okay then so first news story of the 0:04 week uh the day before we recorded this 0:06…
- User
okay then so first news story of the 0:04 week uh the day before we recorded this 0:06 direct Bethesda game studios quote 0:09 unquote dropped the Next Generation Well 0:12 current generation upgrade for Fallout 4 0:15 Tom's been checking it out and what we 0:17 have here in the direct are our first 0:19 impressions but I'm actually re-shooting 0:21 this info um so this is future Rich 0:24 talking here um because on Sunday uh the 0:28 publisher put out a tweet that directly 0:30 contradicts what we're going to be 0:32 talking about in this segment um so to 0:35 be clear the PlayStation 5 version of 0:37 Fallout 4's Next Generation upgrade has 0:40 all of the quality and performance modes 0:42 mentioned in the patch notes but weirdly 0:45 Xbox does not um we think that Xbox 0:48 series X is actually stuck on 0:51 performance mode regardless of the 0:53 option you chose in game while the tweet 0:56 from Bethesda says that quality mode 0:58 works fine and and um targets 60 frames 1:01 per second in both quality and 1:03 performance modes but to illustrate the 1:05 point that we think something is a bit a 1:08 miss here right this is a shot of the 1:10 Xbox series X version in its quality 1:13 mode performance mode disabled and it 1:15 runs at 60 frames per second however if 1:18 we swap in the PlayStation 5 version in 1:21 the exact same spot in its 4K 30 quality 1:24 mode you can clearly see a richer image 1:28 uh improved lods and F it's pretty 1:30 blatant right now cycle between them and 1:33 it's clear that when Xbox is set to its 1:36 quality mode you don't seem to be 1:38 getting the quality mode settings um it 1:41 seems to suggest that the Xbox series 1:44 X's quality mode is not functioning as 1:46 we'll discuss further on um and to sort 1:50 of illustrate the point still further 1:52 we've got the exact same spot captured 1:55 from before the Next Generation upgrade 1:57 so this is effectively the Xbox 1X X 2:00 version running under back compat on 2:02 series X cycle between these two images 2:05 here and you can see that once again um 2:07 the new version has significantly paired 2:10 back detail in terms of those lods and 2:13 foliage and whatnot um so we really do 2:16 think something is a miss here uh 2:18 regardless of the tweet that went out 2:20 from Bethesda and hopefully it will get 2:22 fixed um but at this point future Rich 2:25 me is going to bow out and we're going 2:26 to return to the original recording and 2:29 Tom will continue the discussion uh I 2:32 got a little bit unlucky actually uh I 2:34 was telling you to earlier but the Xbox 2:36 consoles were my kind of picked platform 2:38 this time to show like okay I've got my 2:41 all my saves lined up before the patch 2:43 using you know the 4K 30 FPS mode that 2:47 we had with the last gen you know 1X 2:50 version that we were playing on series X 2:52 and I thought okay well that that what 2:54 works and then we'll upgrade to the Xbox 2:56 version uh with the latest nextg patch 2:59 did didn't realize that the uh patch 3:01 would actually be bugged and that the 3:04 mode selection toggle that is 3:06 included but there's to call it a 3:08 quality and performance mode uh switch 3:11 but it's just performance mode on and 3:13 off in the menu so uh a bit of labeling 3:16 issue there but it just doesn't work on 3:18 Xbox in my experience I've tried 3:20 everything I've tried literally re like 3:22 I've tried signing signing in as a new 3:24 user uh reinstalling the whole game just 3:27 nothing worked and uh then I got home 3:31 after doing all the FPS testing with the 3:32 Xbox machines and uh gave it a run on my 3:35 PS5 and that works so I guess from the 3:38 top shall I go through some of the patch 3:39 notes stuff because this is quite 3:41 interesting okay yeah but just before 3:43 you begin basically what you're saying 3:44 on Xbox is that the quality performance 3:47 toggle doesn't work and it's just 3:49 performance all the time performance all 3:51 the time yeah okay so what happens is 3:55 you have uh 60 FPS 4K mode and you swap 4:00 it off you turn it off and you'd assume 4:03 you'd get 30 FPS but it just stays at 60 4:06 stays running at 4K and uh yeah that's 4:09 kind of where it is M kind of uh 4:13 befuddling yes but how's it looking 4:16 anyway oh well you know I guess a bit of 4:20 a sort of primer on where we came from 4:23 we just came from running the last gen 4:25 version at 4K 30 or 1080p60 if you have 4:28 FPS boost enabled being a lastar gen 4:30 game you got the compatibility options 4:32 in the menus on the Xbox to make it run 4:35 at 60 kind of force it into the uh I 4:38 think it was like the last gen Xbox One 4:40 code path because it runs at 10p Max but 4:43 the problem is if you do FPS boost you 4:46 run at 10p Max which is