I'm reading Montaigne. What is this about It would seem that death had not freed King…
- User
I'm reading Montaigne. What is this about It would seem that death had not freed King Henry from his sworn undertaking, but that Count Egmont had discharged his even before he died: we cannot be held to promises beyond our power or our means. That is why – since actions and performances are not wholly in our power and since nothing is really in our power but our will – it is on the will that all the rules and duties of Man are based and established. And so, since Count Egmont held his soul and his will to be debtors to his promise, he would without a doubt have been acquitted of his obligation even had he survived Count Horn, given that it was not in his power to carry it out. But the King of England, by breaking his word intentionally, cannot be absolved just because he put off the act of treachery until after his death – no more than that mason in Herodotus who loyally kept the secret of the treasures of the king of Egypt during his lifetime, only to reveal it to his children when he died.3 [C] I have seen many men in my time smitten in conscience for having withheld other men’s goods who arrange in their testaments to put things right after they are dead. But it is valueless to fix a date for so urgent a matter or to wish to right wrongs without feeling or cost. They must pay with something which is truly theirs: the more burdensome and onerous their payment the more just and meritorious their atonement. Repentance begs for burdens. Worse still are they who reserve for their last will and testament some hate-ridden provision affecting a near one, having concealed it during their lifetime. By stirring up against their memory the one they have offended they show scant regard for their reputations; and they show even less for their consciences since they cannot, even out of respect for death, make their animosities die, prolonging the life of them beyond their own. They are iniquitous judges, postponing judgement until they can no longer take cognizance of the case. If I can, I will prevent my death from saying anything not first said by my life.
- Assistant
You're reading an excerpt from the essays of Michel de Montaigne, a French Renaissance writer who was one of the most influential authors of the French Renaissance and considered one of the fathers of modern skepticism. Montaigne is known for his exploration of the human condition through his personal and anecdotal style of writing.
In this passage, Montaigne reflects on the notion of promises and responsibilities in relation to our power to act. He refers to two historical figures—King Henry (likely Henry VIII of England) and Count Egmont (Lamoral, Count of Egmont)—to illustrate how promises and obligations should be tied to one's will and power to perform them. According to Montaigne, Egmont would be absolved of his promise were he unable to fulfill it due to circumstances beyond his control, but Henry cannot be excused for intentionally breaking a promise even if the breach occurs after his death.
Montaigne then criticizes those who try to amend wrongs they've committed by leaving instructions in their will to correct these wrongs after they have passed away. He views this delayed justice as ineffective and insincere, because true atonement, he argues, should be more than just a posthumous gesture—it should be a hard and personal penance.
Furthermore, he condemns individuals who leave vengeful directives for after their deaths, which target those they have held grudges against during their lives. In doing so, they aim to harm others from beyond the grave and display a lack of concern for their own conscience and reputation.
Finally, Montaigne expresses his personal philosophy that one's death should not communicate anything that one's life has not already expressed. In essence, he is advocating for living authentically, resolving conflicts, and fulfilling obligations during one's life rather than leaving such matters for after one's death.
Montaigne's essays cover a wide range of topics and are recognized for their depth, insight, and relevance even in the modern age. His works encourage readers to engage in self-reflection and to question conventional wisdom by providing them with his own musings on life, death, morality, and the human experience.