Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-0125-preview· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Here is the lecture content: "Last lecture of the semester, we're obviously going to do…

  1. User

    Here is the lecture content:

    "Last lecture of the semester, we're obviously going to do a review. We are going to do what we have done in week 4,8 and 13 and we are, we're actually going to look at what the goals of this class were and whether or not we have met them. So this is a lecture with a lot of information on the slides, which means that and I'm going to put all of that information on Carmen so you can kind of look at the slides. But it might be best not to-to just kind of hear my words and maybe look at your Carmen page for better direction. So let's get started. We have watched all of these films and if you are not somebody who grew up watching South Asian or Bollywood films, that's a lot of films. It's about 14 to 18 films. If you count all of the ones that you could have watched. I don't know if this is true for all of you, but I wonder if some of your Netflix and Amazon suggested lists have started looking very different now because we have all of these new and different films added. So if we think that there are about 200 films made in Bollywood, generally every year. We have watched 14 to 18 films. And of course I have picked these films and I could have taught this class without any of these, right? I could have picked entirely different films. Some of these films are really, really iconic. So for example, I don't know if teaching this class without Upkar makes a lot of sense, but I could have picked a different film that has a very similar kind of message from a similar time period. The same thing is true for Amar Akbar Anthony. They're very, very iconic films. They're not ones that one can easily miss. But you know, to be very honest, I could actually say that for Jai Santoshi Maa as well. It's not a film that a class like this can be taught without. But I'm sure I could find a equally terrible film that did less well on the box office. But in general, more or less I would have I could have picked very, very different films. In fact, every other time I've taught this class, I have not taught Pardes. We have not talked about, we've talked about Pardes, but we have not watched it. So the point I'm trying to make here is the specificities of the films that we watched are really relevant for the purposes of our class, but the more relevant thing is the messaging around these films; what these films were trying to tell us, right? These films were trying to tell us something about family. They were trying to tell us something about religion. They were trying to tell us something about how one is supposed to be an Indian and behave like an Indian. And we could have had that message with a different set of films. We did not need these exact these exact films. In fact, there is a 19- the Chennai Express. Instead of Chennai Express, I could have assigned a different film from actually a very different time period and I could have said almost entirely the same thing. So the point again being the message is more important than the exact films we picked. But these were fun films to pick, right? Like How fun is Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara or Amar Akbar Anthony or Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge. That's actually another film that I don't know if I could have taught without but you know. So we have done a lot of film watching in the class. You've watched a film, or for some weeks two films per week and that's a lot of watching time. And these films have said something about about the message of Bollywood in general. The message of Bollywood in general, we have repeatedly said, has something to do with how the state of India, the nation works and how it imagines itself and how it imagines its citizens and what those citizens are supposed to do, who those citizens are supposed to be. Our readings for the semester, and we have done a decent chunk of readings as well. We have done anywhere from 300 to 400 pages worth of reading about Bollywood, right? Our readings have kind of been Some of them in the beginning were about how Bollywood works, right? What is specific about Bollywood? So we said Tejaswini Ganti was what is specific about Bollywood. Lutgendorf and Dudra were specific about what Bollywood does. Wilkerson, Webber, nijawan. These were all readings that are about exactly how Bollywood film is made. And how that making of Bollywood film gives it a texture, gives it its own identity, right? So Bollywood film is its own idea of film and its own idea of filmmaking. And these readings in the early part of the semester told us about that. They told us other things too. They told us how audience interacts with film. They told us how we should look at dance in the film. How, we should look at dress in the film, and those were really relevant things to know in terms of how film was working. We also learned about representation in film. We learned about how men were represented in Chakraborty. We learned about about slums from Nandi. We learned about women and their representation in film from Lutgendorf. We learned about about diaspora from Oberoi. We also learned very specific things about specific films from some of these readings. So Elison et. al. for example, was an entire 50 page chapter. It's actually an entire book about Amar Akbar Anthony. And