Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-3.5-turbo-0301· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

7. (20 points) Alice got a positive result from her breast cancer test, i.e. diagnose to…

  1. User
    1. (20 points) Alice got a positive result from her breast cancer test, i.e. diagnose to have a breast cancer. under the below conditions, what’s the probability that Alice has breast cancer? • 1% of women have breast cancer in general • 80% of people who have breast cancer get positive result from the test (true-positive case) • 10% of people who don’t have breast cancer get positive result from the test (false-positive case)

    [hint] Please use Bayes Theorem :

    In this case, it will be Probability ( having cancer | got positive result ) = Probability ( got positive result | having cancer ) * Probability (having cancer) / Probability (got positive result)

    (Answer) Probability = ( % )

  2. Assistant

    Probability (having cancer) = 1% Probability (got positive result | having cancer) = 80% Probability (got positive result | not having cancer) = 10% (false-positive case) Probability (not having cancer) = 99% (complement of having cancer)

    To calculate the probability that Alice has breast cancer given she got a positive result from the test: Probability (having cancer | got positive result) = Probability (got positive result | having cancer) * Probability (having cancer) / Probability (got positive result)

    Probability (got positive result) = Probability (got positive result | having cancer) * Probability (having cancer) + Probability (got positive result | not having cancer) * Probability (not having cancer) = 80% * 1% + 10% * 99% = 10.18%

    Probability (having cancer | got positive result) = 80% * 1% / 10.18% = 7.86%

    Therefore, the probability that Alice has breast cancer given she got a positive result from the test is 7.86%.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.