You are at a fork in the road after a long walk in the desert. One fork leads to a town,…
- User
You are at a fork in the road after a long walk in the desert. One fork leads to a town, one fork leads to more desert. You are very thirsty and need to go to the town to get water. There are two individuals at the fork that can answer questions to help guide you to the town. However, one individual always lies. On individual always tells the truth. You don't know which one is the lier and which is the truth teller. What question do you ask to them to find the way to the town?
Assistant
Here is one way to find the path to town:
I would ask one of the individuals: "If I asked the other individual which path leads to town, which path would they point to?"
Then I would take the opposite path from whichever one that individual points to.
The logic is:
-
If I asked the truth teller, they would accurately report which incorrect path the liar would point to. So the opposite path is correct.
-
If I asked the liar, they would point to the incorrect path the truth teller would accurately direct me towards. So again, the opposite path is the correct one.
So by asking one individual about what the other one would say, then going the opposite, I can reliably find the path to town.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.