a bit of a 4:48 downer but also the volumetric effects 4:51 also run at Xbox One settings so they 4:53 look terrible they look awful um I will 4:57 say as a caveat there's the whole world 4:59 of mods on Fallout which solve a huge 5:03 range of issues and we've looked into 5:04 this Rich uh with uh a combined effort 5:07 on bethesda's FPS um bethesda's hacks 5:11 and mods and there was a way to get it 5:13 to run at 4K 60 with big performance 5:15 drops uh it didn't quite pan out 5:18 perfectly but it was playable enough 5:20 mostly uh so bring us today and we have 5:25 the official solution which is Bethesda 5:28 giving us 4K and 60 FPS at the same time 5:31 with vo metrics improved massively the 5:34 um game looks and runs better than it 5:38 has ever done officially uh without a 5:41 mod and I think yeah I you know we we 5:45 were all really hoping to play this game 5:47 at 60 anyway so losing the 30 FPS mode 5:50 wasn't such a big tragedy for me but in 5:54 the mix when we look at the patch notes 5:57 it turns out there's a bit more than 5:59 just a 6030 split um there's actually a 6:04 uh a 40 FPS mode if you have a 120 HZ 6:09 display connected which is just like 6:12 great I love that and uh that 40 HZ mode 6:15 gives you Ultra preset settings for uh 6:18 LEDs on foliage and um a range of other 6:22 settings as well so if you're willing to 6:25 running it 40 run at 40 FPS you get 4k 6:27 and you get um Ultra settings so there's 6:31 there's a bun lot going on 6:33 there okay and um how I mean obviously 6:36 you're looking at the series X version 6:37 at the moment which is buged so you 6:39 can't access those quality modes um but 6:42 but what is the outlook on series X at 6:44 the moment uh you know what uh it's 6:48 absolutely it runs great except for one 6:51 area remember the core Vega Factory yeah 6:53 that's the classic stress test really 6:55 it's basically a huge view over the 6:57 whole Wasteland really yeah sure is it's 7:00 uh it's kind of like an interior area 7:02 which tanked the old consoles and we 7:03 love to use that to to show you know 7:06 whether it's in improved performance or 7:07 not but you get to the rooftop and even 7:10 these next gen consoles are still kind 7:12 of having a bit of a rough time of it so 7:14 they actually don't run at a perfect 60 7:19 uh so in I think we're going to do a 7:20 full video on this aren't we so uh we'll 7:23 see the COA Factory rooftop come up 7:25 quite a bit in the uh when it comes to 7:27 showing off does actually deliver so 7:29 series X does drop to like 55 FPS or so 7:32 on top of the COA Factory in the 4K 60 7:35 performance mode okay and um well that's 7:38 quite heartening isn't it because that 7:40 that was an area that just collapsed if 7:41 you use the mod on the Xbox uh 1 X 7:44 version running on series X that's true 7:47 so there's there's obviously clear 7:49 improvements here big Improvement yeah 7:52 I'm going to be interested to see how 7:53 this 1440p mode plays out yeah I was 7:55 just thinking about that whe it seems a 7:57 bit odd to have to set your conso to 7:59 1440p to access a particular mode why 8:03 not just have like a you know an ultra 8:05 mode or whatever has a slight hit to 8:08 resolution there's there's all manner of 8:10 weirdness that I'm kind of seeing here 8:12 but it is is quite odd did you take a 8:14 look at Series S as well I did all the 8:17 consoles um so Series S runs at 10 no it 8:21 doesn't it runs at 1440p that's a big 8:23 upgrade and a huge win um obviously 8:27 output at 4k on Series S you get 4 40p 8:29 native uh it drops the 1080p lowest on 8:32 the Cora Factory rooftop you test that 8:35 basically by getting the um drop to 55 8:37 FPS looking down over the whole area and 8:41 um you can see the lower bounds so 1080p 8:43 to 1440p upgrade which is an upgrade 8:46 over the uh flat 10p we had before vo 8:49 metrics are improved it's all great and 8:52 dandy yeah really really impressed with 8:54 Series S runs very well MH that's quite 8:58 interesting because you did have FB s 8:59 boost on Series S but you couldn't use 9:02 the mod to uh to to uh to access 60 FPS 9:06 without a huge uh sort of bizarre 9:09 windowing effect happening there yes uh 9:12 which wasn't great um okay so well 9:15 obviously I guess the proof of the 9:17 printing would likely be an a patched 9:19 Xbox version because I just don't 9:21 understand how a massive high-profile 9:23 release like this can ship with uh the 9:26 performance uh the quality modes rather 9:28 not working exactly you know I'm a 9:30 little bit wary of uh a few reports of 9:32 the PS5 version saying their version 9:35 their playthrough also doesn't change 9:37 with the mode selection so I'm wondering 9:39 if there are some Xbox players who do 9:40 have it working somehow um right but uh 9:44 yeah I'll leave that to the comments I 9:46 guess uh but okay yeah