, that might help us push our perspectives and lead to ideas we didn't have otherwise. So I love that. I think it's really, really clever. And also, you know, we start thinking about self concepts. So example, you know, you mentioned an, you let it sit and then there would be drug dealers coming in. I mean, what you can do is you can start start thinking that as a self concept, right? You know, okay, maybe we will create a red guard. I don't know. Something like that. So take a self concept, and suddenly, what you have is a whole new solution space there because you change one component, one aspect of this page. And I think that's the beautiful aspect of pages framework. And then as we were saying, it enhances fluency, it helps you come up with more ideas. We're different and next week we'll talk about categorization categorization. Yeah. And you'll see different categories. I think Joel was talking about this in, you know, different categories of products, and you can start jumping from one category to another using this frame which is pretty awesome. Thank you, Vin. Let's go to Nathan. We came up with a lot of the same ideas. One of the things that was a little bit different is we talked about reevaluating the y. Why does it matter for the space to be fully utilized? Like, is there a drop in productivity? Do you think potentially the younger employees are not being trained? Or is it just the old perspective of, you need to be there nine to five, and that's the way business is done because you know, different people are going to have different needs. Personally, I've got small children, and if I have to take my daughter to a doctor's appointment in the middle of the day, I can get at least an hour additional work in by working from home with my workstation there where I'm fully productive. Versus having to drive to work and double my commute and all that. But really understand maybe it doesn't need to be more people in the office. There is other things you could do. I mean, you could always give people two cubes worth of space and maybe they'll be more productive if they have more space to stretch out as well. Those are some of the things that we came up with in our group. I love it. So really pushing on the goal here, really pushing on the goal. So is vacant office space a problem or maybe it's a positive Okay. And maybe that allows people who do benefit from coming into the office, more room to stretch out, and maybe, you know, just like having two or three monitors like we do here, maybe if I had two or three offices, right? Really interesting things could happen, and you can do your home office and I can really stretch out around here. So, you know, and, you know, it's not just about getting rid of it, right, as being excess, so we can all work from home and have the advantages you just talked about. Maybe there are some positives for those people for whom it really makes sense. And maybe, you know, most days you work at home, but maybe on the days when you're at the office, having more space or having more flexible space or having different kinds of space would be really, really appealing, right? So pushing on the motivation, the goal, right, the why, right? That goal aspect of your perspective can help you push into new perspectives and new ideas. Yeah. And then what you also did here, if, you know, Nathan, if you look at it closely, you're saying, if I have to take my daughter, right? So the thing is the thing is you have changed the self concept, you know, we're talking about this office space. And certainly, what we're saying is self concept we bring in of a parent. Now, you know, would it make sense? What can we do? So now, once you start thinking about that self concept, then, you know, whole new solution space opens up. So it's okay if it was a working parent, if we keep that as a self concept, then what can we do with office space? Maybe, you know, it becomes more of a I don't know. You know, you have more play area or something like that so that you can bring kids in or you just open up space for kids, something like that. Soda most of the time when we say this is an objective perspective. So the thing is, I know knowingly I'm changing this perspective. Also, it would be nice for us to be conscious about what other things are being changed when we are taking this new perspective. And suddenly you see this whole new solution space new ideas would start to come in. And that is where essentially the fluency comes in. I know Gillian Henry was talking about this. He said, Oh, we came up with 14 ideas, and then we kind of got stuck. And then what we saw, we started apply pages and we came up with seven more ideas. So again, that's the power of this framework. And then, you know, what I would want to do, and I'm going to come back to you, Atika in a minute is don't this brainstorming, too, which is asking you to use these pages. But don't stop with just that assignment, you know, in your workspace at your home. When you're trying to come up with an idea to sort apply this to your everyday life, start using this framework in how you do things going forward. You know, I would encourage you to do that. Yeah, yeah, it does take some practices I think you've experienced here today, but, you know, once you start to get the hang of it, things come along. And I love the question about what we're doing with empty office space here at the university. The answer is, we actually are building another building because we're out of office space, and we need