Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-0125-preview· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

0:0:0.0 --> 0:0:1.490 Keith Low That one is a user journey. 0:0:1.500 --> 0:0:12.470…

  1. User

    0:0:0.0 --> 0:0:1.490 Keith Low That one is a user journey. 0:0:1.500 --> 0:0:12.470 Keith Low Uh, all the various scenario, I think various this is more on the in import in mechanism OK probably they are related because of all the different scenario. 0:0:16.0 --> 0:0:16.440 Duraid Wadie OK. 0:0:19.310 --> 0:0:20.970 Duraid Wadie So what do we actually mean by the? 0:0:20.980 --> 0:0:23.760 Duraid Wadie What mechanism is mean like through API through CSV? 0:0:23.770 --> 0:0:24.750 Duraid Wadie Is that what we're talking about? 0:0:25.500 --> 0:0:26.70 Keith Low Uh, yes. 0:0:26.420 --> 0:0:26.790 Keith Low Uh. 0:0:27.150 --> 0:0:27.290 Duraid Wadie But. 0:0:26.800 --> 0:0:35.910 Keith Low At the moment, the information that I gathered from all the products is, uh, work right does not support API whereas the rest they they do. 0:0:37.0 --> 0:0:39.500 Keith Low But CSV all of them they they do. 0:0:44.500 --> 0:0:46.150 Duraid Wadie OK, so how does work right? 0:0:46.160 --> 0:0:47.600 Duraid Wadie Get the users and it's all manually. 0:0:48.740 --> 0:0:54.200 Keith Low Uh, they have all the various different ways, including FTP emails. 0:0:56.510 --> 0:0:57.460 Keith Low CSV. Excel. 0:0:58.620 --> 0:1:5.740 Keith Low Uh, well, let me see what that Elliott we. 0:1:14.870 --> 0:1:16.640 Keith Low Yeah, there's no API. 0:1:17.290 --> 0:1:19.680 Keith Low They also have a bulk import through FTP. 0:1:23.90 --> 0:1:23.460 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:1:23.470 --> 0:1:26.770 Duraid Wadie So there is some file, but what is that file look like? 0:1:26.780 --> 0:1:31.740 Duraid Wadie The actual content is it CSV, do they support Jason? 0:1:31.750 --> 0:1:31.930 Duraid Wadie What? 0:1:31.940 --> 0:1:36.540 Duraid Wadie What are actually the format they support when one they do them? 0:1:36.590 --> 0:1:42.130 Duraid Wadie Or that's really the critical part for for the Dev guys and the platform to understand. 0:1:46.400 --> 0:1:46.600 Duraid Wadie So. 0:1:45.860 --> 0:1:47.290 Keith Low Yeah, what I was told here. 0:1:47.300 --> 0:1:48.120 Keith Low OK, manual entry. 0:1:49.510 --> 0:1:49.710 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:1:48.960 --> 0:1:50.670 Keith Low Excel, FTP. 0:1:51.680 --> 0:1:57.400 Keith Low Uh web services, which is a true HTTP and XML, uh. 0:1:59.740 --> 0:2:1.610 Keith Low BFTP they support uh. 0:2:5.770 --> 0:2:6.250 Keith Low CSV. 0:2:8.480 --> 0:2:9.680 Keith Low And I think that's about all. 0:2:11.690 --> 0:2:12.120 Duraid Wadie Right. 0:2:12.230 --> 0:2:12.460 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:2:12.470 --> 0:2:12.760 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:2:12.770 --> 0:2:15.180 Duraid Wadie So really they support XML CSV. 0:2:15.190 --> 0:2:18.850 Duraid Wadie That's what's been mentioned from here, OK. 0:2:21.10 --> 0:2:21.400 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:2:21.410 --> 0:2:25.500 Duraid Wadie So do we actually have the format of the files? 0:2:25.580 --> 0:2:27.180 Duraid Wadie I mean, how does the file look like? 0:2:27.190 --> 0:2:27.520 Duraid Wadie Do they? 0:2:27.590 --> 0:2:28.770 Duraid Wadie Do they send us some examples? 0:2:31.500 --> 0:2:32.760 Keith Low I don't have it. 0:2:34.40 --> 0:2:34.990 Keith Low OK, this is required. 0:2:35.0 --> 0:2:37.970 Keith Low I put down as a one of the note we we need this file. 0:2:40.310 --> 0:2:41.900 Duraid Wadie Yeah, we need this file. 0:2:41.910 --> 0:2:42.980 Duraid Wadie It's not just really. 0:2:43.20 --> 0:2:43.660 Duraid Wadie I mean, what? 0:2:43.670 --> 0:2:44.560 Duraid Wadie What's I mean? 0:2:44.570 --> 0:2:56.930 Duraid Wadie The same thing is that what's already gonna happen in in the platform, right, so let's say we start with the CSV import, then our API somehow they would need to talk to this API the customer now. 0:2:58.20 --> 0:3:11.50 Duraid Wadie But that's what really happened so that the customer there, their front end really it's it's it's our API and and and the UI no not those products anymore because we do it one way sync now. 0:3:12.350 --> 0:3:16.400 Duraid Wadie But what API would need to have a proper guide how you would link to it? 0:3:16.410 --> 0:3:21.380 Duraid Wadie How you give it a file, how they can consume it? 0:3:21.880 --> 0:3:22.480 Duraid Wadie That's why. 0:3:22.490 --> 0:3:23.920 Duraid Wadie Why do they have an FTP right? 0:3:23.930 --> 0:3:33.140 Duraid Wadie They have an FTP server or an FTP location so they can update this very often, but that's really what's happening without a lot of. 0:3:33.630 --> 0:3:40.540 Duraid Wadie I would say manual effort, so those guys reading it from an FTP location anything, probably any change has happened. 0:3:40.550 --> 0:3:46.610 Duraid Wadie They would just keep reading it automatically and and they do it update so that that's why they they do it this way. 0:3:47.240 --> 0:3:52.380 Duraid Wadie Well, they would need to consume now our API to do that. 0:3:52.390 --> 0:4:5.770 Duraid Wadie However, if but the integrated product, a few of them are actually keep doing that like there is an allocation where those product lead in this file from, we would need to support a similar thing. 0:4:6.210 --> 0:4:7.90 Duraid Wadie What does that mean? 0:4:7.100 --> 0:4:11.730 Duraid Wadie It's we have a format and we told the customer this is the format. 0:4:13.150 --> 0:4:14.960 Duraid Wadie That's what we need to see the data. 0:4:15.800 --> 0:4:16.40 Keith Low Umm. 0:4:15.20 --> 0:4:19.610 Duraid Wadie That's very important to see how this data is actually getting published, I would say. 0:4:21.510 --> 0:4:22.490 Keith Low OK, I I can. 0:4:24.620 --> 0:4:24.850 Keith Low Umm. 0:4:21.550 --> 0:4:24.960 Duraid Wadie By the customer because yeah, because what happens? 0:4:24.970 --> 0:4:33.800 Duraid Wadie You know, most of those customers have the olden days where they go to their Azure and try ID or whatever they call it. 0:4:33.810 --> 0:4:38.890 Duraid Wadie Now these days that you change the names, they do the export and actually just provide it. 0:4:40.620 --> 0:4:45.460 Duraid Wadie So that system before they don't, I mean before all the skim existed at that times. 0:4:47.630 --> 0:4:49.990 Keith Low OK, well I can do is I can contact all four of them. 0:4:50.620 --> 0:4:54.850 Keith Low Uh to give us the sample CSV. 0:4:57.830 --> 0:4:58.110 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:4:54.860 --> 0:5:5.620 Keith Low Uh data, I think that's what you mentioned so that we can look at what what is inside and and from then what what's next for us, uh, the. 0:5:5.80 --> 0:5:7.50 Duraid Wadie So what what's happening next for us, right? 0:5:7.60 --> 0:5:14.310 Duraid Wadie So we already have a CSV importer, we just need to make sure the API style that's still in the on port. 0:5:15.320 --> 0:5:20.930 Duraid Wadie Uh, the customer can't consumer to a documentations how to guide. 0:5:20.940 --> 0:5:22.520 Duraid Wadie That's the critical part. 0:5:23.790 --> 0:5:32.870 Duraid Wadie Then the next from that will probably need to support allocation somewhere where we drop the CSV file and our system will pick you up and do the on port for that tenant. 0:5:35.570 --> 0:5:37.120 Duraid Wadie So that's your FDP. 0:5:37.170 --> 0:5:39.750 Duraid Wadie But we're not using FTP if that makes sense. 0:5:42.580 --> 0:5:43.30 Keith Low Umm. 0:5:45.0 --> 0:5:52.570 Duraid Wadie So we have to, let's say I don't know, let's say somewhere where the customer can actually qualify all in for us to pick up. 0:5:52.580 --> 0:5:59.960 Duraid Wadie I mean, that's not a good architecture to be honest with you, because that's why skim is invented in the first place. 0:6:1.950 --> 0:6:3.800 Duraid Wadie Skip really invented for that reason. 0:6:3.810 --> 0:6:4.960 Duraid Wadie What is quality cross domain? 