that reading told us about one aspect, one character, the character of the mother in the film. So our readings were kind of spread out in various different ways and they kind of moved with the films. But sometimes they didn't, right? So, for example, Jotsna Kapur was not specifically about about the film of the week, which was Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara. Jotsna Kapur was about was about globalization, right? We had very specific films tied to very specific authors like Philip Lutgendorf taught us about Jai Santoshi Maa and Indian ways of filmmaking. But we also had authors that told us about broad concepts. Agarwal and Pal also did the same thing. They told us about boycott Bollywood, right? So big ideas associated with Bollywood not specifically associated with the film, although we had readings that were specifically associated with film as well. And then we had readings towards the beginning of the term that were about about how to read Bollywood, how to understand Bollywood, how Bollywood is its own animal, its own thing. Right. So these readings, where did they come from and why did I pick them? So when we are taking a class, that's a 3000 level class, actually, most likely any class that you take at the college level, your readings come from professors from other universities, right? I don't write about Bollywood, but had I written about Bollywood, I probably would assign readings, assign something that I have written. If I write a book about Bollywood, I'll make it the textbook for this class, although I'm really not allowed to. I also don't intend on writing a book about Bollywood. The point being, people who write these things, all of these people, all of these people that you see here, they're all professors in other universities, and they are all. They work on either cultural anthropology like Tejaswini ghanti or or religion, specifically Hinduism like Philip Lutgendorf, or media studies like Agrawal and Pal who work at the University of Michigan, as I told you when we read this them this week, that week, Patricia Oberoi who works on cultural anthropology. These are all experts in their specific field who use Bollywood. Who either write about Bollywood like I would as an interest because I teach Bollywood, or who actually kind of engage with Bollywood as an industry like Tejaswini Ganti does as a cultural anthropologist. The point here is that these people write either books and you get to read chapters from those books. Those books are usually from what are called university presses where they are peer reviewed by a panel of people who are like them, they get comments on those books and then they change them and then you see a final product. Or they write for journals which are again research journals where everything is peer reviewed, you work within a particular disciplinary framework and things of that nature. All of that to say, these were all scholarly readings based on the work of these people. Why did I choose these specific people and not others, really? Again, I could have picked other people. There are other books that I could have assigned. There's actually at least one book that I could have assigned the entire book. I could have actually assigned the entire Amar Akbar Anthony book, and we could have read it for three weeks or two weeks and watched another film with it, right. So there are various ways of reading about Bollywood as well, that I could have chosen and I chose what you have here, but I could have chosen something else. The point here again being, within the framework of the class, within what we are here to do, there are ways of doing this that are slightly different than how we have done it. That is again not the point. The point is that we're doing what we're doing and this is the way I have chosen how to do it. And the last thing about the class or about what these specific films taught us was, this is a citizenship class. What did these films teach us about citizenship? What does citizenship mean? And how do we kind of layer the idea of citizenship through film and specifically through Bollywood film? And what have our films taught us about that? And what have our authors taught us about that? So I feel like in every class or in every week we have, excuse me, we have talked about citizenship in some way. We have talked about representation, masculinity, femininity, class, social hierarchy, caste, religion, representation of different religions. We have talked about the concept of East and West. We have talked about the diaspora. We have talked about, we have talked about culture, we have talked about the nation. We've talked about a lot of things. And we can say that if one is thinking about citizenship, it is not-it is made of several layers of things and we have tried to figure those layers out for Indian society to some extent, as much as we can in a 3000 level class. Right. And when I say Indian society, I use air quotes because it's again, 1.3 billion people. It's not one society, right? And those also are challenges of citizenship. Those are challenges of the nation state. How does an extremely diverse country with so many languages and so many people kind of present itself as as a unified whole? And does it actually even need to do that? So one of the important lessons I hope that you have learned from this class is there is of course the way Bollywood represents things on screen. And it gives us a model of how one can be a citizen. But the