more offices and studio space. So yes, we need more studio space. We need more offices, so we're building another building. But I hear you. I think a lot of what's going on especially in larger cities is we are seeing the work from home effort transform the use of office space and the conceptualization. I don't know. Maybe you need to build more studios in your empty office space. So that you can come in and have really, really great setups for your online meetings when you're working, you know, on really, really important are weird, right? So we like because we want to come to office when students are not around. A lot of people are not around. We can sit in our office, get our research done, so you got a little kind of that. No, no, no. It's wonderful to be on campus, no matter what. No matter what. It's great to be here. Now, there's a lot of energy in life. That's the joy of it. For sure. For sure. All right. We want to hear from Attica. Yes, please. Professor, so I was part of Room seven. We discussed, I think, similar ideas around leveraging the office space for different purposes. So whether it's play area, you know, doing more employee engagement, maybe having small community events, and also like subleasing it. And actually, one idea was around converting them into residential apartments. So kind of doing a mix of, you know, you know, office spaces into residential. I think one of the perspectives that we had goes around public officials, which I kind of posted in the comment that, you know, I think from what I hear about the cities, at least the ones which are very busy, that their ecosystem is, you know, around people coming to the office, and I think it also drives how many younger people actually live in the city because the overall vibrancy goes down. So how do I think that's where I sort of personally struggle like, how do you kind of use the pages framework because I understand the self concept from a public official, but not really like, how do you kind of plan out? You know, you use the pages framework fully, I guess, to flush out the idea for it. Yeah. Oh, that's a great question. So let's push on this one a little bit, right? Let's do this together right here right now and see if we can make some progress. So we're seeing vacant office space in cities, driving down people coming into, you know, downtown areas or something like that. And then that means all the sort of businesses and all the life that thrives around having that network of people, you know, come in every day goes away. So the places where you might get lunch or the places where you might get coffee or the places you might have a drink after work or, you know, whatever, right? All those businesses, the shopping you might do, you know, before or after our lunch breaks or whatever, you know, there's no one there because everyone's working from home. So what do you do? So maybe what you do is you think about how can you, you know, use some of that office space and provide space to people who might really welcome the space or really need it. Um, but not be able to afford it or make use of it in other ways, right? So that could be an example, right? So if I think through what is the self concept of someone who could really benefit from that livelihood, why would they feel threatened? What goals might they have? How could I satisfy those goals with certain parts or certain actions? What is the event that might draw their attention, right? So those are ways in which we can use pages to help push and developing that perspective in order to see whether we can start generating solutions off of that perspective. Absolutely. And then I was going to say this what Michelle is talking about here. The thing is, again, I think you were talking about, you know, people have to travel to office, and we talk about bigger cities, I saw someone about New York City. So again, you know, if we start taking perspective of self concept of this person who has to travel your longer distance to come to office, maybe half the building is residential building. And then your office, you take the elevator to your office, right? But again, the whole idea here is how pages would work is take this self concept and say, what problem are we trying to solve. Now here, you're also you know, again, we talked about solution space, and that is what we have been talking about. But what we did was we jump onto a new problem space. Now the thing is, you know, what is happening is an employee who has to take, you know, has to travel longer distance to come to office, then there's another problem there. There's this traffic problem, there's this public transport problem, transportation problem, gas all those things. So you say, again, if we are trying to solve this vacancy problem and that, can we combine these two problems together? And then what could be our solution and that cause us to give you more creative ideas. Once again, And another thing, I think, Hersh was asking? I think it was Hersh was talking about, can perspectives be driven by goals? Yeah. Sure. Sure. Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, you can think about different aspects of perspectives as being your anchor, right? So maybe the goal is the most important thing, right? So maybe it's maximizing, you know, people coming through the office. And so, right, what would get as many people as possible into the office? And so everything else can sort of dance around that, right? And we talked about, you know, could we have Social events or, you know, et cetera, right? As ways to think about, you know, maybe how we maximize the number of people through the office. So that would be that goal and that sort of dominates. But you could also take a self concept, right? So, what if, you know, I'm a young person who lives in a tiny apartment that's really unpleasant, and I wish I had somewhere else to go, right? And so that self concept could sort of drive everything else. And then we could think about what are the attending goals and events and actions and so forth that follow, or we can be really rooted on parts, right? So we've talked about offices generically, but I don't know, maybe it's about desks and chairs or maybe it's about, you know, actual resources to get work done, right? So manufacturing is different than marketing is different than, you know, design or, you know, whatever, right? So maybe there are different specific resources that are available in certain places, and those are really important. So let's zoom in on office and get more specific. About what some of those resources are, and by focusing on those parts, maybe that allows us to then think of new goals or think of new self concepts and so forth. So part of the reason that we have all these different aspects of pages, five, not too many, but enough, is to help us push our thinking in different directions by jumping from one aspect to another. So let's push on parts for a while and then let's maybe shift to goals, and then maybe we shift to self concept, and and so on. And that way we avoid getting stuck, and we also allow ourselves to explore different the full sort of space, right? The whole point here is, how do we increase your fluency at imagining different perspectives so that you generate different kinds of ideas so that ultimately you're left with this lovely set of ideas that are quite different from one another and allow you to explore different kinds of problems and different kinds of solutions. Right. So I think we kind of addressed the question you were raised? Did we put it there. Yeah. I wonder. Something that, you know, it's so it does seem this kind of sponsor to another problem. It's not really linked to the office space because one of the things that kind of come to my mind is also around public transportation. Because, you know, if people are using it less, you know, they have less funding, and then it doesn't improve the system. So infrastructure gets negatively impacted, you know, so yes, there's a concept around overcrowding as well because I think New York City is trying to address that through tariffs and stuff like that. But then how do you kind of address the public transportation. So from what I understood, it's like spans of a separate problem altogether because of this. Yeah. But, this is, I guess, what can be interesting about this, right, is that if you start out with vacant office space, and then you get to the real issue is public transportation, right? So now, it's like, wait a minute, right? And not everyone went in that direction, right? So I might have gone in a very different direction with vacant office space than, you know, needing to think hard about public transportation. And so, yeah, at some point, you might want to say, You know what, wait a minute, we've wandered away from our problem. We can't really address that, or no, it turns out that we think these things are so tightly connected that actually unless we start talking about public transportation, we're not really going to be able to address, the vacant office based problem in a way that's sort of fruitful, right? And so part of this is thinking, you know, systems thinking and thinking about how the pieces come together, and the different perspectives might lead you to make different kinds of connections. So is it about, you know, what is the culture and our organization? And can we create the kind of culture we want if we're not in the office and what kinds of different activities? Or are we thinking about how do we have healthy cities and healthy urban environments, and then we think about pubic transportation and parks and and, you know, all the businesses that thrive off of the office communities where people are coming in and spending money, right? So very different directions by taking our perspectives in these different ways, it leads us to think about very different possibilities and ideas. And that's kind of our point, right? Is that this task of thinking through pages is intended to guide you to go off in these different directions rather than focus on one and just hunker down there and not consider any of the others. So it's delightful to hear that your different conversations ended up going off in these different directions. That was really our aspiration, right? That you might have gotten to, you know, how do I have laser tag and, you know, childcare and public transportation issues, you know, and we work, right? I mean, you know, that's kind of the point is that you're going off in all these different directions, and pages is sort of starting to help you do that. Right. So thank you, Atika Another thing, you know, perch. What you're saying, is it seems like pages is very flexible. I can start from anywhere and fill in. Sounds like there's no one way to be correct. Now the thing is, I don't know, Jeff but there's nothing about being correct. Yeah. Yeah. The thing is it is about gerations about coming up with new perspectives. Again, I think the question, if I'm understanding it, precas really observation