0:6:4.970 --> 0:6:8.560 Duraid Wadie Really, user synchronization all about this invented for that reason. 0:6:8.870 --> 0:6:11.710 Duraid Wadie So we will heck up to their Azure ID. 0:6:13.270 --> 0:6:23.140 Duraid Wadie We will have an enterprise uh application on on Azure and that actually doing the synchronizations, but that's really what what scheme is all about. 0:6:24.160 --> 0:6:27.700 Duraid Wadie Are we going to really have time to do it in and now I adopt it? 0:6:27.710 --> 0:6:36.680 Duraid Wadie This I mean this type of stuff I'm talking about to takes actually a month to come up with with the verify the app on on Azure and so on and so on. 0:6:38.600 --> 0:6:42.510 Duraid Wadie So that's definitely has to be on the on the road map to to get there. 0:6:42.580 --> 0:6:50.340 Duraid Wadie I would say we would this type of sink in that will take away the customer patching the API or any CSV import. 0:6:50.350 --> 0:6:51.180 Duraid Wadie All of that goes away. 0:6:54.670 --> 0:7:2.410 Duraid Wadie And he actually happens right up the customer identity itself for every change has happened, it would all happen automatically to us. 0:7:4.620 --> 0:7:7.910 Keith Low OK, I think what we are discussing now has nothing to do with uh. 0:7:7.920 --> 0:7:11.700 Keith Low Whether we go with all zero or cognito, right? Yeah. 0:7:10.650 --> 0:7:12.60 Duraid Wadie I think that they with the mechanism. 0:7:12.70 --> 0:7:12.580 Duraid Wadie No, no, no. 0:7:12.590 --> 0:7:13.610 Duraid Wadie This is like yeah. 0:7:14.260 --> 0:7:16.240 Keith Low It's just a user attribute important. 0:7:16.980 --> 0:7:17.550 Duraid Wadie That's right. 0:7:17.560 --> 0:7:33.520 Duraid Wadie So for example, if they use all zero rocktail, they use Azure ID those identity themselves, they support scaled skim interfaces, so we will have our API helped up to those identities of that makes sense. 0:7:33.520 --> 0:7:33.740 Keith Low Umm. 0:7:33.620 --> 0:7:34.950 Duraid Wadie Then the identities? 0:7:34.960 --> 0:7:42.120 Duraid Wadie Those identities will actually post the changes and we will read them and we will do the changes in our systems. 0:7:43.680 --> 0:7:47.160 Duraid Wadie So that's your what we call it, that's your CSV import really. 0:7:48.870 --> 0:7:50.640 Keith Low Umm, OK, I think, uh. 0:7:50.650 --> 0:7:58.160 Keith Low Previously, we also discussed that, uh, the compulsory attributes would be first name, last name, username and email. 0:7:58.490 --> 0:8:7.830 Keith Low So I think we agreed on this for, for example, like work Rite has a lot of other attribute which is yeah, which we won't care and we just pass back to them. 0:8:8.30 --> 0:8:13.400 Keith Low So I think there won't be and also of central have some other attribute which are. 0:8:13.730 --> 0:8:25.230 Keith Low I got no idea what what are they, but regardless, I will ask them to to list out all the attributes that they have as well as the sample data so that I think we can start working on it. 0:8:25.280 --> 0:8:32.480 Duraid Wadie Yeah, because, you know, like the really the deaf team needs to look at how they're gonna do that, that that's what they are. 0:8:32.490 --> 0:8:32.650 Duraid Wadie How? 0:8:32.660 --> 0:8:37.490 Duraid Wadie How they gonna stream this data from one place to another place saving it locally? 0:8:37.500 --> 0:8:42.300 Duraid Wadie I mean like saving it but don't do anything with it, so they need to figure out this out to Venice with you. 0:8:43.680 --> 0:8:49.270 Duraid Wadie They need to lock up the data the the format of the data, what type and that's why it's important to see it really. 0:8:49.660 --> 0:8:50.990 Duraid Wadie You know the are they using JSON? 0:8:51.0 --> 0:8:51.810 Duraid Wadie Are they using XML? 0:8:51.820 --> 0:9:3.650 Duraid Wadie Because XML is different that actually can have what we call your types on the data that changes the game a bit, where the others formats you don't know it was that type of data is. 0:9:5.100 --> 0:9:12.530 Keith Low Uh, by the way, I think previously we also discussed because of all the four different product may have a different way of importing. 0:9:12.620 --> 0:9:15.250 Keith Low The only common which I can see right now is is CSV. 0:9:15.320 --> 0:9:17.770 Keith Low So we for MVP, we start with the CSV. 0:9:18.440 --> 0:9:19.920 Keith Low So am I right on that? 0:9:21.490 --> 0:9:42.980 Duraid Wadie I mean, if that's if that wants to be the starting point, yes, I would say, but I think Chris probably would need to verify this is the way it's gonna be for the first time VP, because I don't know really how you know the configuration team, the service delivery team, what they, what they say into the customer, right? 0:9:43.410 --> 0:9:47.240 Duraid Wadie Because that's what they say into the customers end of the point from all their manuals. 0:9:47.510 --> 0:10:0.110 Duraid Wadie This is the way we get users then so all of that probably needs to be changed and I don't know where they put all of these, you know, like part of their RFP's when they come to sell it. 0:10:0.380 --> 0:10:2.360 Duraid Wadie All of that needs to be considered here. 0:10:4.520 --> 0:10:4.980 Keith Low Hmm. 0:10:5.790 --> 0:10:18.270 Duraid Wadie So really, if we're gonna say we doing this, it needs to be communicated back to all those product and those products they need to communicate it back probably to the sales parks, they call them what all they the sales documentation goes and all of that. 0:10:23.600 --> 0:10:24.770 Keith Low OK, OK. 0:10:25.740 --> 0:10:26.240 Keith Low Highlight this. 0:10:26.250 --> 0:10:30.300 Keith Low So, Chris, uh, just me and talking, I mean you do. 0:10:30.330 --> 0:10:31.110 Keith Low You have any question? 0:10:36.510 --> 0:10:37.670 Kar King Siew So far, don't for me. 0:10:40.990 --> 0:10:42.160 Jasmine Tang Thanks for going to satisfied. 0:10:43.490 --> 0:10:43.780 Keith Low OK. 0:10:43.790 --> 0:10:48.660 Keith Low I think then let me get those information from all the four products. 0:10:48.670 --> 0:10:57.270 Keith Low In fact, actually I have got a lot of information from them, except that I don't have a sample data, so I will request a in addition to what I've already have. Mm-hmm. 0:10:55.840 --> 0:11:2.100 Duraid Wadie I mean, yeah, I mean talking is do you actually need the sample data or what you've seen so far is OK? 0:11:6.260 --> 0:11:13.690 Kar King Siew Umm, I haven't really seen the sample data, so probably yeah I will need to take a take a look first. 0:11:14.760 --> 0:11:23.720 Keith Low I don't have any sample data as of now, so they they have a I mean like for example Ella told me they they import like like like wow what type of? 0:11:26.580 --> 0:11:39.940 Keith Low Causes they they sign up, or all sorts of information that the attribute is is very weird and also I think also mentioned to me like yeah, using manual using Excel, using FTP and so on. 0:11:39.950 --> 0:11:43.380 Keith Low It's a long list of things, but then it's it's just these bits only. 0:11:43.390 --> 0:11:44.30 Keith Low I don't have anymore. 0:11:44.670 --> 0:11:46.520 Keith Low Uh, uh. 0:11:46.530 --> 0:11:47.540 Keith Low And sample data on it. 0:11:47.550 --> 0:11:51.750 Keith Low I would request from her as well as some other products, and I think you can start looking at it. 0:11:54.150 --> 0:11:54.470 Kar King Siew Yeah. 0:11:54.510 --> 0:11:54.970 Kar King Siew Yeah. Thanks. 0:11:57.500 --> 0:12:1.580 Keith Low Umm OK, I think I think at this point of time, that's all we can do now. 0:12:3.810 --> 0:12:4.170 SueAnn See Uh. 0:12:4.180 --> 0:12:6.0 SueAnn See Can I point out something, Keith? 0:12:4.380 --> 0:12:7.80 Keith Low Yeah. Umm. 0:12:12.0 --> 0:12:12.230 Keith Low Umm. 0:12:7.260 --> 0:12:15.50 SueAnn See OK, so based on the previous emails that you have collected, right, actually I think some of them did provide some samples. 0:12:17.900 --> 0:12:20.300 Keith Low Umm yeah. 0:12:15.60 --> 0:12:31.530 SueAnn See So for example, this is from OPS central is a sample API request to create user and very clearly inside there there's a list of fields and on top of that they have a custom view list which can mean almost anything, right? 