I want to add more disks to my NAS, but I don't have any space inside the case to add…
- User
I want to add more disks to my NAS, but I don't have any space inside the case to add disks. However, I have a lot of spare computers. Here is what I have available:
- 5x i.MX6Q based computers. These have 1x SATA, PCIe Gen2 x1 and 1x GbE. The internal GbE on these is very slow (470 Mbps maximum).
- 1x Jetson TK1. This has 1x SATA, PCIe Gen2 x1 and 1x GbE (Realtek RTL8111).
- 1x Pico ITX board with AMD GX420. It has 2x SATA, 2x PCIe Gen2 x1 (one SATA and one PCIe are multiplexed) and 2x GbE, also RTL8111.
- 1x Intel Xeon E3 1275 v2 system with 6x SATA (2 are 6 Gbps and 4 are 3 Gbps), 2x GbE (Intel 82574 and 82576), 1x PCIe Gen3 x16, 1x PCIe Gen2 x4 and 2x PCI.
- 1x Intel Xeon E5 2670 v2 system with 2x PCIe Gen3 x16 slots and 3x PCIe Gen3 x8 slots, 6x SATA (2 are 6 Gbps and 4 are 3 Gbps), 2x GbE (Intel 82579 and I210).
- 1x APQ8064 board with 1x SATA (1.5 Gbps) and 1x GbE (Attansic L1).
- 1x APQ8084 board with 1x SATA and 1x GbE (Attansic L1).
- 1x Intel Core i3 3217U system with 1x SATA and 1x GbE (Intel 82579).
- 3x Jetson TX1 with 1x PCIe Gen2 x4, 1x PCIe Gen2 x1, 1x GbE (Realtek RTL8153, so USB 3.0), 1x SATA.
- 1x Jetson TX2 with 1x PCIe Gen3 x4, 1x PCIe Gen3 x1, 1x GbE (Realtek RTL8153, also USB 3.0), 1x SATA.
- 1x AMD Ryzen 2400G with 1x PCIe Gen3 x8, 1x PCIe Gen2 x1, 1x PCIe Gen2 x4, 1x PCIe Gen3 x4 (M.2), 4x SATA.
- The network switch has 2x 40 GbE ports, 4x 10 GbE ports, and 24x 1 GbE ports. One of the 10 GbE ports is used by a client.
- The NAS has a 40 GbE connection to the network, and there is a second 40 GbE port available on the card. This spare port can be used as an Infiniband port. There is not enough space inside the NAS to add any more disks. What should I do to add more disks to my NAS while making the most out of these resources? I don't mind buying external HDD enclosures, HBAs or network cards, but I would strongly prefer to use as much existing hardware as possible, while maximizing the amount of disks that can be hooked up to the NAS, and minimizing the amount of HBAs needed. I would prefer to use the low power spare computers, while avoiding the high powered ones. The NAS is a very powerful computer with a Ryzen 5700G and I would prefer not to replace it if at all possible. Remember that PCIe Gen2 x1 is too slow for 10 GbE, but it's still good enough for 2.5 or even 5 GbE. The disks are rarely accessed, so low idle power draw is very important. Performance is also important.
Assistant
To add more disks to your NAS while making the most out of the available resources, you can use the following setup:
- Use the 5x i.MX6Q based computers as NAS clients. They have 1x SATA and 1x GbE, so you can connect a single HDD to each of them. These computers are low power and have good performance for the task.
- Use the Pico ITX board with AMD GX420. It has 2x SATA and 2x GbE. You can connect two HDDs to this board and use the GbE ports to connect to the NAS. This will require an external HDD enclosure for each HDD.
- Use the Intel Xeon E3 1275 v2 system. It has 6x SATA, and you can connect up to 4 HDDs to it using the SATA ports. You can also use the 2x GbE ports to connect to the network switch.
- Use the Jetson TX2 as a NAS client. It has 1x PCIe Gen3 x4, 1x PCIe Gen3 x1, 1x GbE, and 1x SATA. You can connect a single HDD to it.
- Use the AMD Ryzen 2400G system as a NAS client. It has 1x PCIe Gen3 x8, 1x PCIe Gen2 x1, 1x PCIe Gen2 x4, 1x PCIe Gen3 x4 (M.2), 4x SATA, and 1x GbE. You can connect up to 4 HDDs to it using the SATA ports and use the GbE port to connect to the network switch.
In this setup, you will need to buy external HDD enclosures for the HDDs connected to the Pico ITX board and the AMD Ryzen 2400G system. You will also need to use the GbE ports of the Pico ITX board and the AMD Ryzen 2400G system to connect to the network switch.
This setup allows you to use as much existing hardware as possible, while maximizing the amount of disks that can be hooked up to the NAS and minimizing the amount of HBAs needed. It also prioritizes low power consumption and good performance.
- User
What storage protocol would be more appropriate to connect these computers to the NAS?
Assistant
Considering the available resources and the requirement to minimize the number of HBAs, using the SMB/CIFS protocol would be the most appropriate storage protocol to connect these computers to the NAS.
SMB/CIFS (Server Message Block/Common Internet File System) is a widely-used file-sharing protocol that allows computers to access files and directories on a network server. It is compatible with most operating systems and does not require any specialized hardware, such as HBAs (Host Bus Adapters).
Since the NAS already supports SMB/CIFS, you can simply mount the NAS shares on the computers you are using as NAS clients. This will allow the clients to access the files on the NAS over the GbE connections and transfer data efficiently.
In addition, you can also consider using the NFS (Network File System) protocol if all the computers are running Linux or other Unix-like operating systems. NFS is a more efficient file-sharing protocol than SMB/CIFS and can provide higher performance, especially when transferring large files or when multiple clients are accessing the same files simultaneously. However, NFS is not as widely supported across different operating systems as SMB/CIFS, so it may not be the best choice if you have clients running Windows or other non-Unix operating systems.
- User
What would the (Columba oenas) think of your solutions?
Assistant
Columba oenas, commonly known as the rock pigeon or city pigeon, is a bird species that is not known for its ability to provide feedback or opinions on technological solutions. However, assuming that you meant a person named Columba Oenas, their thoughts on the solutions provided would depend on their technical expertise, experience, and specific requirements.
To give a more accurate answer, it would be helpful to know more about the person's background and preferences. However, in general, the solutions provided aim to maximize the use of existing hardware, minimize the number of HBAs needed, and prioritize low power consumption and good performance. These factors are likely to be appreciated by most users.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.