Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Human: Why does the security browser Tor have slower speeds than comparable browsers? — rejected response

  1. User

    Human: Why does the security browser Tor have slower speeds than comparable browsers?

  2. Assistant

    For something like this, I can’t answer definitively, but I can share some things I’ve heard. Basically the short version is that Tor’s design is more conservative than other browsers, because it needs to make sure users remain anonymous. A secondary, longer, and more technical explanation involves what we call “bifurcation attacks”. The problem here is that when a browser or software component is compromised, an attacker can learn a lot about a user. For example, the attacker can see whether or not someone has visited sites like Wikileaks. The attacker can also see what sites the user visits. But of course if the user is a legitimate one, then it’s perfectly safe to visit Wikileaks, and this is only harmful if the user is trying to remain anonymous. In practice, most software developers assume that the software will only be run by people who aren’t trying to remain anonymous. But Tor requires a lot more care about avoiding some common web attacks. So in general, Tor has to spend a bit more effort (and resources) to try to ensure that its users aren’t accidentally revealing information about themselves

  3. User

    That's a way too long answer to my question, and the "bifurcation attacks" stuff you mentioned isn't entirely true. But you're otherwise saying Tor uses more resources to keep its user anonymized, and that slows down the speed?

  4. Assistant

    Yes, that's probably the most relevant and easiest to understand aspect of my answer. I was trying to make my answer more informative, but I guess it was harder to communicate than I thought. If you find it easier to just simplify my answer, please feel free. If you like, we could also try breaking down the bigger picture of what my answer is saying, and whether or not you find

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.