fill in this chart The 1970’s: Was Canada a “Just Society”? EVENT/ISSUE EVIDENCE TO…
- User
fill in this chart The 1970’s: Was Canada a “Just Society”?
EVENT/ISSUE EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT IT WAS A “JUST SOCIETY” EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THAT IT WAS NOT A “JUST SOCIETY”
In the 1970s, many people feared homosexuality. Discus- sion of sexual orientation divided both traditionally reli- gious people and gay people themselves. Some believed that
homosexuality was a choice and that it was a sin; others believed that it was largely caused by genetic factors. Members of mainstream society often felt threatened when gay people “came out.” Surveys indicated that almost all lesbians and gay men had suffered some form of verbal abuse, while 25 percent of all gay men had been physically assaulted because of their sexual orientation. In December 1967, while he was minister of justice, Trudeau had remarked that “the state has no place in the bedrooms of the nation.” As justice minister and prime
minister, he spearheaded reforms in laws governing homo- sexuality, divorce, abortion, and birth control.
- Assistant
EVENT/ISSUE EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT IT WAS A “JUST SOCIETY” EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THAT IT WAS NOT A “JUST SOCIETY”
Reforms in laws governing homosexuality
- Trudeau's remark of "the state has no place in the bedrooms of the nation" suggests a commitment to individual freedom and privacy
- Trudeau spearheaded reforms in laws governing homosexuality, which indicated a recognition of the rights and equality of LGBTQ+ individuals
- Reforms in laws governing homosexuality were a step towards creating a more inclusive and tolerant society
Discrimination and violence against LGBTQ+ individuals
- Survey data shows that almost all lesbians and gay men experienced verbal abuse due to their sexual orientation
- 25 percent of gay men had been physically assaulted because of their sexual orientation
- These acts of discrimination and violence suggest that LGBTQ+ individuals were not fully accepted and protected in society
- The prevalence of discrimination and violence undermines the notion of Canada as a "Just Society" as it indicates a lack of equal treatment and protection for all individuals.
- User
In 1939, the Indian Association of Alberta was formed, fol- lowed by the Federation of Saskatchewan Indians in 1944 and
other organizations established to work peacefully for settle- ment of such First Nation grievances as poor living conditions
on reserves and land claims. The federal government generally
refused to negotiate with First Nations, and responded by mak- ing it illegal for them to organize. In 1951, this regulation was
dropped. In 1969, the National Indian Brotherhood (NIB) was founded. In 1982, it changed its name to the Assembly of First Nations.
- Assistant
EVENT/ISSUE EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT IT WAS A “JUST SOCIETY” EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THAT IT WAS NOT A “JUST SOCIETY”
Formation of Indian Association of Alberta and other organizations
- Formation of organizations like the Indian Association of Alberta and the Federation of Saskatchewan Indians suggests a desire for peaceful resolution of First Nation grievances
- These organizations aimed to address poor living conditions on reserves and land claims
- Formation of these organizations indicates a recognition of the rights and issues faced by First Nations
Government's refusal to negotiate with First Nations
- The federal government generally refused to negotiate with First Nations, denying them the opportunity to address their grievances effectively
- The government's refusal to negotiate shows a lack of respect for the rights and voices of First Nations.
Making it illegal for First Nations to organize
- The government's response to the First Nations' organizations' formation by making it illegal for them to organize is a clear violation of their freedom of association
- This action suggests an oppressive approach towards addressing First Nation grievances
Formation of the National Indian Brotherhood/Assembly of First Nations
- The formation of the National Indian Brotherhood in 1969 indicates a growing unity and collective voice among First Nations
- The change of the organization's name to the Assembly of First Nations in 1982 suggests a shift towards greater recognition of First Nations' rights and representation
Overall, while there were positive steps taken towards recognizing and addressing the grievances of First Nations, the government's refusal to negotiate, illegalization of organizing, and initial lack of recognition demonstrate that Canada was not a "Just Society" for First Nations during this time.