is that you can start with parts. And then yeah you know, Somewhere else or you could start with self concept and head somewhere else. And that's absolutely the case, you should take ownership of this process. These are jumping off points, and all I think we are recommending is that don't just focus on parts or don't just focus on self concept. If you start with parts, great, but then try actions and then try events. If you start with self concept, great. Now try goals and see where that leads you. So the idea in introducing this is to encourage to not just dwell on any one? And a lot of us intuitively tend to focus on one of these. So I find when I talk to people who feel like I have a brains iron process and it works for me, what they tend to do is pick one or two of these and focus on that and maybe neglect the others. And so part of the reason we put pages together, building on, I don't know, about 70 years of research on how people think and generate new ideas was precisely to try and encourage you in a manageable way to explore these very different aspects of your perspectives. Do you go off in these different directions rather than just get anchored on any one of them. And that also means you can have one self concept and you can have say ten different parts, or you can have four different goals. So think is with this. And then it's not that you're just changing every you can play I think that's your a flexible framework or the framework is not flexible. It gives you flexibility. It gives you flexibility to think broadly differently. I think that is what this framework. That is what the value of this framework is. Yeah. Jason, to your point, first ideas are rarely the best ideas. And so if we can help you be more confident with this process and help you be more fluent in generating new ideas, then you're going to persist and stick around to get the later, really interesting ideas rather than stop at the first idea that's not terrible, which I see so often, right? And people who are really struggling with brainstorming. It's like, Look I had four ideas, it's enough. I'm exhausted. One of these, I hope is good enough. And rather than convincing yourself that your third or fourth idea is good enough, If we make it easier to generate your 12th or your 23rd idea, then you're more likely to have a collection of things that are really interesting to play with and to run from there. And, you know, that lesson from Robbie, right, that that way out there idea is much easier to bring back and make reasonable to work with rather than hoping that your sort of reasonable, conventional idea is somehow one you could push or stretch to be more unusual. That doesn't usually work that way. So I'd rather have you come up with lots of out there ideas because an out there idea, I mean, we gave you the Bertaz chemistry example, right? You know, that sugars were anything interesting you know, on the outside of cells, like, you know, most people fought like, no, there's nothing interesting there, right? So that way out idea turned out to be a Nobel Prize winning idea, right, because people explored it. And so what might seem to you in your brainstorming session to be a way out idea, After you push it and work on it, might turn out to be something that makes a ton of sense. You just hadn't had the perspective by which it made sense yet when you generated it initially. I see, this is and I'm loving this. I know coming to time start wrapping up. But, you know, these ideas that are coming up now, you know, someone said, I think Joel mentioned, you know, homeless shelter and Jay brought in, you know, why don't you grow food there? So, you know, you also have job shelter. I mean, again, this is the beauty of this framework. Once you start going on, and that is what we were talking about the fluency, you know, once you take thinking and you start changing things. And about goals, about events. So someone saying, Can we just you know, climate change problem that Again, now you're thinking very high level like an even broader goal here. And then again, this is a very small problem we started with, but see where it took you. Again, we shouldn't go that much far out of that cannot come back in. But absolutely, I know, but it takes you there, see how you can solve those problems and we talked to Atika about, for example, transportation problems. So in the end, I think in summary, this is a powerful framework. Okay. And I would say, you know, don't just stop using after you finish your assignment, and, you know, this is an assignment. I've used this and you're done? Please you know, start incorporating it in your everyday life, you're at work, you know, you facing a problem, see how you can change something or you know, if you're convincing something to accompany you to a dinner, and they're saying, No, see, you know, how can you C creative parts, can you change? Can you change the restaurant? Can you change the sin? Can you change I mean, think about this and see if you are successful, can you come up with more creative idea? Want to do? I want to pick up on Jay's point about, you know, the Departments of. So many organizations have one or more departments of. It's often legal or compliance, finance, sometimes. And what was interesting to me when I first really started working on creativity is that the The units in companies that contacted me first for creativity training were legal compliance. It was the Department of K because a lot of them don't want to be the Department of