more interesting point about this is we are not just interested in a model of how to be a citizen or a good citizen, an ideal citizen. We are actually also interested in what Bollywood excludes. And what does that exclusion mean? What does it mean when a person from a particular sexuality is represented in a certain way? What does it mean when a woman's desires are presented in a certain way? What does it mean when when dancers go from poor people who are supporting their families to rich people who are just doing this for fun, right? What are these statements actually seeing? What do these statements actually mean? What our readings have done for us is give us some part of those meanings, right? Tejaswini Ghanti in her-sorry, Jotsna Kapur, in her article about background dancers, tells us that this is a statement on globalization. This is a statement on how skin color is relevant, relevant not in a good way, but relevant in terms of this has become a way of deciding social hierarchy in India type of way, right? So we see all of these different layers of representation happening in film. And happening in the readings and hopefully seeing the connections that the readings and the films make. So the very, very last thing I want to do for this lecture is actually tell you something about how the citizenship class is structured and what our general goals in this class are. So this is the part where I'm actually going to post these goals on Carmen and we're kind of trying to see, it's for you to read and see whether or not we have kind of met the goals of the GE. So this is a theme class, which means that there are certain goals that are themes goals. So some of these. And there are two goals, and within those goals there are two expected learning outcomes each. So one of the expected learning outcomes of goal one is engage in critical and logical thinking about the topic or idea of the theme, right? Have we critically and logically engaged with citizenship? Engaged in an advanced, in-depth scholarly exploration of the topic or the idea of the theme? So the topic or the idea of our theme is citizenship, and have we engaged in an advanced, in-depth scholarly exploration of the topic? So the topic we decided of course, is Bollywood. And advanced in depth and scholarly. Well, we have watched a lot of films and we have read a lot of articles that are all scholarly articles. So scholarly is something that is written by scholars. Written by scholars means written by experts in the field. So somebody like Tejaswini Ganti who has who is a cultural anthropologist, or Philip Lutgendorf, who is a professor of religion, you know these are considered, these are experts in the field. And when we are reading by them, we are reading scholarly pieces. These are all peer reviewed pieces. So that's what makes them scholarly. So have we done that? Then let's look at the second goal. Yes, students are, these are ELO's again. Identify, describe, and synthesize approaches or experiences as they apply to the theme. Demonstrate a developed sense as a learner through reflection, self-assessment, creative work, your two projects building on prior experiences. Well, maybe we can even say experiences built on themselves through the class. To respond to new and challenging contexts, right? So the things that we have learned in this class, and again if you are not familiar with the context of South Asia, the amount of information that been given to you through these readings, through these films is really astounding. So when we think about categories that define citizenship, when we think about about these content, these categories in the context of America and then kind of say, you know, this is a very specific context. Let's go to an entirely new context in an entirely different part of the world. Let's throw throw film on top and like 300 pages of reading on top of that and let's then discover what's going on. So that's kind of what we have done in this class and, and I hope we have done it well. I think we have done it really well, but yeah. OK, and citizenship itself has its own ELOs, of course, and there is four of those, too. So describe a range. And within the citizenship ELOs, you are, as a learner, able to describe and analyze a range of perspectives on what constitutes citizenship and how it differs across political, cultural, national, global and/or historical communities. I mean, I think just by virtue of being about a very different cultural context and we learned a lot about the political context of the country as well, right through a lot of film, through a lot of lectures. We just didn't learn about the political context of India. We actually learned about the political context of South Asia. We learned about partition, we learned about colonialism. So again, we've covered covered a lot of ground that we were we were asked to cover, we were told to cover. Let's see the second ELO in this category; Identify, reflect on, and apply the knowledge, skills and dispositions required for intellectual competence as a global citizen, right? So are you able to reflect on things? Are you able to apply these things? Are you able to identify things that are relevant for global citizenship? Now, generally in the framework of a class, these types of applications are done through writing, right? So you have written quizzes, you have done midterm exams, you have done two projects, and it is through these activities one kind of figures out how much competence a