0:12:31.540 --> 0:12:31.740 Keith Low Yeah. 0:12:31.540 --> 0:12:33.760 SueAnn See So I think we need to be careful about this. 0:12:34.170 --> 0:12:37.840 SueAnn See Another one is a Devon way, Devon way. 0:12:38.670 --> 0:12:48.600 SueAnn See By reading their documentation, what I find out is that it's a module builder so they can build very flexible modules that has a parent child relationship. 0:12:48.850 --> 0:12:56.420 SueAnn See But what we need to know is that which of those information is really mandatory to be passed in upon a user creation? 0:13:0.660 --> 0:13:1.270 Keith Low Yeah, I agree. 0:13:2.20 --> 0:13:2.290 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:13:2.300 --> 0:13:14.50 SueAnn See So I think these are the details that we need from them, not really just a list of fields, because even if they give us a list of fields, we wouldn't know, like for example, if we don't accept home address, what impact does it cost? 0:13:14.60 --> 0:13:16.320 SueAnn See Is it really mandatory or not? Yeah. 0:13:17.370 --> 0:13:18.390 Keith Low But I think the mandate. 0:13:16.980 --> 0:13:19.770 Duraid Wadie But still do we yeah. 0:13:19.780 --> 0:13:22.790 Duraid Wadie Do we really care what's mandatory or not? 0:13:21.730 --> 0:13:25.70 Keith Low Yeah, correct. 0:13:27.350 --> 0:13:27.740 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:13:22.800 --> 0:13:28.240 Duraid Wadie We have our own mandatory stuff right that the one we have to have and and home but. 0:13:31.880 --> 0:13:32.500 Duraid Wadie Ah, I see. 0:13:32.510 --> 0:13:33.540 Duraid Wadie I see what you mean. 0:13:33.650 --> 0:13:34.80 Duraid Wadie Yeah, yeah. 0:13:27.750 --> 0:13:37.920 SueAnn See So if assuming we don't care right, that means maybe we will have somewhat a structure like this, but this home address will be inside this custom field list. 0:13:38.890 --> 0:13:39.580 Duraid Wadie Yeah, I see. 0:13:39.590 --> 0:13:40.100 Duraid Wadie What you mean? 0:13:40.470 --> 0:13:40.570 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:13:40.110 --> 0:13:41.740 Duraid Wadie Actually, it's not just that, right. 0:13:45.530 --> 0:13:47.720 SueAnn See Yes, correct. Yeah. 0:13:42.190 --> 0:13:48.610 Duraid Wadie It's probably they doing verification from their product right as well, which is also another problem. 0:13:48.620 --> 0:13:48.850 Duraid Wadie OK. 0:13:48.860 --> 0:13:52.430 Duraid Wadie That's actually another big problem that so, yeah. 0:13:52.440 --> 0:13:53.470 Duraid Wadie So on she's got up. 0:13:53.520 --> 0:13:55.630 Duraid Wadie I I mean a very good point here. 0:14:3.370 --> 0:14:3.590 Keith Low Umm. 0:13:55.720 --> 0:14:6.590 Duraid Wadie We need to know the mandatory stuff all the product as well, thus mean bit of fiddle logic that's happening really in in home. 0:14:6.880 --> 0:14:9.700 Duraid Wadie To be honest with you, how do we know what's mandatory or not? 0:14:11.820 --> 0:14:19.130 Keith Low I think in this case it's quite obvious they have to tell us what is mandatory that is actually mandatory for for their product, not for us. 0:14:19.140 --> 0:14:21.720 Keith Low I mean, for us we only need 4/4 attribute. 0:14:24.10 --> 0:14:24.350 Keith Low Yeah. 0:14:23.110 --> 0:14:24.690 Duraid Wadie Yeah, I mean, I didn't think about that. 0:14:24.700 --> 0:14:25.680 Duraid Wadie I mean, that's a great point. 0:14:25.690 --> 0:14:27.680 Duraid Wadie So I mean, that's really a great point. 0:14:27.690 --> 0:14:28.810 Duraid Wadie What she's mentioned here. 0:14:29.480 --> 0:14:30.640 Keith Low You know the the yeah. 0:14:32.290 --> 0:14:44.160 SueAnn See So an another way we can look at it is that in Devonway documents they do have a screenshot of their profile information. 0:14:44.170 --> 0:14:48.450 SueAnn See So this is another place that we probably can get some information from. 0:14:49.810 --> 0:14:55.310 SueAnn See Uh, which looks quite like our profile page for IHOME actually. 0:14:56.790 --> 0:15:3.410 SueAnn See But if you look carefully, there are certain things like there's even an SON point URL here, right? 0:15:3.740 --> 0:15:6.200 SueAnn See So this is the profile page, the one that. 0:15:9.150 --> 0:15:18.760 SueAnn See I don't remember exactly where, but somewhere in this document that that is mentioned about this module builder where people can just build any modules from scratch and there's some parent child relationship. 0:15:20.640 --> 0:15:21.620 Duraid Wadie And in here. 0:15:21.920 --> 0:15:25.910 Duraid Wadie So I'm actually probably your mentioned here, right? 0:15:26.120 --> 0:15:26.430 SueAnn See Hmm. 0:15:26.540 --> 0:15:28.290 Duraid Wadie It's probably the model builder. 0:15:28.300 --> 0:15:31.20 Duraid Wadie They can decide if this is mandatory or non mandatory. 0:15:32.880 --> 0:15:33.450 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:15:33.460 --> 0:15:43.0 SueAnn See One thing I'm not clear about the module builder is whether it's just a it it touches the user profile at all, or it's just the other modules that they're building. 0:15:47.260 --> 0:15:47.740 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:15:50.370 --> 0:15:50.630 SueAnn See Hmm. 0:15:44.90 --> 0:15:54.140 Duraid Wadie Ohh yeah, they can't touch anything their model builders so they can so once they build a model right they can reference the model cross all of the other models. 0:15:54.910 --> 0:15:55.730 SueAnn See Umm. 0:15:56.770 --> 0:16:4.20 Duraid Wadie That that's where the capability really they have and they that's how they really is all what we call it really under the hood is the antler and syntax. 0:16:4.290 --> 0:16:5.400 Duraid Wadie How they doing that? 0:16:6.250 --> 0:16:17.420 Duraid Wadie But for us it's more a bit problematic really, because I think this one actually neither discussion with the with one of the the I think so on. 0:16:17.970 --> 0:16:19.290 SueAnn See Yes. Yeah. 0:16:21.100 --> 0:16:22.380 Keith Low There wouldn't be there what you mean? 0:16:23.400 --> 0:16:25.610 Duraid Wadie Yeah, that's a bit complicated. 0:16:27.230 --> 0:16:28.890 Keith Low Umm, I'll be meeting them tonight. 0:16:28.900 --> 0:16:29.500 Keith Low I can actually. 0:16:30.700 --> 0:16:30.990 Keith Low Uh. 0:16:31.480 --> 0:16:32.730 Keith Low Remind them or bring. 0:16:33.120 --> 0:16:33.970 Keith Low Bring it to them. 0:16:34.40 --> 0:16:36.590 Keith Low But I think we have a very big problem with that. 0:16:36.600 --> 0:16:39.980 Keith Low One way in the sense that the time zone is quite quite bad, yeah. 0:16:39.900 --> 0:16:41.230 Duraid Wadie I know, I know. 0:16:41.900 --> 0:16:42.190 Keith Low Yeah. 0:16:42.200 --> 0:16:43.230 Keith Low Yeah, I think you do have them. 0:16:43.240 --> 0:16:46.930 Keith Low They they, you know, they are mountain time and she's 14 hours to Malaysia time. 0:16:47.0 --> 0:16:47.870 Keith Low So it's a bit tough. 0:16:49.730 --> 0:16:49.970 Keith Low OK. 0:16:49.980 --> 0:16:51.910 Keith Low Anyway, I can bring up to do, uh. 0:16:53.450 --> 0:16:56.660 Duraid Wadie But Chris acted for him is fine because the same similar time zones. 0:16:57.260 --> 0:16:57.720 Keith Low Yeah. 0:16:57.730 --> 0:16:59.350 Keith Low Yeah, two hour difference for him. 0:16:59.400 --> 0:17:0.590 Keith Low He still OK for him? Yeah. 0:16:59.590 --> 0:17:1.330 Duraid Wadie Yeah. Yes. 0:17:4.80 --> 0:17:5.570 Keith Low OK, I'll get this sorted out then. 0:17:5.580 --> 0:17:7.950 Keith Low Uh, coming to you guys and I think the order numbers here. 0:17:11.260 --> 0:17:12.110 Keith Low Yeah, I guess that's all. 0:17:12.120 --> 0:17:12.560 Keith Low Thanks a lot. 0:17:13.480 --> 0:17:14.190 Duraid Wadie Thank you everyone. 0:17:14.200 --> 0:17:14.600 Duraid Wadie Thank you. 0:17:14.300 --> 0:17:14.980 Kar King Siew OK. 0:17:15.220 --> 0:17:15.770 Kar King Siew Thank you. Bye. 0:17:16.380 --> 0:17:16.730 Duraid Wadie Thank you. 0:17:16.740 --> 0:17:16.910 Duraid Wadie Bye bye. 0:17:16.480 --> 0:17:17.70 Keith Low Think about it.

