Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Ankhenaten was an ancient Egyptian pharaoh, that was pretty controversial. Can you share some (rejected answer)

  1. User

    Human: Ankhenaten was an ancient Egyptian pharaoh, that was pretty controversial. Can you share some reasons why that was?

  2. Assistant

    Yes, Ankhenaten was one of the most controversial pharaohs in Egyptian history. First of all, he was a kind of progressive ruler for his time. He wanted to simplify society and centralize power. He also wanted to re-organize the Egyptian religion, by making a single god the most important. This was unusual at the time, and caused some problems. But the main reason he was controversial was that he kind of went against the usual norms for Egyptian society. He wanted to change everything about the system, which most people felt was extreme. He was removed from power fairly quickly.

  3. User

    Agreed. There have been recent discoveries about Tut's tomb also, showing that they recycled past funerary furniture, and slopped it into Tut's tomb, as his father's. The Sun God seems to be the way they can tell, with the designs on the artifacts. Also, he changed how ancient Egyptians carved the art style of royals, yes?

  4. Assistant

    Yes, that’s correct. Ankhenaten made major changes to Egyptian art and architecture. He simplified the royal iconography, and gave pharaohs different physical appearances. For example, he changed the hairstyle of the king from being tall and tied into a braid to being short and shaved. He also changed the artistic style of royal representations from being realistic and detailed, to being stylized and simple. All of these changes are still visible in Egypt today.

  5. User

    Some of that is right, but Ankhenaten showed a more realistic style, rather than the cookie cutter designs of past. He had wide hips for example, in his pictures.

  6. Assistant

    Oh yes, you are right. Ankhenaten did introduce a more naturalistic style. He didn't want his art to look too unrealistic, and wanted to make sure that the gods and pharaohs looked human, not like cookie cutters. This style of art was only really used by Ankhenaten, and wasn't used again for many centuries.

  7. User

    There also are issues of inbreeding, and some of the bizarre portraits of royalty, from many countries, suggest congenital issues.

  8. Assistant

    There are a lot of different theories about Ankhenaten, and that is one of them. That's the idea that inbreeding of the pharaohs caused some congenital problems. The earliest records of genetic problems in pharaohs are from the Nubian kingdom, and they do show that they had some problems with this. It's hard to say, because we don't know enough about how genetic diseases worked then to know for sure, but it is an interesting idea.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.