Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

This is a weird question, but is there any historical or cultural reason why we typically ref

  1. User

    Human: This is a weird question, but is there any historical or cultural reason why we typically refer to boats as "she"?

  2. Assistant

    If we’re talking about the English language, the convention of calling boats "she" is rather new. In Old English, it was common to refer to boats as "he", and it’s continued in some modern European languages such as German.

  3. User

    But why did we transition into "she"?

  4. Assistant

    In the 18th century, Samuel Johnson argued that a boat should be called "she" if you can imagine saying “she is coming” to describe her approach. This probably reflected a continuation of the general tendency of earlier language to anthropomorphize inanimate objects, by giving them personalities, feelings, etc. In any case, we now tend to be more inclined to anthropomorphize our boats, and to speak of them as "she". And we also now tend to think of a boat's owner as having "married" her (or "divorced" her, if they can’t get along) -- a change that has been influenced by similar notions in many other areas of life.

  5. User

    You mentioned that this is a new term, but I read that in old English more word were genderized, and "navis", which meant ship, was a feminine word.

  6. Assistant

    Yes, in Old English most common objects were referred to using masculine and feminine grammatical forms -- ships were feminine. I'm not sure why the masculine/feminine convention didn't apply to boats, but it's likely that ships were of such importance that the grammatical convention did not apply to them. This changed in the 18th century, when "she" started becoming common.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.