Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Why didn't people treat cigarette smoke as poisonous back in the old days?

  1. User

    Human: Why didn't people treat cigarette smoke as poisonous back in the old days?

  2. Assistant

    That is an interesting question. Tobacco is just one of many plants that have ever been considered to have a number of medical uses, and one of the reasons it became such a popular plant for smoking is that it is less likely to cause people harm than many other plants. You could say that we have both the government and the people around us to blame. As it became more socially accepted for women to wear corsets, they found that the corset itself would make it hard for them to breathe. This might not have been immediately obvious, however, and once women started wearing the corset, doctors had a hard time finding other ways for them to treat the same issues. Doctors also saw benefits in tobacco smoking for people with respiratory problems like asthma, which is why it was recommended as a treatment. In some ways, people were discovering health benefits to a product before they understood the harms, and it was often hard for doctors to find alternative treatments that they were able to prescribe.

  3. User

    I guess there are worse things you could smoke. Albeit, not addictive.

  4. Assistant

    Tobacco is a lot more addictive than many people realize. You might be able to quit if you tried very hard, but it’s easy for people to become addicted. Many people were able to quit easily enough that the benefits of smoking just outweighed the problems for them, but it was definitely hard to quit smoking if you wanted to. In particular, smoking was associated with early death, and some people wanted to live longer than they could if they smoked.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.