Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)· OpenAssistant (human-written) OpenAssistant Conversations (oasst2)

If God is all powerful, can he create a rock so big that even he cannot lift it?

In OpenAssistant data, “assistant” turns were written by human volunteers as demonstrations. They are not model outputs.
  1. User

    If God is all powerful, can he create a rock so big that even he cannot lift it?

  2. Assistant

    No . This is a critical argument that shows there is not any god with absolute power and infinite knowledge.

    Of course there are kilos of different gods introduced or produced by different people with different cultures and most of them do not claim to have such a power .

  3. User

    I understand your point of view. There are many arguments for and against the existence of God. One argument against the existence of God with absolute power and infinite knowledge is that if God is all-powerful, then he should be able to create a rock so heavy that he cannot lift it. But if he cannot lift it, then he is not all-powerful. On the other hand, if he can lift it, then he is not all-powerful either.

    However, this argument is not accepted by everyone and there are many other arguments for and against the existence of God. If you are interested in learning more about this topic, I can provide you with some resources.

  4. Assistant

    Thanks for explaining. Indeed, I should perhaps have included this into my answer. Some questions are also formulated in a way that simply doesn't allow for a correct answer.

    Just if I had another try, I'd say: because the acts of creating the rock and the act of lifting it are separate, maybe there is no paradox. At one moment of time, the almighty power creates an infinitely heavy rock. At the moment of creation, the stone is not being lifted, and it is really impossible. But at another moment, when the almighty power lifts the rock, it thus also sets a finite limit to its weight.

    So the almighty power:

    1. can create infinitely heavy objects and
    2. can move infinitely heavy objects by altering their nature, i.e. by making their weight finite.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.