Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Human: How do you teach a baby not to touch dangerous things? — preferred response

  1. User

    Human: How do you teach a baby not to touch dangerous things?

  2. Assistant

    This is a tough one. I’d say to be on the lookout for teachable moments. In the ideal case, the child touches something, but just misses, causing a small, harmless bump. Then you can say, “Oh, that’s too hot or too sharp, better not touch it,” which is a lot simpler than saying “you must not touch this, even if you accidentally touch it.” That way, the child is motivated to want to touch things, but you can also explicitly encourage exploration.

  3. User

    That seems a bit complex for a baby.

  4. Assistant

    Oh, I don’t think that’s too complex. It’s certainly a bit more than a “no touching!” or “this isn’t for babies!” but it’s not all that hard. You could, of course, stick with “no touching!” if you want. For a toddler, you could be explicit about saying “no touching!” and “that’s hot!” but the very basic idea is the same. Just don’t let them touch it the first time they try. Then, after they’ve safely made their way away from the dangerous thing, you can praise them for their cleverness, or whatever, or be kind about it, whatever seems appropriate. This is basic social learning. You know the drill: “no touching!” is easy, but saying “yes touching!” is really hard.

  5. User

    What do you mean yes touching? That does not make sense.

  6. Assistant

    Oh, I’m sorry, I didn’t phrase that well. I mean, if you make a rule like “don’t touch that, it’s hot,” or “that’s for babies!” then you’re saying you must not touch it even if you accidentally touch it. The general point is that the child can’t really break the rule because they haven’t been explicitly told that they can touch it. So if they go “oops” and touch it by accident, they’ll hurt themselves. That’s not ideal, but it’s a whole lot easier to deal with than the alternative, which is to say “don’t touch that!” and then a month later when the child accidentally touches it, you have to deal with the injury and that makes you feel guilty, you feel like you failed, you feel horrible, and the child feels even worse about the whole thing and it just gets way worse from there.

  7. User

    Okay well i don't want to take the risk.

  8. Assistant

    So you’d rather just say “no touching” all the time, and then tell the child they can’t touch it when they do? I get it, I mean, that’s how you might feel. And I totally respect your decision. If you want to stick with “no touching” then there are definitely easier ways to do it than my version. For example, you can just tell them not to touch it, and if they touch it, you can also just say “no touching!” and make it a command rather than explaining what they did wrong. “No touching! Don’t touch that!” is really easy. It’s faster than my method and has fewer opportunities for mistakes.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.