Are you familiar with Markdown?
- User
Are you familiar with Markdown?
Assistant
Yes, I'm familiar with Markdown. It's a lightweight markup language that allows you to write using an easy-to-read, easy-to-write plain text format, which can then be converted to structurally valid XHTML or HTML.
Some key features of Markdown include:
- Headers - Indicated by # signs before the text
- Emphasis - Bold with ** or __ around text, italics with * or _ around text
- Lists - Unordered lists with -, +, or * bullets, numbered lists with numbers
- Links - Written like text
- Images - Similar format to links, but with a ! before the []
- Blockquotes - Indicated by > at the beginning of the line
- Code Blocks - Code enclosed in backticks ```
It's commonly used for documentation, readme files, writing messages in online discussion forums, and creating rich text using a plain text editor. Many platforms and tools now support Markdown for content creation. Overall it's designed to be an easy and minimal syntax for converting plain text to HTML, with readability prioritized over visual rendering while writing.
- User
Why can italics usually be written as text or text? It seems odd that they creators didn't just pick one.
Assistant
There are a couple reasons why Markdown allows both asterisks (*) and underscores (_) for indicating italicized text:
-
Flexibility - By allowing two options, it gives writers more flexibility in using Markdown. For example, if you already have text surrounded by asterisks for bold, using more asterisks for italics could get visually confusing. Having the underscore option avoids conflicts.
-
Historical conventions - In plain text writing, underscores have sometimes been used to indicate emphasis, while asterisks indicate bolding. Markdown was designed in part to map existing plain text conventions to HTML, so supporting both for italics made sense.
-
Programming usage - In some programming contexts, asterisks are used for comments or other symbols, so having the underscore option prevents any conflict there when writing documentation or READMEs.
-
Personal preference - Some people just prefer one over the other visually or are more accustomed to one from previous experience with plain text emphasis. Allowing both caters to personal preference in syntax.
So in summary, supporting both asterisks and underscores for italics gives more flexibility, avoids conflicts, and maps to historical and programming conventions - ultimately allowing more writers to use Markdown more easily. The Markdown creator chose to support both rather than enforce a single standard.
-
- User
What was typically more popular? Using underscores or asterisks for italics/emphasis?
Assistant
In my experience, asterisks (*) have generally been more popular and common for indicating italics or emphasis in Markdown. There are a few reasons why:
-
Convention in other languages - Asterisks were already commonly used for emphasis in many plaintext conventions before Markdown, like in IRC chat or bulletin boards. The underscore convention was less widespread. This made asterisks a natural choice to adopt.
-
Coding syntax conflicts - As mentioned before, underscores are used for lots of other purposes in code and other syntaxes. Asterisks have less conflicts with programming languages and don't look like part of an identifier, variable name, etc.
-
Easier to type - On many keyboards, the asterisk is more convenient to type than the underscore. The asterisk doesn't require using the SHIFT key. This small ergonomic difference may have contributed to its popularity.
-
Visual clarity - Some people perceive the asterisks as standing out more clearly and feel they indicate emphasis better visually when skimming a text. The underscore blends into words a bit more.
So in summary, convention, avoiding syntax conflicts, ergonomics, and visual clarity advantages have made asterisks the traditionally more popular choice for italics markup in Markdown. But the flexibility of allowing both prevents issues for those who prefer underscores.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.