    Based on the transcript attached, list down all the points and the action needed. Re-read the transcript again to make sure nothing is missed before you give out your answer.

  2. Assistant

    Based on the transcript, the following points and actions are needed:

    1. User Import Mechanism Clarification:

      • Action: Determine and clarify the mechanisms through which users can be imported (e.g., API, CSV) for each product/service involved.
    2. Support for APIs and CSV:

      • Action: Confirm which products/services support API and which support CSV import. For those that do not support APIs (e.g., WorkRite), note alternative methods (FTP, emails, Excel, etc.).
    3. Sample Data and Format Requirements:

      • Action: Collect sample data for user imports from all products involved to understand the format and content that is accepted. This includes determining whether formats like JSON or XML are supported and understanding any specific attribute requirements.
    4. Mandatory Fields and Custom Attributes:

      • Action: Identify which attributes are mandatory for each product/service and how custom attributes are handled. This involves understanding and documenting any unique or product-specific attributes, especially those that are mandatory.
    5. Communication with Products/Services for Clarifications:

      • Action: Engage in discussions with representatives from each product/service to obtain clear documentation and sample data, including mandatory attributes and support for custom fields.
    6. Implications of Module Builders on User Profiles:

      • Action: For products that allow users to build custom modules (e.g., Devonway), determine how these can affect user profiles and whether they introduce any mandatory attributes.
    7. API Documentation and Support for User Import:

      • Action: Ensure that detailed API documentation is available for how users can be imported into the system, including guidelines on supported formats, attribute requirements, and handling of custom fields.
    8. Architecture and Data Flow for User Import:

      • Action: Review and possibly redesign the architecture for importing user data to accommodate various formats, mandatory fields, and custom attributes. This may require developing a more flexible data handling system.
    9. Scalability and Future Proofing:

      • Action: Consider the implications of the current user import mechanisms on future scalability and integration capabilities, particularly in terms of supporting standard protocols like SCIM for cross-domain user synchronization.
    10. Coordination with Sales and Marketing:

      • Action: Communicate any changes or requirements in user import processes to sales and marketing teams to ensure that RFPs and customer communications are updated accordingly.
    11. Verification of Data Handling and Import Processes:

      • Action: Once sample data and format/attribute requirements are understood, verify how the system will handle, store, and process this information—especially considering any legal or privacy concerns.
    12. Integration with External Systems (e.g., Azure AD):

      • Action: Explore the potential for and implications of integrating with external identity providers (e.g., Azure AD) using protocols such as SCIM for more streamlined user synchronization and import processes.

