My intuition is failing me with the monty hall problem, the one with the three doors.…
- User
My intuition is failing me with the monty hall problem, the one with the three doors. Explain it to me in a way that ACTUALLY makes sense. I can't understand intuitively how it would be a 66% chance to win if you switch, I could see 50% but how is it 66%?
- Assistant
The Monty Hall problem can indeed be counter-intuitive. Let's break it down:
You're on a game show, and there are three doors. Behind one door is a car (the grand prize), and behind the other two doors are goats (consolation prizes). You don't know what's behind each door.
You pick a door, say Door #1. The chance that the car is behind this door is 1 in 3, or about 33.33%.
Then, Monty, who knows what's behind each door, always opens one of the remaining doors that has a goat. This doesn't change the probability of the door you've already chosen: it's still 33.33%.
Now you have a choice: stick with your original choice (Door #1), or switch to the other unopened door.
Here's where it can get tricky, but think about it this way:
If the car was initially behind your chosen door (a 33.33% chance), and you switch, you will lose (because you'd be switching to a door with a goat).
However, if the car was not behind your chosen door (a 66.67% chance, because there are two other doors), and you switch, you will win (because you'd be switching from a goat to the car).
The reason the chance is 66.67% (or 2 in 3) is because there are 2 cases out of 3 where switching will let you win (the cases where the car was initially behind one of the two doors you did not pick). That's why it's generally a better strategy to switch: because more often than not, the car will be behind one of the other doors.
- User
Could it work with more than three doors? Let's say we have five doors and there's only still one grand prize. Would it improve my chances if I switched after only one of the doors were revealed?
- Assistant
Yes, it could work with more than three doors. In fact, the more doors there are, the better it is to switch your choice. Let's say we have five doors and there's only still one grand prize. If you pick a door at random, you have a 20% chance of picking the right door and an 80% chance of picking a wrong door. If the host then opens one of the other doors and shows you a goat, he is giving you some information that changes the probabilities of where the grand prize is. But how much do they change?
Well, think about it this way: when you first pick a door, there are two possible scenarios:
- Scenario A: You picked the right door (20% chance). In this case, it doesn't matter which door the host opens, because all of them have goats behind them. If you switch your choice, you will lose the grand prize and get a goat.
- Scenario B: You picked a wrong door (80% chance). In this case, the host has to open one of the other wrong doors, because he can't open your door or the right door. If you switch your choice, you will get the grand prize.
So switching your choice only helps you if you picked a wrong door in the first place, which happens 80% of the time. Therefore, switching your choice gives you an 80% chance of winning the grand prize. On the other hand, sticking with your original choice only helps you if you picked the right door in the first place, which happens 20% of the time. Therefore, sticking with your original choice gives you a 20% chance of winning the grand prize.
You can see that switching your choice improves your chances of winning by four times compared to sticking with your original choice. This is because when there are more doors, there is a higher probability that you picked a wrong door initially, and a lower probability that you picked the right door initially. When the host opens one of the other doors and shows you a goat, he is basically telling you that one of the remaining doors has a higher probability of having the grand prize behind it than your original choice.
I hope this explanation helps you understand why switching your choice in the Monty Hall problem with more than three doors is better than sticking with your original choice. If you have any questions or comments, please let me know.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
- Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)Compare side by side →
Unspecified NVIDIA model (HelpSteer2)Compare side by side →
Unspecified NVIDIA model (HelpSteer2)Compare side by side →