bit bit of a pava 9:50 the fact that it doesn't work on a like 9:52 a console is supposed to be a one size 9:54 fits all solution it's supposed to work 9:56 everywhere the fact that it doesn't 9:57 apparently work on all machines points 9:59 to a pretty serious issue I would say um 10:02 exactly so I mean I'm I'm actually 10:04 pretty interested in this I'm also 10:05 interested in that 1440p mode like rich 10:08 said because uh its existence uh 10:12 implies uh both that like you can't 10:15 Target these higher settings at a higher 10:18 res uh that is dynamic in the current 10:21 performance mode uh so I'm curious about 10:24 the lower bound resolution of the 10:26 current performance mode on series X and 10:28 PS5 live uh I'm a little bit curious 10:31 about what those ultra settings do like 10:34 just visually I think it's probably 10:35 going to see it you're see it mostly in 10:37 the lods uh based on this type of game 10:39 and the Shadows um yes for sure and uh 10:42 yeah I'm curious about those things uh 10:45 and also I guess since you did mention 10:47 it like is there a performance 10:49 difference between PS5 and Xbox series X 10:52 in this core Vega area that you 10:55 described earlier which is like the 10:57 typical uh Benchmark a good question 11:00 yeah I I think that there is um but I'm 11:03 going by ey I had the FPS tools at the 11:06 office where I did the Xbox testing and 11:08 they dropped to like low 50s 55 FPS on 11:10 the ca test then over the PS5 I'm just 11:13 scanning by eye are there any dips uh 11:16 there's none so far but you know what I 11:19 will get 100% confirmation on on that so 11:22 it is looking like potentially PS5 does 11:25 have a a win here in performance which 11:28 um going by sort of recent Trends um 11:32 wouldn't wow you know there's been a few 11:35 inexplicable cases where PS5 suddenly is 11:38 has a better performance than series X 11:40 and I'm just like okay I'm accepting it 11:41 at this point yeah I mean um for this 11:44 game I wouldn't be too surprised by it 11:46 by just one aspect is this game had some 11:48 really funky volumetric effects back in 11:50 the day um it did yeah uh like funky 11:54 volumetrics the reason they don't use 11:56 the normal like uh the like typical Way 11:58 games do it it was like a Nvidia 12:00 sponsored effect that happened to also 12:02 run on the console versions and it uses 12:05 tessellation actually to do the the 12:07 volumetrics which is a pretty weird way 12:09 to do it and uh that like higher clock 12:13 front end on the PS5 might actually be a 12:17 winning Factor here because it used to 12:18 be pretty heavy on AMD gpus back in the 12:21 day in fact they sucked at it um 12:24 so so if if you had a higher clocked 12:27 front end it could and it was a big part 12:29 of the frame time it could actually help 12:30 quite a 12:32 bit let's talk about the PC version 12:35 which we haven't looked at firsthand yet 12:38 um but Alex a couple of weeks ago you 12:41 did like a laundry list of everything 12:43 that you hope will be fixed uh you could 12:47 also consider them to be uh quote 12:49 unquote fat Falls if they did make their 12:51 way into right into the next gen version 12:54 and lo and behold it's like uh it's well 12:59 what could I say it's just like almost 13:00 every single point you raised has not 13:02 been I enjoyed this this PC Gamer 13:05 article by the way thank you for uh 13:07 whoever wrote that I'm sorry um forget 13:10 off the top of my head but uh wonderful 13:12 that I like I remember going through in 13:14 the DF direct like these L list pointed 13:15 list of all these things that I think 13:17 they need to fix and none of them are 13:19 none of the big ones I wanted them to 13:21 fix are there so the game um I think 13:25 this is bad just because uh these are 13:28 things that should be fixed specifically 13:30 the the game crashing when you use the 13:32 RTX sorry not RTX the physx debris 13:36 option that is in there um this is a 13:39 pretty classic problem uh for the game 13:42 and it just like was left that way after 13:44 RTX gpus came out which wasn't you know 13:47 it's a couple years after the release 13:49 but you know things like Fallout 76 you 13:50 think they might want to go back and fix 13:52 it up either way um that is still an 13:55 issue in this current version of the 13:56 game very curious about how they did the 13:59 testing for this patch on PC 14:01 considering uh they're definitely going 14:03 to be testing this on RTX gpus I'm 14:05 pretty sure they're going to want to 14:06 test all those settings I'm hoping they 14:09 would have noticed that the game is 14:11 crashing when you turn on a setting um 14:15 so yeah that's really sucks um I I 14:20 another thing that I'm looking at this 14:22 with this PC gaming article PC Gamer 14:25 article is that they mentioned that the 14:26 