    By addressing these points and actions, the team can ensure a comprehensive understanding and implementation of user import mechanisms that are compatible with all involved products/services, accommodating their specific requirements and supporting future scalability and integrations.

  3. User

    0:0:0.0 --> 0:0:1.490 Keith Low That one is a user journey. 0:0:1.500 --> 0:0:12.470 Keith Low Uh, all the various scenario, I think various this is more on the in import in mechanism OK probably they are related because of all the different scenario. 0:0:16.0 --> 0:0:16.440 Duraid Wadie OK. 0:0:19.310 --> 0:0:20.970 Duraid Wadie So what do we actually mean by the? 0:0:20.980 --> 0:0:23.760 Duraid Wadie What mechanism is mean like through API through CSV? 0:0:23.770 --> 0:0:24.750 Duraid Wadie Is that what we're talking about? 0:0:25.500 --> 0:0:26.70 Keith Low Uh, yes. 0:0:26.420 --> 0:0:26.790 Keith Low Uh. 0:0:27.150 --> 0:0:27.290 Duraid Wadie But. 0:0:26.800 --> 0:0:35.910 Keith Low At the moment, the information that I gathered from all the products is, uh, work right does not support API whereas the rest they they do. 0:0:37.0 --> 0:0:39.500 Keith Low But CSV all of them they they do. 0:0:44.500 --> 0:0:46.150 Duraid Wadie OK, so how does work right? 0:0:46.160 --> 0:0:47.600 Duraid Wadie Get the users and it's all manually. 0:0:48.740 --> 0:0:54.200 Keith Low Uh, they have all the various different ways, including FTP emails. 0:0:56.510 --> 0:0:57.460 Keith Low CSV. Excel. 0:0:58.620 --> 0:1:5.740 Keith Low Uh, well, let me see what that Elliott we. 0:1:14.870 --> 0:1:16.640 Keith Low Yeah, there's no API. 0:1:17.290 --> 0:1:19.680 Keith Low They also have a bulk import through FTP. 0:1:23.90 --> 0:1:23.460 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:1:23.470 --> 0:1:26.770 Duraid Wadie So there is some file, but what is that file look like? 0:1:26.780 --> 0:1:31.740 Duraid Wadie The actual content is it CSV, do they support Jason? 0:1:31.750 --> 0:1:31.930 Duraid Wadie What? 0:1:31.940 --> 0:1:36.540 Duraid Wadie What are actually the format they support when one they do them? 0:1:36.590 --> 0:1:42.130 Duraid Wadie Or that's really the critical part for for the Dev guys and the platform to understand. 0:1:46.400 --> 0:1:46.600 Duraid Wadie So. 0:1:45.860 --> 0:1:47.290 Keith Low Yeah, what I was told here. 0:1:47.300 --> 0:1:48.120 Keith Low OK, manual entry. 0:1:49.510 --> 0:1:49.710 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:1:48.960 --> 0:1:50.670 Keith Low Excel, FTP. 0:1:51.680 --> 0:1:57.400 Keith Low Uh web services, which is a true HTTP and XML, uh. 0:1:59.740 --> 0:2:1.610 Keith Low BFTP they support uh. 0:2:5.770 --> 0:2:6.250 Keith Low CSV. 0:2:8.480 --> 0:2:9.680 Keith Low And I think that's about all. 0:2:11.690 --> 0:2:12.120 Duraid Wadie Right. 0:2:12.230 --> 0:2:12.460 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:2:12.470 --> 0:2:12.760 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:2:12.770 --> 0:2:15.180 Duraid Wadie So really they support XML CSV. 0:2:15.190 --> 0:2:18.850 Duraid Wadie That's what's been mentioned from here, OK. 0:2:21.10 --> 0:2:21.400 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:2:21.410 --> 0:2:25.500 Duraid Wadie So do we actually have the format of the files? 0:2:25.580 --> 0:2:27.180 Duraid Wadie I mean, how does the file look like? 0:2:27.190 --> 0:2:27.520 Duraid Wadie Do they? 0:2:27.590 --> 0:2:28.770 Duraid Wadie Do they send us some examples? 0:2:31.500 --> 0:2:32.760 Keith Low I don't have it. 0:2:34.40 --> 0:2:34.990 Keith Low OK, this is required. 0:2:35.0 --> 0:2:37.970 Keith Low I put down as a one of the note we we need this file. 0:2:40.310 --> 0:2:41.900 Duraid Wadie Yeah, we need this file. 0:2:41.910 --> 0:2:42.980 Duraid Wadie It's not just really. 0:2:43.20 --> 0:2:43.660 Duraid Wadie I mean, what? 0:2:43.670 --> 0:2:44.560 Duraid Wadie What's I mean? 0:2:44.570 --> 0:2:56.930 Duraid Wadie The same thing is that what's already gonna happen in in the platform, right, so let's say we start with the CSV import, then our API somehow they would need to talk to this API the customer now. 0:2:58.20 --> 0:3:11.50 Duraid Wadie But that's what really happened so that the customer there, their front end really it's it's it's our API and and and the UI no not those products anymore because we do it one way sync now. 0:3:12.350 --> 0:3:16.400 Duraid Wadie But what API would need to have a proper guide how you would link to it? 0:3:16.410 --> 0:3:21.380 Duraid Wadie How you give it a file, how they can consume it? 0:3:21.880 --> 0:3:22.480 Duraid Wadie That's why. 0:3:22.490 --> 0:3:23.920 Duraid Wadie Why do they have an FTP right? 0:3:23.930 --> 0:3:33.140 Duraid Wadie They have an FTP server or an FTP location so they can update this very often, but that's really what's happening without a lot of. 0:3:33.630 --> 0:3:40.540 Duraid Wadie I would say manual effort, so those guys reading it from an FTP location anything, probably any change has happened. 0:3:40.550 --> 0:3:46.610 Duraid Wadie They would just keep reading it automatically and and they do it update so that that's why they they do it this way. 0:3:47.240 --> 0:3:52.380 Duraid Wadie Well, they would need to consume now our API to do that. 0:3:52.390 --> 0:4:5.770 Duraid Wadie However, if but the integrated product, a few of them are actually keep doing that like there is an allocation where those product lead in this file from, we would need to support a similar thing. 0:4:6.210 --> 0:4:7.90 Duraid Wadie What does that mean? 0:4:7.100 --> 0:4:11.730 Duraid Wadie It's we have a format and we told the customer this is the format. 0:4:13.150 --> 0:4:14.960 Duraid Wadie That's what we need to see the data. 0:4:15.800 --> 0:4:16.40 Keith Low Umm. 0:4:15.20 --> 0:4:19.610 Duraid Wadie That's very important to see how this data is actually getting published, I would say. 0:4:21.510 --> 0:4:22.490 Keith Low OK, I I can. 0:4:24.620 --> 0:4:24.850 Keith Low Umm. 0:4:21.550 --> 0:4:24.960 Duraid Wadie By the customer because yeah, because what happens? 0:4:24.970 --> 0:4:33.800 Duraid Wadie You know, most of those customers have the olden days where they go to their Azure and try ID or whatever they call it. 0:4:33.810 --> 0:4:38.890 Duraid Wadie Now these days that you change the names, they do the export and actually just provide it. 0:4:40.620 --> 0:4:45.460 Duraid Wadie So that system before they don't, I mean before all the skim existed at that times. 0:4:47.630 --> 0:4:49.990 Keith Low OK, well I can do is I can contact all four of them. 0:4:50.620 --> 0:4:54.850 Keith Low Uh to give us the sample CSV. 0:4:57.830 --> 0:4:58.110 Duraid Wadie Yeah. 0:4:54.860 --> 0:5:5.620 Keith Low Uh data, I think that's what you mentioned so that we can look at what what is inside and and from then what what's next for us, uh, the. 0:5:5.80 --> 0:5:7.50 Duraid Wadie So what what's happening next for us, right? 0:5:7.60 --> 0:5:14.310 Duraid Wadie So we already have a CSV importer, we just need to make sure the API style that's still in the on port. 0:5:15.320 --> 0:5:20.930 Duraid Wadie Uh, the customer can't consumer to a documentations how to guide. 0:5:20.940 --> 0:5:22.520 Duraid Wadie That's the critical part. 0:5:23.790 --> 0:5:32.870 Duraid Wadie Then the next from that will probably need to support allocation somewhere where we drop the CSV file and our system will pick you up and do the on port for that tenant. 0:5:35.570 --> 0:5:37.120 Duraid Wadie So that's your FDP. 0:5:37.170 --> 0:5:39.750 Duraid Wadie But we're not using FTP if that makes sense. 0:5:42.580 --> 0:5:43.30 Keith Low Umm. 0:5:45.0 --> 0:5:52.570 Duraid Wadie So we have to, let's say I don't know, let's say somewhere where the customer can actually qualify all in for us to pick up. 0:5:52.580 --> 0:5:59.960 Duraid Wadie I mean, that's not a good architecture to be honest with you, because that's why skim is invented in the first place. 0:6:1.950 --> 0:6:3.800 Duraid Wadie Skip really invented for that reason. 0:6:3.810 --> 0:6:4.960 Duraid Wadie What is quality cross domain? 