Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gpt-3.5-turbo-1106· OpenAI Arena Human Preference 55K

Here's a question from Reddit, what would you tell the asker to offer them the best…

  1. User

    Here's a question from Reddit, what would you tell the asker to offer them the best possible advice or perspective to help them weigh all the arguments in his situation:"I had doubts after my last visit to the psychologist. I'm not expecting you to psychoanalyze the psychologist here, but I'd like to see what people think about this.

    I have an alcohol trauma. My parents drank too much, which led to fights and violence, and now there are traumas, stress, and a complete aversion to inebriation, especially a change in the behavior of close family members - when a stranger is drunk, I feel at most aversion, but if it's someone close, the fact that alcohol has turned them from a familiar person into an unpredictable one stresses me out.

    And it never bothered me. I don't party, I've found non-drinking friends. And even without deliberately avoiding those who drink - whenever I built a relationship based on meetings, trips, movies, pub crawls with someone, it turned out that they didn't drink either. Maybe it's just a matter of cause and effect.

    Now I have a girlfriend who doesn't drink, unless someone persuades her to. And when I know she has, I feel uncomfortable. She criticizes my approach, thinks I'm exaggerating. I prefer her to respect my needs, but I don't want to impose anything on her either. She's also worried about limiting alcohol consumption due to her epilepsy, and those single exceptions can be tragic for her since she's always on medication, but I won't nag her. Soon we'll be living together.

    I told my psychologist about all of this (I've been going for a few months) and she said, "You're not a child anymore, you shouldn't be afraid of alcohol." I was a bit taken aback. She didn't, of course, suggest that I should start drinking, but she started advising me on how to get used to parties, how to change my lifestyle to include more situations with many drunk people, "especially since almost everyone drinks." I said that maybe I don't feel the need to force myself into something that's uncomfortable for me, but I prefer to be in a environment where I feel comfortable. She said I don't have to force myself, "but what if your girlfriend invites drunk friends over, and you forbid them?" I didn't know what to say in response, I completely disagree with her."

  2. Assistant

    It's understandable that you're feeling conflicted about the advice you received from your psychologist. It's important to remember that different professionals may have different perspectives and approaches to therapy. Ultimately, the most important thing is to find a therapist who you feel comfortable with and who respects your boundaries and concerns.

    In this situation, it may be helpful to have an open and honest conversation with your psychologist about your feelings and the concerns you have about the advice given. Express your discomfort and explain the reasons behind your aversion to alcohol and the situations that make you uncomfortable. It's important for your therapist to understand your unique experiences and perspective in order to provide you with the most effective support and guidance.

    Additionally, it's important to advocate for your own needs and boundaries in your relationship with your girlfriend. It's okay to communicate your discomfort with certain situations and work together to find a compromise that respects both of your needs.

    If you continue to feel uncomfortable with the advice you're receiving, it may be worth considering seeking a second opinion from another therapist. Your mental health and well-being are important, and finding the right support for your specific needs is essential.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.