No. They want to be the problem solver, they want to get involved when the problem is just being set so that their criteria can be included, and they can be part of the constraints that shape the solutions that are actually productive and useful and valuable rather than have people get creative by going around them. Or ignoring them or avoiding them, right? Because that really causes lots and lots of problems in companies, and it wastes a lot of time, right? To what you think is a great solution, only to have legal or finance or whatever kill your solution because it doesn't meet a criterion you didn't know existed. So the main reason that we're starting with your creativity is precisely because no matter where you are in your organization, if you can think more flexibly and creatively, then you are more likely to get you know, if you show that to other people in your organization, you're more likely to be invited into the conversation early. And so you don't have to be the Department of No and all of that. You can help people create solutions that are really viable and implementable and worthwhile, rather than have to come in to the end and say, I'm really sorry, but this isn't going to work. Or I'm just not sorry. It's not going to work. Right. And so that is something that's part of your own tool kit, right? Your own set of capabilities that you can apply, again, no matter what it is you're actually working on. Right. And then we're going to talk about this Clement is talking and say, you know, I know it's funny sense she's saying, you know, all we need is the world to listen to us. And as we go through this course, we will talk about that. How can we make you know, Coming up with creative ideas is one thing. It is a starting point. But then how do you make people listen to your creative ideas? How do you get them on board. And we will talk about that as we go through the discourse. So please stay with us. Thank we'll get there. I wrap up. Time to wrap up. So obviously, our goal here is to help you think about the creative process and develop your skills at going through it. And we first talked about cues and how can you get to be more sensitized to the cues that you're experiencing and take the invitation they're offering you to go into the creative process. And then, second, Um, when I'm in that creative process and I'm trying to generate alternative perspectives, so I can generate new inventions, I can generate new enlightenments, right? How pages can be part of that process? Can I break my current perspective down? Can I see what's positive about it and what's leading to some initial ideas, and then can I modify it? Can I change something in my current pages and have that send me off in another direction and then cycle back and change a different aspect of pages. And that process of cycling through different aspects of pages and changing them to change your perspective turns out to be a way that many people find helps them fluently and efficiently generate different perspectives and therefore, new ideas. And that's really what we're trying to do today. Absolutely. Alright, so I think we are going to wrap up this session. So only thing, again, I think I've already said this twice, please please start applying again, and this is not only for this session, you know, in the weeks, as we move forward, we'll give you some tools, we'll give you some concepts, start applying them out to your real life, your work life. Creativity that's the beauty of creativity. It is not only about your workspace. It is about your everyday life. Every small little thing, you're you know, trying to come up with a new recipe or you're trying to create dinner or new everywhere you can apply creativity, and start applying these concepts, start applying these frameworks. And see, you know, what you get out of that. And then please come back. Tell us your story. So to hear more about this. Excellent. Thanks for a great conversation today. I know we've sprung a lot on you today, and we look forward to making the most of it in the weeks ahead. Have a great week. All right. See you next week. Thank you.
- Assistant
Thank you for the detailed transcript on your recent live session! Here's a concise summary to retain the main points:
Summary of the Live Session on Creativity and Perspective:
-
Introduction and Module Update:
- Expressed excitement about returning and interacting with participants.
- Discussed the completion of the first brainstorming assignment and the upcoming second brainstorming task related to creativity.
- Previewed a role-playing negotiation activity, "Blue Light Discussion," for next week involving characters Gregg and Healy.
-
Focus on Creativity:
- Emphasized that creativity involves developing new perspectives.
- Identified three key outcomes: Insights (new ways of seeing), Inventions (new products or processes), and Enlightenments (new concepts or knowledge).
-
Perspectives Matter:
- Differentiated between perspectives and reality.
- Gave examples (checker shadow illusion, Smokey the Bear, Bertozzi's chemistry insight) to illustrate how perspectives shape understanding and solutions.
-
Pages Framework:
- Introduced the "Pages" framework to articulate and shift perspectives, consisting of Parts (nouns), Actions (verbs), Goals (motivations), Events (contexts), and Self-concept (roles).
- Demonstrated how changing aspects of Pages can generate new perspectives and solutions.
-
Interactive Activity:
- Assigned a problem - how to utilize vacant office space.
