Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-0125-preview· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

The passkeys password system is unsafe because a copy of biometric info is sent and…

  1. User

    The passkeys password system is unsafe because a copy of biometric info is sent and stored on a server, right?

  2. Assistant

    It seems there might be a misunderstanding regarding the "passkeys" system and biometric information. Let's clarify these concepts:

    Passkeys:

    • Passkeys are a newer approach to authentication meant to replace traditional passwords. Unlike passwords, passkeys do not rely on a user remembering a string of characters. Instead, they use cryptographic key pairs, consisting of a private key that stays on the user’s device, and a public key that's stored on the server. When a user wants to authenticate, the device proves it has the private key corresponding to the public key stored on the server, without the private key ever leaving the user's device. This method is considered more secure than passwords because there's nothing for a hacker to steal that can be directly used to gain access to the user's account.

    Biometrics:

    • Biometric information refers to data derived from unique physical or behavioral characteristics of an individual, such as fingerprints, facial recognition, or voice patterns. Biometric systems are often used as a local mechanism to unlock devices or authenticate the user to a system, including in the process of granting access to use a passkey.

    Relationship Between Passkeys and Biometrics:

    • When using biometrics with passkeys, the biometric information typically does not leave the device. For example, on a smartphone, a fingerprint or facial recognition scan is used to unlock the device or approve a specific action, like logging into an account. The authentication with biometrics is local to the device and is used to secure the access to the private key involved in the passkey authentication process. The biometrics ensure that only the rightful owner of the device can use the private key stored on that device without the biometric data itself being sent to or stored on a server as part of the passkey authentication process.

    Safety and Privacy:

    • The passkeys system is designed to enhance security and privacy. By not relying on traditional passwords that can be phished, guessed, or stolen and by keeping biometric data on the user's device, the overall risk of unauthorized access is significantly reduced. Regarding biometrics, the concern about safety usually revolves around how biometric data is stored and used on the device, rather than its integration with passkeys. Modern devices that use biometrics for authentication store this data in a secure enclave on the device, making it difficult for malicious parties to access it.

    In summary, the passkeys system does not inherently compromise the safety of biometric information since biometric data is used locally on the user's device for authenticating the user to the device or application and not sent or stored on a server as part of the passkey authentication process.

  3. User

    If there is malware on my system, my fingerprint (or other biometric info) could be sent to a hacker, and used to authenticate passkeys on the hacker's systems, right?

  4. Assistant

    The scenario you're describing involves a sophisticated and highly targeted form of attack, but it's important to understand the layers of security and how biometrics and passkeys work to evaluate the risk accurately.

    Biometric Data Security

    Firstly, biometric data such as fingerprints are typically not directly usable in the way passwords are. On modern devices, when you register a fingerprint, facial recognition, or other biometric data, the device does not store an image or direct copy of your biometric data. Instead, it stores a mathematical representation (or hash) of the data in a secure enclave—a dedicated, isolated chip designed to protect sensitive data and cryptographic keys. This design ensures that even if malware were present on the device, accessing the actual biometric data in a form that could be reused is extremely difficult, if not impossible, with current technology.

    Authentication and Passkeys

    When you use a biometric to authenticate and authorize the use of a passkey, the biometric itself does not act as the passkey. Instead, it's a local check to authorize the device to use the stored private key part of the passkey pair for signing a challenge from the server, thus proving its identity without transmitting sensitive data over the network.

    Theoretical Risks

    For malware to use your biometric data to authenticate as you on another system, it would have to:

    1. Bypass the secure enclave to access the biometric data or its representation, which is designed to be tamper-resistant.
    2. Replicate your biometric in a way that can be recognized by another device or system. Given that systems store a mathematical representation rather than a direct copy, recreating a usable biometric from this data is currently outside the realm of practical attacks.

    Practical Considerations

    1. Malware Threats: More common threats from malware include keyloggers (which capture keyboard input), phishing attempts, and exploiting software vulnerabilities. These attacks typically aim to steal directly usable data (like passwords) or trick users into granting access.

    2. Local Authentication: The purpose of using biometrics for local authentication (unlocking devices, confirming transactions, etc.) serves as a robust security measure because it requires physical control of the device by the user or sophisticated spoofing that would also require physical access.

    Conclusion

    While it's theoretically possible for highly advanced malware to attempt to capture and misuse biometric data, the practical execution of such an attack presents significant technical hurdles. The design of biometric systems, secure enclave technology, and the mechanism behind passkeys provide layers of security that make exploiting biometric data for unauthorized authentication highly challenging.

    However, no system is entirely foolproof, and maintaining device security through regular updates, using reputable security software, and staying informed about potential threats is crucial for protecting against emerging vulnerabilities.