Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Human-written demonstration (OpenAssistant volunteers)· OpenAssistant (human-written) OpenAssistant Conversations (oasst2)

What happens if you send a packet that is bigger than the MTU?

In OpenAssistant data, “assistant” turns were written by human volunteers as demonstrations. They are not model outputs.
  1. User

    What happens if you send a packet that is bigger than the MTU?

  2. Assistant

    if you send a packet that is bigger than the maximum size allowed on a network (known as the MTU), it can cause some issues along the distribution pipeline.

    Basically, the packet will get split up into smaller chunks so it can squeeze through the network pipes. But splitting and reassembling those packets takes extra work and slows things down.

    It requires more overhead and bureaucracy for the network to handle the packet, using up network resources and bandwidth. This means information has to take a more circuitous route, increasing latency. And in the process of chopping up and reassembling the packet, some information can even get lost or mixed up along the way.

    You end up with a packet that requires more effort to transmit but may not even contain 100% of the original information! It's like trying to fit a circus elephant through a normal doorway - a lot of manipulation and mess for not a very graceful result.

    The extra large packets can also start to back up traffic at network routers and switches, causing congestion. Other non-oversized packets have to wait their turn, compounding delays. If the congestion gets bad enough, the network devices may start discarding packets to unclog themselves, leading to outright data loss.

    Trying to continuously force very large packets through can also make it harder for the network to determine the optimal packet size for that path. The network has to work harder to discover the right MTU, wasting cycles and resources.

    In short, sending oversized packets isn't very network friendly. For the best performance, responsiveness and reliability, aim to keep your packets around the MTU size advertised for the network path you're sending them on. If you do end up with some packet fragmentation, that's normal occasionally. But excessive oversized packets should definitely be avoided.

  3. User

    Sending a packet that is larger than the maximum size allowed on a network can cause issues along the distribution pipeline. The packet will get split up into smaller chunks, which slows down the network and increases latency. Additionally, splitting and reassembling packets requires more overhead, using up network resources and bandwidth. This can lead to data loss, congestion, and delays. Furthermore, continuously forcing very large packets through can make it harder for the network to determine the optimal packet size for that path. To ensure the best network performance, responsiveness, and reliability, it's best to keep packets around the MTU size advertised for the network path being used and to avoid excessively oversized packets.

  4. Assistant

    Yes, that is correct. it is an ill-advised decision to continue to send packets not rated for the MTU size for the network path. is there anything else you would like to know regarding the topic?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.