- Participants brainstormed using the Pages framework, generating varied ideas from urban laser tag and community events to public transportation enhancements.
-
Reflection and Takeaways:
- Emphasized the value of frequent perspective changes for creativity.
- Encouraged the application of the Pages framework beyond the session, in both professional and personal contexts.
- Mentioned future sessions will cover how to pitch creative ideas effectively.
Feel free to ask if you need more detailed bullet points or additional information on any specific segment!
-
- User
Please just give the answer to these questions based on the transcript of a lecture you just read --- Which of the following examples is closest to the blanket with sleeves example in highlighting the opportunity in something most people overlooked due to taking for granted that they already knew its value?
Group of answer choices
Checkerboard
Smokey Bear
M&Ms/barcodes
Computer theft
Vacant office space
Flag question: Question 2 Question 20.5 pts As highlighted by Scott Page, perspectives can make problems hard and make us confused. Group of answer choices
True
False
Flag question: Question 3 Question 30.5 pts Intellectual property was an example of a change in parts, as discussed in the example of theft of company resources. Group of answer choices
True
False
Flag question: Question 4 Question 40.5 pts Cycling through different aspects of PAGES during a brainstorming process helps ease the task of fluently generating alternative perspectives. Group of answer choices
True
False
- Assistant
Certainly! Here are the answers based on the transcript:
Question 1: Which of the following examples is closest to the blanket with sleeves example in highlighting the opportunity in something most people overlooked due to taking for granted that they already knew its value?
- Group of answer choices:
- Checkerboard
- Smokey Bear
- M&Ms/barcodes (Correct Answer)
- Computer theft
- Vacant office space
The M&Ms/barcodes example, where scientists previously considered sugars on cell walls simply as a protective layer but later discovered their valuable role as barcodes, is closest to the blanket with sleeves example in terms of highlighting overlooked opportunities.
Question 2: As highlighted by Scott Page, perspectives can make problems hard and make us confused.
- Group of answer choices:
- True (Correct Answer)
- False
True. The transcript notes Scott Page's point that different perspectives can simplify problems but can also muddle and make problems seem difficult.
Question 3: Intellectual property was an example of a change in parts, as discussed in the example of theft of company resources.
- Group of answer choices:
- True (Correct Answer)
- False
True. The transcript mentions how intellectual property theft was a change in parts from initially thinking about physical items (like computers) being stolen.
Question 4: Cycling through different aspects of PAGES during a brainstorming process helps ease the task of fluently generating alternative perspectives.
- Group of answer choices:
- True (Correct Answer)
- False
True. The transcript emphasizes that the process of cycling through different aspects of PAGES helps in generating various perspectives and ideas more fluently.
These answers are verified based on the content provided in the transcript.
- Group of answer choices:
- User
are you sure it is not checkerboard?
- Assistant
I understand your consideration, but based on the context provided in the lecture transcript, the M&Ms/barcodes example is most closely related to the blanket with sleeves example. Both examples highlight how a previously undervalued or overlooked element can lead to significant insights or innovations when revisited from a new perspective.
However, let's revisit the reasoning:
- Checkerboard: This example was used to illustrate how perspectives can distort our perception of reality, but it doesn't highlight overlooked value in the same way.
- Smokey Bear: This example shows how a widely accepted perspective (no forest fires) can have unintended consequences. It doesn't parallel the innovation aspect as strongly.
- M&Ms/barcodes: This example highlights how the overlooked sugars on cell walls were later discovered as barcodes, representing a significant finding from something assumed to be of little value.
- Computer theft: This was part of the exercise in shifting perspectives using the Pages framework, not an example of overlooked opportunity.
- Vacant office space: This also served as a brainstorming prompt and not a direct example of overlooked value.
Given these points, I reaffirm that the M&Ms/barcodes example best parallels how overlooked elements can yield unexpected opportunities when revisited, much like the innovative creation of the blanket with sleeves (Snuggie).
Therefore, the correct match remains:
- M&Ms/barcodes
This is based on the specific criteria outlined in your question regarding overlooked opportunities and newly discovered value.