student is developing and what they are learning about what it means to be a citizen in a different part of the world. And I really do hope that one also understands, a student in this class also understands, that being a citizen in a different part of the world is not that different from being a citizen in this part of the world, because it really is about what is what are the parameters of citizenship, right. That's kind of what we have tried to do here. And those parameters are built on hierarchy. What are the hierarchies and what are those different hierarchies? And how do we treat people who don't fall within those hierarchies or who fall at certain levels of those hierarchies? So I hope, well, I think we have been able to do that. OK, let's look at a few more. These are the last ones. Examine, critique, evaluate various expressions and implications of diversity, equity, inclusion, and explore a variety of lived experiences. We really have done that, right? We have looked at caste, we have looked at religion, we have looked at different expressions of diversity, right? Caste is a different expression of diversity than we are used to. Gender, of course, expresses itself differently in different parts of the world. We have looked at that as well. And we have looked at a variety of lived experiences. We really have. Analyze and critique the intersections of concepts of justice, difference, citizenship, and how these interact with cultural traditions, structures of power and/or advocacy for social change, right? So we are to look at all of this material and kind of get out of it. I wanna say Gully boy is a really good capping-off film because it does all of these things. It kind of makes us aware of all of the different things that are happening, all of the things that are cultural, all of the things that are social, all of the things that are problematic, all of the things that are good. And within it this character kind of finds his own understanding of justice and social justice, and lots of other characters do that. I mean I would actually argue that Jai Santoshi Maa does that in some way, trying to carve a place and space for yourself. Shubh Mangal Zyada Savdhaan does that in so many different ways, right? So we see a lot of different ways in which our various characters and various films have interacted with what we set out to do in this class. So the very last thing I'll say to you guys is we know a little bit about Bollywood. You have seen 14 films. You have read, let's say 300-400 pages. It's very important to know what we have learned here. But it's also really important to know that we don't generalize this knowledge, right? It's a very, if you think about it, 15 weeks of learning about anything is a very, very small amount of learning. So 10 years from now, when you're standing in a party, don't generalize what you know about this part of the world, right? You can say something like, I took a Bollywood class once. It was fun. I learned a lot, and this is what I learned. You cannot say, oh, in India, religion works in X ways. You can say that if you have a caveat, such as in India, religion works in X ways and I learned that in that reading in that class, right? Keep your context really small because we only know a very small amount of things. That's actually part of being a scholar, right? I would never claim that I know everything about sexuality in India. I know a little bit about sexuality of a particular group of people in a particular town in North India. Right. And I've spent like 12 years doing this work. So point being, stay humble about what we know. We learned a lot. We watched a lot of films. We did a lot of reading. I really think we learned a lot about citizenship and how to be a citizen in India. But let's be also very, very aware that we learned very, very little. And there's always a lot more to learn and know. And it's important to kind of stay within the parameters of what we have done here."

    Using only the lecture content, answer all questions in under 250 words:

    1. Which ELOs did the class NOT meet well?
  2. Assistant

    Based on the lecture content, the instructor doesn't explicitly point out any Educational Learning Outcomes (ELOs) that the class did not meet well. The lecture extensively reviews how the class adequately covered the goals and outcomes it set out to achieve, especially in terms of engaging with the topic of citizenship through Bollywood films, scholarly readings, and critical thinking. The instructor reflects on how the class has critically and logically engaged with the theme of citizenship, analyzed a range of perspectives on what constitutes citizenship across different communities, and examined the nuances of global citizenship, diversity, equity, inclusion, along with the intersections of justice, cultural traditions, and structures of power.

    The lecture content emphasizes the successful coverage of the themes and ELOs tied to the course, including scholarly exploration, application of knowledge, reflections on lived experiences, critiques of various expressions of diversity, and analyses pertaining to citizenship and social justice through the lens of Bollywood. Since there is a focus on the achievements and the engagement with the learning outcomes without highlighting any specific ELOs that were not met well, it can be inferred from the provided content that the instructor believes the class effectively met its set objectives and learning outcomes.