0:6:4.970 --> 0:6:8.560 Duraid Wadie Really, user synchronization all about this invented for that reason. 0:6:8.870 --> 0:6:11.710 Duraid Wadie So we will heck up to their Azure ID. 0:6:13.270 --> 0:6:23.140 Duraid Wadie We will have an enterprise uh application on on Azure and that actually doing the synchronizations, but that's really what what scheme is all about. 0:6:24.160 --> 0:6:27.700 Duraid Wadie Are we going to really have time to do it in and now I adopt it? 0:6:27.710 --> 0:6:36.680 Duraid Wadie This I mean this type of stuff I'm talking about to takes actually a month to come up with with the verify the app on on Azure and so on and so on. 0:6:38.600 --> 0:6:42.510 Duraid Wadie So that's definitely has to be on the on the road map to to get there. 0:6:42.580 --> 0:6:50.340 Duraid Wadie I would say we would this type of sink in that will take away the customer patching the API or any CSV import. 0:6:50.350 --> 0:6:51.180 Duraid Wadie All of that goes away. 0:6:54.670 --> 0:7:2.410 Duraid Wadie And he actually happens right up the customer identity itself for every change has happened, it would all happen automatically to us. 0:7:4.620 --> 0:7:7.910 Keith Low OK, I think what we are discussing now has nothing to do with uh. 0:7:7.920 --> 0:7:11.700 Keith Low Whether we go with all zero or cognito, right? Yeah. 0:7:10.650 --> 0:7:12.60 Duraid Wadie I think that they with the mechanism. 0:7:12.70 --> 0:7:12.580 Duraid Wadie No, no, no. 0:7:12.590 --> 0:7:13.610 Duraid Wadie This is like yeah. 0:7:14.260 --> 0:7:16.240 Keith Low It's just a user attribute important. 0:7:16.980 --> 0:7:17.550 Duraid Wadie That's right. 0:7:17.560 --> 0:7:33.520 Duraid Wadie So for example, if they use all zero rocktail, they use Azure ID those identity themselves, they support scaled skim interfaces, so we will have our API helped up to those identities of that makes sense. 0:7:33.520 --> 0:7:33.740 Keith Low Umm. 0:7:33.620 --> 0:7:34.950 Duraid Wadie Then the identities? 0:7:34.960 --> 0:7:42.120 Duraid Wadie Those identities will actually post the changes and we will read them and we will do the changes in our systems. 0:7:43.680 --> 0:7:47.160 Duraid Wadie So that's your what we call it, that's your CSV import really. 0:7:48.870 --> 0:7:50.640 Keith Low Umm, OK, I think, uh. 0:7:50.650 --> 0:7:58.160 Keith Low Previously, we also discussed that, uh, the compulsory attributes would be first name, last name, username and email. 0:7:58.490 --> 0:8:7.830 Keith Low So I think we agreed on this for, for example, like work Rite has a lot of other attribute which is yeah, which we won't care and we just pass back to them. 0:8:8.30 --> 0:8:13.400 Keith Low So I think there won't be and also of central have some other attribute which are. 0:8:13.730 --> 0:8:25.230 Keith Low I got no idea what what are they, but regardless, I will ask them to to list out all the attributes that they have as well as the sample data so that I think we can start working on it. 0:8:25.280 --> 0:8:32.480 Duraid Wadie Yeah, because, you know, like the really the deaf team needs to look at how they're gonna do that, that that's what they are. 0:8:32.490 --> 0:8:32.650 Duraid Wadie How? 0:8:32.660 --> 0:8:37.490 Duraid Wadie How they gonna stream this data from one place to another place saving it locally? 0:8:37.500 --> 0:8:42.300 Duraid Wadie I mean like saving it but don't do anything with it, so they need to figure out this out to Venice with you. 0:8:43.680 --> 0:8:49.270 Duraid Wadie They need to lock up the data the the format of the data, what type and that's why it's important to see it really. 0:8:49.660 --> 0:8:50.990 Duraid Wadie You know the are they using JSON? 0:8:51.0 --> 0:8:51.810 Duraid Wadie Are they using XML? 0:8:51.820 --> 0:9:3.650 Duraid Wadie Because XML is different that actually can have what we call your types on the data that changes the game a bit, where the others formats you don't know it was that type of data is. 0:9:5.100 --> 0:9:12.530 Keith Low Uh, by the way, I think previously we also discussed because of all the four different product may have a different way of importing. 0:9:12.620 --> 0:9:15.250 Keith Low The only common which I can see right now is is CSV. 0:9:15.320 --> 0:9:17.770 Keith Low So we for MVP, we start with the CSV. 0:9:18.440 --> 0:9:19.920 Keith Low So am I right on that? 0:9:21.490 --> 0:9:42.980 Duraid Wadie I mean, if that's if that wants to be the starting point, yes, I would say, but I think Chris probably would need to verify this is the way it's gonna be for the first time VP, because I don't know really how you know the configuration team, the service delivery team, what they, what they say into the customer, right? 0:9:43.410 --> 0:9:47.240 Duraid Wadie Because that's what they say into the customers end of the point from all their manuals. 0:9:47.510 --> 0:10:0.110 Duraid Wadie This is the way we get users then so all of that probably needs to be changed and I don't know where they put all of these, you know, like part of their RFP's when they come to sell it. 0:10:0.380 --> 0:10:2.360 Duraid Wadie All of that needs to be considered here. 0:10:4.520 --> 0:10:4.980 Keith Low Hmm. 0:10:5.790 --> 0:10:18.270 Duraid Wadie So really, if we're gonna say we doing this, it needs to be communicated back to all those product and those products they need to communicate it back probably to the sales parks, they call them what all they the sales documentation goes and all of that. 0:10:23.600 --> 0:10:24.770 Keith Low OK, OK. 0:10:25.740 --> 0:10:26.240 Keith Low Highlight this. 0:10:26.250 --> 0:10:30.300 Keith Low So, Chris, uh, just me and talking, I mean you do. 0:10:30.330 --> 0:10:31.110 Keith Low You have any question? 0:10:36.510 --> 0:10:37.670 Kar King Siew So far, don't for me. 0:10:40.990 --> 0:10:42.160 Jasmine Tang Thanks for going to satisfied. 0:10:43.490 --> 0:10:43.780 Keith Low OK. 0:10:43.790 --> 0:10:48.660 Keith Low I think then let me get those information from all the four products. 0:10:48.670 --> 0:10:57.270 Keith Low In fact, actually I have got a lot of information from them, except that I don't have a sample data, so I will request a in addition to what I've already have. Mm-hmm. 0:10:55.840 --> 0:11:2.100 Duraid Wadie I mean, yeah, I mean talking is do you actually need the sample data or what you've seen so far is OK? 0:11:6.260 --> 0:11:13.690 Kar King Siew Umm, I haven't really seen the sample data, so probably yeah I will need to take a take a look first. 0:11:14.760 --> 0:11:23.720 Keith Low I don't have any sample data as of now, so they they have a I mean like for example Ella told me they they import like like like wow what type of? 0:11:26.580 --> 0:11:39.940 Keith Low Causes they they sign up, or all sorts of information that the attribute is is very weird and also I think also mentioned to me like yeah, using manual using Excel, using FTP and so on. 0:11:39.950 --> 0:11:43.380 Keith Low It's a long list of things, but then it's it's just these bits only. 0:11:43.390 --> 0:11:44.30 Keith Low I don't have anymore. 0:11:44.670 --> 0:11:46.520 Keith Low Uh, uh. 0:11:46.530 --> 0:11:47.540 Keith Low And sample data on it. 0:11:47.550 --> 0:11:51.750 Keith Low I would request from her as well as some other products, and I think you can start looking at it. 0:11:54.150 --> 0:11:54.470 Kar King Siew Yeah. 0:11:54.510 --> 0:11:54.970 Kar King Siew Yeah. Thanks. 0:11:57.500 --> 0:12:1.580 Keith Low Umm OK, I think I think at this point of time, that's all we can do now. 0:12:3.810 --> 0:12:4.170 SueAnn See Uh. 0:12:4.180 --> 0:12:6.0 SueAnn See Can I point out something, Keith? 0:12:4.380 --> 0:12:7.80 Keith Low Yeah. Umm. 0:12:12.0 --> 0:12:12.230 Keith Low Umm. 0:12:7.260 --> 0:12:15.50 SueAnn See OK, so based on the previous emails that you have collected, right, actually I think some of them did provide some samples. 0:12:17.900 --> 0:12:20.300 Keith Low Umm yeah. 0:12:15.60 --> 0:12:31.530 SueAnn See So for example, this is from OPS central is a sample API request to create user and very clearly inside there there's a list of fields and on top of that they have a custom view list which can mean almost anything, right? 