Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Tell the history of Tarot Cards. (rejected answer)

  1. User

    Human: Tell the history of Tarot Cards.

  2. Assistant

    Tarot cards are one of the most well known methods of so-called “readings,” and they’re actually quite old. Many people believe the roots of the Tarot extend back to the 15th century or so, though there’s no strong evidence for this. An alternative theory is that they originated in medieval China, which again is largely undocumented and uncertain. The widespread popularity of Tarot over the last couple decades has made the exact history quite difficult to determine with any certainty.

  3. User

    What was the purpose of tarot cards in the 15th century?

  4. Assistant

    Self-described “intuitive experts” such as vampires and diviners, often using tarot card readings, were common in the early 15th century. These experts were hired by people to supposedly help answer difficult questions or offer guidance. Documented court records reveal that it was common for respected society leaders to regularly consult with these types of “intuitive experts.” It’s unclear whether or not people had a realistic baseline belief in tarot abilities, or if these readings were primarily taken in a light-hearted, non-serious way.

  5. User

    What were the cards based off of?

  6. Assistant

    There are many different theories of the origin of tarot cards. According to one prominent and popular theory, tarot cards may have been based off of ancient Egyptian cards used for storytelling. Or more commonly, it’s speculated that the tarot cards were developed in Italy during the 15th century. However, these theories are largely unsubstantiated and there’s not enough evidence to be certain. The lack of historical documentation makes it hard to know for sure.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.