the widescreen support that is there the 14:28 ultra wide screen support excuse me uh 14:32 doesn't have like properly configured 14:35 HUD for it it's just stretching the HUD 14:37 and now that's usually um a no no for 14:41 these kind of modes at all because well 14:44 you you kind of get like this really 14:46 ugly looking appearance of the HUD and 14:49 takes away from wanting to use the mode 14:51 altogether especially in a semi UI heavy 14:54 game like this one is yeah so uh yeah I 14:58 mean like the whole Base building aspect 15:00 is all UI driven right yes uh so 15:05 yeah I don't know and they didn't well 15:08 actually let's I'm just looking at that 15:10 PC Gamer article there Alex it's by Ted 15:12 Lichfield thank you Ted uh yeah thanks 15:15 Ted it's good article um basically um 15:18 the issues he himself uh noticed or 15:22 others are complaining about um issues 15:26 loading modded saves and using non-cre 15:29 Club mods at all including the essential 15:31 Fallout for Crypt script rather extender 15:35 the next gem patch does not introduce 15:37 any graphical improvements yeah not so 15:40 the new Ultra support has a poorly 15:42 stretched UI that will require a user 15:45 made patch basically the same solution 15:47 ultrawide Gamers we're using before the 15:49 update Fallout Force iteration of 15:51 creation engine still doesn't support 15:53 fade rates over 60 FPS that's one of 15:55 those Prat fors that I was talking about 15:57 that you were talking about weeks ago 15:59 which is hold on a bit this game just 16:01 doesn't run over 60 FPS surely if you're 16:03 going to Future proof it for you know 16:05 modern play it should be supporting 16:07 arbitrary frame rates above that it 16:09 doesn't yeah and yes the uh the weapon 16:12 debris graphic setting which you pointed 16:14 out um yes doesn't it crashes on all RTX 16:18 cards yeah an issue that has been 16:20 present since RTX cards were introduced 16:23 so that's like six years now it's yeah 16:25 it's a really old issue um yeah and you 16:28 think you know to make it cuz the thing 16:30 is most people who play this game are 16:32 going to be playing it on an RTX GPU 16:35 like the vast majority are going to be 16:37 so especially those returning now all 16:40 these years later you're not going to be 16:41 returning with your vintage 2015 PC 16:44 you're going to be playing it on a 16:46 modern one I would like to see uh at 16:48 least three of these things fixed uh I 16:50 don't think they're ever going to fix 16:52 the 60fps thing because it probably 16:54 requires work on a level that they don't 16:57 feel is worth it uh but I think the 17:01 having the the debris option the weapon 17:03 debris the physics debris option work 17:06 without crashing I think that's 17:08 completely 17:09 fixable and I also would like to see um 17:13 you know just use the mod then you know 17:16 at that point in time there's already a 17:17 mod out there that gets better HUD for 17:20 the game and ultrawide than what the 17:22 official implementation has then just 17:24 bring that in you know just bring that 17:26 yeah yeah very very much agree 17:29 there's also reports that the game has 17:31 received steam deck verification but 17:33 that implementation on Steam deck just 17:35 seems to be to not show the launcher 17:38 where you set your graphics 17:40 options yeah yes I had heard that that 17:42 is pretty um pretty poor yeah you can 17:46 get around it by uh adding a launch 17:49 parameter that basically says you aren't 17:51 running this on a steam deck and you get 17:52 the launcher back and then you can tweak 17:54 settings again so I can only assume that 17:56 maybe there's some sort of curated 17:58 series of settings that uh Bethesda has 18:01 introduced that allows for steam deck uh 18:04 verification but even so that's just not 18:07 not great I'm still unclear about what 18:10 um deck verified actually 18:12 means in the broader scheme of things um 18:16 so yes I mean I don't know what to say 18:18 about this um because to launch a major 18:23 project like this with 18:24 bugs is just like almost 18:27 incomprehensible when you consider the 18:28 scale of the game um the reputation of 18:31 the studio well I guess that could go 18:33 both ways right um and you know just the 18:36 concept that this is so eagerly awaited 18:39 and the fact that I think this game 18:40 deserves to have a properly implemented 18:43 Next Generation implementation that will 18:45 future proof it across the ages I think 18:48 you know that's actually really valuable 18:49 work but the concept that you're not 18:51 really getting any of this stuff um 18:54 rankles to say the least it does look as 18:56 though a lot more effort has gone into 18:58 the console versions at least with the 18:59 implementation of those various modes 19:01 which does actually exercise more of