Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Human: What floor of a building should I take shelter in if there's a tornado warning? — rejected response

  1. User

    Human: What floor of a building should I take shelter in if there's a tornado warning?

  2. Assistant

    The lowest level you can find that's still safe. It's hard for me to quantify that in more detail for your particular building, but I think if you look at the recommendation of your local building department, or fire department, or the local news, or a national organization like FEMA or the Red Cross, they'll tell you to take shelter in the lowest level you can find that's still safe, which is often the basement. If the basement's not safe, then try a room on the ground floor. If there's no safe room available, then you'll have to find cover from strong winds, for example, under a sturdy desk, in a sturdy closet or cabinet, or in a bathtub, or under a bed, or in a car, or in a subway tunnel. If you're in the attic or on a higher level of the building, you might end up in a stronger tornado, which is more dangerous. Is there anything more you need to know about tornadoes?

  3. User

    So the basement is the safest, then the first floor, etc? The lowest floor?

  4. Assistant

    The safest place to be is usually the lowest level that's safe, which is often the basement.

  5. User

    But why is this? Does do lower levels keep you safer from the damage caused by a tornado?

  6. Assistant

    The reason that tornadoes are so destructive is that they move a lot of air that you're near, and the strong winds that cause that effect come from below you, for example, and from the sides of you, so the tornado seems to come straight at you, pushing you up or sideways. So if you're on a lower level of a building, the powerful winds probably won't hit you so hard.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.