What are the similarities and differences between British and American Structuralism?…
- User
What are the similarities and differences between British and American Structuralism? How will you decide what to include in the syllabus if you are the teacher who adopts Situational Language Teaching and the Audiolingual Method?
- Assistant
Both British and American structuralism share the central focus on grammar and language structure. They both consider language as a system with underlying rules and aim to understand and describe these rules. However, there are some differences in their approaches:
-
Emphasis on pronunciation: American structuralism, influenced by the work of Leonard Bloomfield and Charles Hockett, lays more emphasis on phonetics and phonology, while British structuralism, influenced by J.R. Firth and F.R. Palmer, focuses more on the syntax and morphology of language.
-
Application in language teaching: American structuralism, also known as the Bloomfieldian tradition, played a significant role in the development of behaviorist language teaching methods like the Audiolingual Method. British structuralism, on the other hand, had a more theoretical impact and laid the groundwork for systemic functional linguistics.
Now, if you were a teacher adopting Situational Language Teaching and the Audiolingual Method, you would typically include the following in the syllabus:
-
Situational language teaching focuses on teaching specific language functions in meaningful contexts. Therefore, you would include situations or scenarios, such as ordering food in a restaurant or asking for directions, that allow students to practice particular language functions.
-
The Audiolingual Method emphasizes oral practice, repetition, and drills to develop accurate pronunciation and grammatical patterns. Hence, your syllabus would incorporate various speaking activities, dialogues, and drills to reinforce correct language production.
-
Both methods often follow a structural syllabus, systematically introducing grammatical structures. Thus, you would organize the syllabus based on a progressive sequence of grammatical items, gradually building upon previously taught structures.
-
Vocabulary expansion is important in both methods. You would include vocabulary related to the specific situational contexts and the grammatical structures being taught, using visual aids, realia, and contextualized exercises to enhance learning.
-
Listening exercises and activities would be crucial in both methods to develop students' aural comprehension skills. You would include listening tasks such as comprehension questions, gap-fill exercises, and dictations.
-
Both methods also incorporate reading and writing activities. Reading passages or dialogues related to the situational contexts can be included to practice comprehension skills, while writing tasks may involve sentence patterns, controlled composition, or guided paragraph writing.
Ultimately, the syllabus for Situational Language Teaching and the Audiolingual Method should provide a balanced combination of spoken and written language practice, structured based on grammatical progression and contextualized situations to facilitate meaningful language learning.
-