0:12:31.540 --> 0:12:31.740 Keith Low Yeah. 0:12:31.540 --> 0:12:33.760 SueAnn See So I think we need to be careful about this. 0:12:34.170 --> 0:12:37.840 SueAnn See Another one is a Devon way, Devon way. 0:12:38.670 --> 0:12:48.600 SueAnn See By reading their documentation, what I find out is that it's a module builder so they can build very flexible modules that has a parent child relationship. 0:12:48.850 --> 0:12:56.420 SueAnn See But what we need to know is that which of those information is really mandatory to be passed in upon a user creation? 0:13:0.660 --> 0:13:1.270 Keith Low Yeah, I agree. 0:13:2.20 --> 0:13:2.290 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:13:2.300 --> 0:13:14.50 SueAnn See So I think these are the details that we need from them, not really just a list of fields, because even if they give us a list of fields, we wouldn't know, like for example, if we don't accept home address, what impact does it cost? 0:13:14.60 --> 0:13:16.320 SueAnn See Is it really mandatory or not? Yeah. 0:13:17.370 --> 0:13:18.390 Keith Low But I think the mandate. 0:13:16.980 --> 0:13:19.770 Duraid Wadie But still do we yeah. 0:13:19.780 --> 0:13:22.790 Duraid Wadie Do we really care what's mandatory or not? 0:13:21.730 --> 0:13:25.70 Keith Low Yeah, correct. 0:13:27.350 --> 0:13:27.740 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:13:22.800 --> 0:13:28.240 Duraid Wadie We have our own mandatory stuff right that the one we have to have and and home but. 0:13:31.880 --> 0:13:32.500 Duraid Wadie Ah, I see. 0:13:32.510 --> 0:13:33.540 Duraid Wadie I see what you mean. 0:13:33.650 --> 0:13:34.80 Duraid Wadie Yeah, yeah. 0:13:27.750 --> 0:13:37.920 SueAnn See So if assuming we don't care right, that means maybe we will have somewhat a structure like this, but this home address will be inside this custom field list. 0:13:38.890 --> 0:13:39.580 Duraid Wadie Yeah, I see. 0:13:39.590 --> 0:13:40.100 Duraid Wadie What you mean? 0:13:40.470 --> 0:13:40.570 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:13:40.110 --> 0:13:41.740 Duraid Wadie Actually, it's not just that, right. 0:13:45.530 --> 0:13:47.720 SueAnn See Yes, correct. Yeah. 0:13:42.190 --> 0:13:48.610 Duraid Wadie It's probably they doing verification from their product right as well, which is also another problem. 0:13:48.620 --> 0:13:48.850 Duraid Wadie OK. 0:13:48.860 --> 0:13:52.430 Duraid Wadie That's actually another big problem that so, yeah. 0:13:52.440 --> 0:13:53.470 Duraid Wadie So on she's got up. 0:13:53.520 --> 0:13:55.630 Duraid Wadie I I mean a very good point here. 0:14:3.370 --> 0:14:3.590 Keith Low Umm. 0:13:55.720 --> 0:14:6.590 Duraid Wadie We need to know the mandatory stuff all the product as well, thus mean bit of fiddle logic that's happening really in in home. 0:14:6.880 --> 0:14:9.700 Duraid Wadie To be honest with you, how do we know what's mandatory or not? 0:14:11.820 --> 0:14:19.130 Keith Low I think in this case it's quite obvious they have to tell us what is mandatory that is actually mandatory for for their product, not for us. 0:14:19.140 --> 0:14:21.720 Keith Low I mean, for us we only need 4/4 attribute. 0:14:24.10 --> 0:14:24.350 Keith Low Yeah. 0:14:23.110 --> 0:14:24.690 Duraid Wadie Yeah, I mean, I didn't think about that. 0:14:24.700 --> 0:14:25.680 Duraid Wadie I mean, that's a great point. 0:14:25.690 --> 0:14:27.680 Duraid Wadie So I mean, that's really a great point. 0:14:27.690 --> 0:14:28.810 Duraid Wadie What she's mentioned here. 0:14:29.480 --> 0:14:30.640 Keith Low You know the the yeah. 0:14:32.290 --> 0:14:44.160 SueAnn See So an another way we can look at it is that in Devonway documents they do have a screenshot of their profile information. 0:14:44.170 --> 0:14:48.450 SueAnn See So this is another place that we probably can get some information from. 0:14:49.810 --> 0:14:55.310 SueAnn See Uh, which looks quite like our profile page for IHOME actually. 0:14:56.790 --> 0:15:3.410 SueAnn See But if you look carefully, there are certain things like there's even an SON point URL here, right? 0:15:3.740 --> 0:15:6.200 SueAnn See So this is the profile page, the one that. 0:15:9.150 --> 0:15:18.760 SueAnn See I don't remember exactly where, but somewhere in this document that that is mentioned about this module builder where people can just build any modules from scratch and there's some parent child relationship. 0:15:20.640 --> 0:15:21.620 Duraid Wadie And in here. 0:15:21.920 --> 0:15:25.910 Duraid Wadie So I'm actually probably your mentioned here, right? 0:15:26.120 --> 0:15:26.430 SueAnn See Hmm. 0:15:26.540 --> 0:15:28.290 Duraid Wadie It's probably the model builder. 0:15:28.300 --> 0:15:31.20 Duraid Wadie They can decide if this is mandatory or non mandatory. 0:15:32.880 --> 0:15:33.450 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:15:33.460 --> 0:15:43.0 SueAnn See One thing I'm not clear about the module builder is whether it's just a it it touches the user profile at all, or it's just the other modules that they're building. 0:15:47.260 --> 0:15:47.740 SueAnn See Yeah. 0:15:50.370 --> 0:15:50.630 SueAnn See Hmm. 0:15:44.90 --> 0:15:54.140 Duraid Wadie Ohh yeah, they can't touch anything their model builders so they can so once they build a model right they can reference the model cross all of the other models. 0:15:54.910 --> 0:15:55.730 SueAnn See Umm. 0:15:56.770 --> 0:16:4.20 Duraid Wadie That that's where the capability really they have and they that's how they really is all what we call it really under the hood is the antler and syntax. 0:16:4.290 --> 0:16:5.400 Duraid Wadie How they doing that? 0:16:6.250 --> 0:16:17.420 Duraid Wadie But for us it's more a bit problematic really, because I think this one actually neither discussion with the with one of the the I think so on. 0:16:17.970 --> 0:16:19.290 SueAnn See Yes. Yeah. 0:16:21.100 --> 0:16:22.380 Keith Low There wouldn't be there what you mean? 0:16:23.400 --> 0:16:25.610 Duraid Wadie Yeah, that's a bit complicated. 0:16:27.230 --> 0:16:28.890 Keith Low Umm, I'll be meeting them tonight. 0:16:28.900 --> 0:16:29.500 Keith Low I can actually. 0:16:30.700 --> 0:16:30.990 Keith Low Uh. 0:16:31.480 --> 0:16:32.730 Keith Low Remind them or bring. 0:16:33.120 --> 0:16:33.970 Keith Low Bring it to them. 0:16:34.40 --> 0:16:36.590 Keith Low But I think we have a very big problem with that. 0:16:36.600 --> 0:16:39.980 Keith Low One way in the sense that the time zone is quite quite bad, yeah. 0:16:39.900 --> 0:16:41.230 Duraid Wadie I know, I know. 0:16:41.900 --> 0:16:42.190 Keith Low Yeah. 0:16:42.200 --> 0:16:43.230 Keith Low Yeah, I think you do have them. 0:16:43.240 --> 0:16:46.930 Keith Low They they, you know, they are mountain time and she's 14 hours to Malaysia time. 0:16:47.0 --> 0:16:47.870 Keith Low So it's a bit tough. 0:16:49.730 --> 0:16:49.970 Keith Low OK. 0:16:49.980 --> 0:16:51.910 Keith Low Anyway, I can bring up to do, uh. 0:16:53.450 --> 0:16:56.660 Duraid Wadie But Chris acted for him is fine because the same similar time zones. 0:16:57.260 --> 0:16:57.720 Keith Low Yeah. 0:16:57.730 --> 0:16:59.350 Keith Low Yeah, two hour difference for him. 0:16:59.400 --> 0:17:0.590 Keith Low He still OK for him? Yeah. 0:16:59.590 --> 0:17:1.330 Duraid Wadie Yeah. Yes. 0:17:4.80 --> 0:17:5.570 Keith Low OK, I'll get this sorted out then. 0:17:5.580 --> 0:17:7.950 Keith Low Uh, coming to you guys and I think the order numbers here. 0:17:11.260 --> 0:17:12.110 Keith Low Yeah, I guess that's all. 0:17:12.120 --> 0:17:12.560 Keith Low Thanks a lot. 0:17:13.480 --> 0:17:14.190 Duraid Wadie Thank you everyone. 0:17:14.200 --> 0:17:14.600 Duraid Wadie Thank you. 0:17:14.300 --> 0:17:14.980 Kar King Siew OK. 0:17:15.220 --> 0:17:15.770 Kar King Siew Thank you. Bye. 0:17:16.380 --> 0:17:16.730 Duraid Wadie Thank you. 0:17:16.740 --> 0:17:16.910 Duraid Wadie Bye bye. 0:17:16.480 --> 0:17:17.70 Keith Low Think about it.

