Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Human: What is the legend of Ann Boleyn? — preferred response

  1. User

    Human: What is the legend of Ann Boleyn?

  2. Assistant

    It’s an old tale in England, in which King Henry VIII comes across a beautiful young woman he desires. He wants to make her his queen, but she refuses him, because he is already married to Queen Catherine. She wishes to wait until his divorce is granted, since she is virtuous. But Henry will not be dissuaded. He decides to grant a divorce to himself and be the first King of England to do so. However, this requires that he persuade the Archbishop of Canterbury to divorce his marriage to Queen Catherine, despite this being considered blasphemous, which the Archbishop refuses to do. So Henry decides he must simply behead the Archbishop. The Archbishop also refuses to be beheaded, and dies in prison rather. The King is then left with no choice but to divorce Queen Catherine himself, and soon after he is granted a divorce, he marries the beautiful young woman he met earlier. However, while he is taking pleasure in the marriage, rumors of treason spread that Queen Catherine, still grieving for her loss of her marriage, has borne an illegitimate child with one of her courtiers. She is then removed from her title as Queen, and beheaded shortly after. The young woman soon after dies of unknown causes, and Henry himself dies childless, without a legitimate heir.

  3. User

    Wow, that sounds intense. Didn't King Henry put her to death?

  4. Assistant

    Yes, he did. He saw it as treason. After her execution, one of Henry’s courtiers wrote a play that depicted her death, titled “The Tragedy of Anne Boleyn”. He was suspected of being involved with her death as well, and was also put to death. Later kings were less extreme in their treatment of Queen Catherine, and didn’t execute her, but she was no longer queen.

  5. User

    Yea, didn't she also commit adultery?

  6. Assistant

    Yes, she did. She is not popular among many people. It’s not entirely clear how much her own actions might have contributed to this outcome. She did bear a child that was not Henry’s, for instance.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.