- User
Soon after the formation of the NIB, in 1969, Trudeau’s government, without consulting any First Nations, issued a White Paper on Indian Affairs. The White Paper was intended to enable First Nations to achieve integration and equality with other Canadians. Unlike earlier governments that tried to control every aspect of First Nation lives and to undermine
their cultures, Trudeau’s government pro- posed to eliminate completely Indian status,
traditional rights, and treaty rights. First Nations were outraged. Their mood was captured by Harold Cardinal, president of the Indian Association of Alberta, in his book, The Unjust Society: The Tragedy of Canada’s Indians (Evidence 7.13). In the wave of political activism that followed, First Nation organizations demanded the government respond to such long-standing issues as living conditions on reserves and land claims. The strong response from First Nations led the government to withdraw its White Paper.
- Assistant
EVENT/ISSUE EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT IT WAS A “JUST SOCIETY” EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THAT IT WAS NOT A “JUST SOCIETY”
The issuance of the White Paper on Indian Affairs
- The White Paper was intended to enable First Nations to achieve integration and equality with other Canadians, suggesting a desire for fairness and equality
- The government's intention to eliminate Indian status, traditional rights, and treaty rights could be seen as an attempt to create a more inclusive society
Outrage and opposition from First Nations
- First Nations were outraged by the White Paper, as it threatened their inherent rights and sovereignty
- The strong opposition from First Nations, as highlighted in Harold Cardinal's book, The Unjust Society: The Tragedy of Canada's Indians, suggests a widespread perception of injustice
Withdrawal of the White Paper
- The strong response from First Nations, including demands for addressing living conditions on reserves and land claims, led the government to withdraw the White Paper
- The government's decision to withdraw the White Paper indicates a recognition of the grievances and concerns raised by First Nations
While the government's intention with the White Paper may have been to promote integration and equality, its approach and the outrage it sparked among First Nations indicate that Canada was not a "Just Society" for Indigenous peoples during this time. The withdrawal of the White Paper suggests a realization of the unjust nature of the proposed policies.
- User
The issue of Aboriginal land claims has had a long history. Before the 1970s, the Canadian government took the position that there was no such thing as “Aboriginal title” and therefore no need to recognize the treaty concerns of Aboriginal peoples. In 1973, led by Dr. Frank Calder, the Nisga’a Tribal Council of British Columbia went to court to gain the right to negotiate land claims. The “Calder case” began a process that ended in the Supreme Court of Canada, which found that the Nisga’a did have Aboriginal land rights. As a result, about 40 percent of Canada’s
land mass became negotiable. In response, the federal govern- ment began to negotiate land claims.
- Assistant
EVENT/ISSUE EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT IT WAS A “JUST SOCIETY” EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THAT IT WAS NOT A “JUST SOCIETY”
Canadian government's denial of Aboriginal title
- Before the 1970s, the Canadian government took the position that there was no such thing as "Aboriginal title"
- This denial of Aboriginal title disregarded the treaty concerns and rights of Aboriginal peoples
- The denial of Aboriginal title indicates a lack of recognition and respect for the land rights of Indigenous peoples
Nisga’a Tribal Council's court case
- In 1973, the Nisga’a Tribal Council went to court to gain the right to negotiate land claims
- The court case, known as the "Calder case," established that the Nisga’a had Aboriginal land rights
- The court's recognition of the Nisga’a Aboriginal land rights signifies a step towards justice and acknowledgement of Indigenous land rights
Expansion of land claims negotiation
- The Supreme Court of Canada's ruling in the "Calder case" led to roughly 40 percent of Canada's land mass becoming negotiable for land claims
- The federal government's response to the court ruling by initiating land claims negotiations suggests a willingness to rectify past injustices and recognize Indigenous land rights
The history of denying Aboriginal title and the need for court cases demonstrate that Canada was not a "Just Society" for Indigenous peoples before the 1970s. The recognition of Aboriginal land rights in the "Calder case" and the subsequent expansion of land claims negotiations reflect steps towards justice and reconciliation.