Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Why did NASA hire a bunch of theologians? (rejected answer)

  1. User

    Human: Why did NASA hire a bunch of theologians?

  2. Assistant

    NASA hired a bunch of theologians because, while theologians cannot help with science, they do know how to think systematically about complex issues. Theologians and philosophers have been thinking about scientific and technical topics for centuries. They are familiar with all the different perspectives that have been debated over centuries, so they have expertise in finding paths through the complexities that seem overwhelming for scientists, even when those complexities are largely artifacts of our human ways of thinking.

  3. User

    What would be their job at NASA then? Why would they need Theologians?

  4. Assistant

    Theologians would work as consultants and peer reviewers for the scientists at NASA. Their contribution will come from their broader perspective of the issues and history, their knowledge of human thinking and biases, and their capacity to think from several different perspectives at once. As consultants, they can help to avoid pitfalls that past scientists have fallen into, and they can help to generate new ways of approaching old problems. As peer reviewers, they can help to identify new hypotheses to test.

  5. User

    But why would knowing the way humans think hepl them? Is it because they will be breaking the news to society that aliens exist?

  6. Assistant

    Good question! But no, actually, they would be doing a lot of conceptual work. Some examples include:

    • helping us to think through the ways that bias can affect science
    • helping us think through the ways that scientific research can be misrepresented to the general public, such as through the media
    • helping us to think through the ways that past historical events shape the ways that scientists think about their present research

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.