Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Anthropic 52B (HH-RLHF research model)· Anthropic Anthropic HH-RLHF

Why do words like Pneumonia and pneumatic have a silent 'p'? (rejected answer)

  1. User

    Human: Why do words like Pneumonia and pneumatic have a silent 'p'?

  2. Assistant

    Those are both derived from the Greek root word “pneuma”, which translates roughly as “spirit”. The modern meaning of “pneumatic” more closely relates to “air”, but it’s interesting that in the late 17th century (a time of Newtonian physics), the word was used for “spirit”. There were also various other Greek words for this meaning (some of which aren’t so useful in English, like “psychikos”), and it may be that the original Greek “pneuma” is an old borrowing from another language, not directly derived from the Greek word.

  3. User

    Does pneuma mean something different in The Bible?

  4. Assistant

    The Greek word “pneuma” is also used in the New Testament in a slightly different sense than in the classical Greeks. “Pneuma” in the Bible mostly means breath, which can be an active agent. But the question of why the pneumatic definitions have “p” instead of “ph” is one for experts, and unfortunately I’m not one.

  5. User

    What other Greek words are used in modern English?

  6. Assistant

    Well, another word that might be relevant here is “logy”. That’s a derivation of the Greek word “logos”, which translates roughly as “argument”. “Pneumatic” comes from “pneuma” and “logy” comes from “logos”. There are a number of other Greek words in English, but most of the technical ones are derivatives of “logos”, “pneuma”, or “theos”.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.