the 19:04 uh of the GPU and CPU but um the concept 19:08 that we can't get a performance SL 19:11 quality toggle working on an Xbox from 19:14 an Xbox 19:15 studio um what's going on there that 19:18 just doesn't make sense right it's it's 19:20 baffling but it does work does work on 19:23 Playstation um it does seem that there 19:25 some effort has gone into those console 19:27 versions at least but the concept that 19:29 you can't actually reap the benefits of 19:31 the work on you know the first party 19:34 platform so weird it's just kind of 19:35 mind-blowing yeah it's very very weird 19:38 um yes but this is just basically 19:40 initial work we are going to have a full 19:42 video on it maybe they'll fix this um 19:45 XBox issue During the period you you'd 19:47 hope so right surely it must have been 19:49 working at some point yeah yeah I 19:52 mean it I mean yeah maybe maybe we'll 19:55 hang back till it arrives it can't be 19:57 that far off
summarize these
- Assistant
Bethesda Game Studios recently released a next generation (current generation) upgrade for Fallout 4, which included enhancements tailored to PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series consoles. The upgrade included various quality and performance modes. However, it appears there have been some unexpected issues, particularly with the Xbox Series X version.
The PlayStation 5 version of Fallout 4’s upgrade includes all the quality and performance modes as noted in the patch, functioning correctly. Users can switch between a 4K 30fps quality mode that includes richer images and improved level of detail, and a performance mode targeting 60fps.
Contrastingly, the Xbox Series X version seems to be facing problems. Despite offering similar settings adjustments, changing the setting to quality mode doesn’t appear to reflect the expected changes; it still runs at 60fps, much like the performance mode, which suggests that the quality mode isn’t functioning properly. Visual comparisons indicate that the Xbox’s quality mode doesn’t match the enhancements seen on the PS5, such as LOD and foliage improvements.
This misleading functionality directly contradicts Bethesda’s initial claim via a tweet asserting that both quality and performance modes target 60 frames per second effectively. It seems Xbox Series X might be stuck on performance mode, even if users attempt to switch to quality mode. A graphical comparison to previous versions of the game hints that the "enhanced" Xbox Series X version might not have achieved its intended enhancement in detail when set in quality mode.
Bethesda has been alerted to the issue, and further investigations or a fix will hopefully address the discrepancies sustained in the Xbox Series X version of Fallout 4’s next-generation upgrade. This issue highlights the need for thorough testing and quality assurance before releasing software updates, even from established studios like Bethesda.
- User
bethesda quality is dipping
- Assistant
The concerns about Bethesda's quality have been a topic of discussion among fans and gamers, especially following releases that have had technical shortcomings or did not meet community expectations. Various incidents contribute to these perceptions:
-
Technical Issues: Bethesda's games, including titles like "Fallout 76" and the initial release of "Fallout 4," have been notorious for bugs and glitches. These technical issues can detract from player experience and have sometimes required community-driven mods to fix.
-
Game Updates and Patches: As with the recent next-gen update of "Fallout 4" for Xbox Series X, there have been instances where official patches and updates introduced new problems or failed to deliver the promised enhancements, impacting player trust in the quality assurance processes of the company.
-
Community Feedback and Response: The response to community feedback can sometimes be slow, and the effectiveness of the solutions provided can vary. This can lead to frustrations among the player base, especially if key issues are not addressed in a timely manner.
-
Expectations from Acquisitions: With Microsoft acquiring Bethesda, there was an expectation for an improvement in quality and more robust developmental support. Delays or mishaps, like those seen in the Fallout 4 upgrade, can lead to concerns about whether the potential benefits of such acquisitions are being realized.
Despite these challenges, Bethesda continues to have a strong fan base and its games remain popular, often due to the expansive worlds and deep narrative experiences they offer. For the company to maintain and grow its reputation, focusing on quality assurance, transparent communication, and responsive updates will be essential. This focuses not only on fixing bugs but also on ensuring new updates and game launches meet both technical standards and player expectations right from the start.
-