Name one thing you learned from Lecture #21 Part 1-5 (you can choose any part). You can…
- User
Name one thing you learned from Lecture #21 Part 1-5 (you can choose any part). You can write a paragraph if you'd like but you need only write one sentence. Type your answer in the text box provided.
- Assistant
One thing I learned from Lecture #21 Part 1-5 is the importance of understanding consumer behavior when developing marketing strategies.
- User
The Continuity Problem Sometimes the problem of personal identity has been expressed in terms of the continuity problem.
How can there be an x that stays the same given it changes?
How can there be an x that changes given it stays the same?
In a binary system this seems like a contradiction, some sort of paradox, because if x changes, it doesn't stay the same. if x stays the same, it doesn't change.
The Ship of Theseus A thought experiment which concerns the continuity problem.
The ship of Theseus was an Athenian ship used in war and made of wood. It would go out to battle, be subject to some damage and they would then repair it by replacing some of the wooden planks. This would happen again and again and again. So, it goes out, comes back and they replace more wooden planks and so on and so forth.
So we have an x that changes.
Is there any point at which throughout the changes it is no longer the ship of Theseus?
We can ask various questions and impose various hypothetical scenarios in which the ship changes presenting us with this question.
Material/Physical Matter Quantity Suppose over time going out and coming back in to repair the damage we have now replaced 51 percent of the wooden planks. Is it the same ship of Theseus? If we think it isn't then this suggests the physical/material matter (or some quantity of) is what makes the x, in this case the ship, the x it is.
Quality Instead of replacing it, with wooden planks, we do it with glass or aluminum or some other, some material other than wood. Does that matter? Is it still the same ship of Theseus?
Function How about if it just sits in the docks? It no longer goes out to sea. No longer functions as the warship. Is it the same ship of Theseus? What if we turn it into a cruise ship, Carnival Cruise or Princess Cruise. Is it the same ship of Theseus? Now that people are traveling to Mexico or Greece or the Caribbean on it.
Gradual vs Drastic/Dramatic Change Suppose I take an axe to the ship and I demolish it. And then I rebuild the ship, made up of the same material (i.e. the same wooden planks). I don't change any of the wooden planks. But now the change has not been gradual over time. It's been a drastic kind of change. Does that make a difference?
If we take apart the ship and we send the ship to the Met Museum in New York and then we put it back together again and put it on display is it the same ship of Theseus?
Timeline Does it have something to do with things having a particular timeline, a beginning, a middle and an end. The ship of Theseus was originally built and even if it undergoes changes as long as it's at present linked back to that origin, when it was first built, it's the same ship of Theseus. But if I take the axe to it then I put an end to that timeline. Even if it's made with the same material, when I remake it I have created a new origin, new timeline and thus it is a different ship.
When asking these questions and considering different changes made to the ship, we test our intuitions as to what we think determines that sameness, what must be the case for the x to remain the same x even though it has undergone changes. This is addressing the continuity problem.
If you make a change and think it's no longer the same ship of Theseus that points you in a direction as to what you think matters when it comes to determining that the x is the same x.
- Assistant
One thing that we learn from this portion of Lecture #21 is that the continuity problem raises questions about personal identity and the concept of sameness when something undergoes changes. It challenges us to consider whether the material matter, the function, the gradual vs drastic change, the timeline, or other factors determine the identity of an object.