    Based on the transcript above, list down all the points and the action needed. Re-read the transcript again to make sure nothing is missed before you give out your answer.

  4. Assistant

    From the provided transcript, the conversation captures a detailed discussion on the integration and data import processes among products. Here are the distilled points and actions required:

    1. Understanding Import Mechanisms:

      • Action: Clarify and document the various import mechanisms (API, CSV, etc.) used by different products.
    2. API and CSV Support:

      • Action: Confirm and list which products do not support APIs and which ones do, noting the alternative import methods such as FTP, email, Excel, etc.
    3. Gathering Sample Data:

      • Action: Obtain sample data from all involved products to understand the format, content, and any product-specific attributes or requirements.
    4. Identifying Mandatory Fields:

      • Action: Determine the mandatory fields for each product and assess how custom attributes are handled.
    5. Clarification on Import Processes:

      • Action: Engage with product representatives for clear documentation and examples on both mandatory fields and custom attribute handling.
    6. Impact of Module Builders:

      • Action: For products allowing custom module builds (like Devonway), understand if and how this affects user profile data and mandatory fields.
    7. Documentation for API:

      • Action: Ensure comprehensive API documentation is available detailing the user import processes, including guidelines on supported formats and attribute requirements.
    8. Reviewing Architecture for Data Import:

      • Action: Examine the current architecture to support various formats and mandatory fields, possibly necessitating a redesign for flexible data handling.
    9. Address Future Scalability:

      • Action: Consider how current methods will impact future scalability and potential integrations, especially considering the integration of standard protocols like SCIM.
    10. Communicate with Sales and Marketing:

      • Action: Ensure any new import requirements or changes are communicated to sales and marketing teams for consistent messaging in RFPs and customer interactions.
    11. Data Handling Verification:

      • Action: Once sample data and requirements are clarified, verify the system's handling, storage, and processing capabilities for the information.
    12. Integration with External Identity Providers:

      • Action: Investigate the potential for integrating with external identity providers (e.g., Azure AD) using SCIM for more streamlined user synchronization.

    By going through these points and taking the necessary actions, the team aims to create a seamless, efficient import mechanism that can accommodate various data formats, meet products' unique requirements, and support scalability and future integrations.