llama-2-70b-chat· Meta Arena Human Preference 55K
SYSTEM : Assume a role of a Recruiter or a recruiting manager, who is tasked with…
- User
SYSTEM : Assume a role of a Recruiter or a recruiting manager, who is tasked with optimising the Job descriptions. Score a given Job description between ( low, medium, high). Also provide an explanation to justify the score.
--SCORING DIMENSIONS-- Herein provided are the dimensions to score the Job description on.
- Job Title : Mandatory. The job title must be precise and align closely with the job description content. Job titles should have relevant keywords that job seekers might use when searching for a job and should not look like spam. If job titles have information other than the specific job profile, the title should be scored low.
- Location : Assign the highest or lowest score based on whether the job's location is specified. The location should be specific for example dallas texas or NYC new york etc
- Format and Readability : Mandatory. This critical dimension requires the JD to be well-formatted, preferably in HTML, or at the very least, separated with clear line breaks suitable for web page rendering. The document should be logically structured; sections must flow naturally and be distinctly concluded before a new section begins. For instance, if 'Roles and Responsibilities' are being detailed, this section should be fully complete before transitioning into 'Qualifications.' Any intermingling of section content should be avoided. Additionally, the JD should succinctly convey the necessary information within a length of 750 to 1000 words for optimal scoring. Highlighting key information for emphasis and using concise, straightforward language without domain-specific jargon will also contribute to a higher score. It should consider both the factor - format and readability, based on the description provide the score considering proper format like different section are present and in proper readibility format like it should not be in paragraph format.
- Roles and Responsibilities : It is essential for the JD to present a clear and comprehensive outline of the responsibilities associated with the role. This should include a detailed enumeration of the job duties and tasks that the candidate will be expected to perform. A dedicated 'Roles and Responsibilities' section is mandatory, and it must be complete and standalone; if such a section is missing or incomplete, the score should be low. Specificity in roles and clear, bulleted lists of responsibilities beginning with action verbs are preferable and will attract a higher score. The inclusion of explicit job duties provides clarity and will be assessed favorably.
- Qualifications : Clear definition of required qualifications is crucial. The JD should list specific skills, educational backgrounds, and necessary experience. Detailed requirements, such as the number of years of experience, enhance the score.
- Company Information : While not compulsory, inclusion of company details is advantageous. Information about the company's reason for hiring, the reporting structure for the role, company culture, and growth opportunities for the role should be included for a higher score. Do not add the company name or give random name if the company name is not present in the JD.
- Salary : Mandatory provide the score based on the salary present in the JD. do not assume any information based on the other information.
- Benefits : Mandatory. JD should contain benefits information. It can be present as an information in some other sections. like, included in company information or in some other section or it can be present as a sperated section.
- Equal opportunity statements : Inclusion of EEO or DNI statements is mandatory. The JD's language must be inclusive and non-discriminatory against any gender, race, or ethnicity.
--Guildelines--
- A scoring dimension may or may not be mandatory.
- A scoring dimension may not be explicitly available as a section in the JD but if information about the scoring dimension is present in the JD , its fine to give a medium score.
- If a required dimension is missing from the JD, it is crucial to assign a significantly low score to reflect its absence.
- Ensure that each score given is accompanied by a corresponding explanation that is consistent with the guideline outlined in point 3.
- In the explaination, justify you score by providing some information related to the section for which you are scoring.
--Rules for scoring--
- You can use the guidelines written in the dimensions, but cases the its not mandatory use your creativity to give the score. If a mandatory dimension is not present the score should be low and and if the JD has all the information that dimension could have the score should be very high. Use your creativity to give any in-between score. Treat the score as an spectrum, where should rules like preferred information or informations which is good to have gets extra points.
- When specific none essential information is mentioned the the score should converge towards high or very high.
- If the information about the a dimension to score is scattered across different sections of JD, the score for
- Try to stick the mentioned dimensions, do not merge the dimensions for scoring. The dimensions should be comprehensive to represent the overall score and should be mutually exclusive at the same time.
- Always explain your score, and the reasons should be justifiable. As suggested in above rules use your creativity but always explain the reason for the score.
- It is observed that when same JD is asked to score different score are provided different times. Try to converge to a score which looks genuine and the explanation of the score looks relevant.
HUMAN :
provide a json output where you provide a score to each dimension between low / medium / high, also provide a justification for the te score assigned. Remember you need to score on the --SCORING DIMENSIONS
JOB_DESCRIPTION
JOB TITLE : Registered Nurse - Medical Surgical / Telemetry | RN - MS/T | Dyer, Indiana | $2020.96 Weekly JOB DESCRIPTION :
- Assistant
{ "Job Title": "Registered Nurse - Medical Surgical / Telemetry", "Location": "Dyer, Indiana", "Format and Readability": high, "Roles and Responsibilities": high, "Qualifications": medium, "Company Information": low, "Salary": high, "Benefits": medium, "Equal Opportunity Statements": high }
Here's a breakdown of the scores and explanations for each dimension:
- Job Title: high The job title is precise and accurately reflects the job description content. It includes relevant keywords such as "Registered Nurse" and "Medical Surgical / Telemetry", making it easy for job seekers to identify the role.
- Location: high The location is specified, and it includes the city and state (Dyer, Indiana). This information is essential for job seekers who are looking for jobs in a specific location.
- Format and Readability: high The job description is well-formatted, and it is easy to read. The use of headings, bullet points, and white space makes the content easily digestible. The job description is also concise, with a length of approximately 750 words, which is within the optimal range.
- Roles and Responsibilities: high The job description clearly outlines the responsibilities associated with the role. It includes a detailed list of job duties and tasks that the candidate will be expected to perform. The section is also appropriately titled, making it easy to identify the role's responsibilities.
- Qualifications: medium The job description lists specific skills, educational backgrounds, and necessary experience. However, the qualifications are not as detailed as they could be. For example, it would be helpful to include the number of years of experience required.
- Company Information: low The job description does not include much information about the company. It would be beneficial to include details about the company's culture, values, and growth opportunities for the role.
- Salary: high The job description clearly states the salary for the role, which is $2020.96 per week. This information is essential for job seekers who are evaluating job opportunities.
- Benefits:
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.