Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-pro-dev-api· GoogleHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Help me calculate the net IRR of a residential real estate investment. While I own the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4-1106-preview’s answer.
  1. User

    Help me calculate the net IRR of a residential real estate investment. While I own the house, assume I’m earning a positive cash flow by renting it out.

    • Purchase price, year 0 = $1000k
    • Sale price, year 5 = $3000k
    • 30 year fixed rate mortgage, 5% fixed APR
    • insurance and other recurring taxes = 3% of original purchase price
    • monthly rent = 5% above the monthly mortgage payments
  2. Gemini Assistant

    Net IRR Calculation:

    Step 1: Calculate Annual Cash Flow

    • Year 0:

    • Cash Flow = Rent - Mortgage Payments - Insurance and Taxes

    • Rent = 1.05 * (Purchase Price * Monthly Mortgage Payment)

    • Monthly Mortgage Payment = $1000k * 5% / 12 / (1 - (1 + 5% / 12)^(-30*12))

    • Insurance and Taxes = 3% * $1000k

    • Cash Flow = 52,500−52,500 - 4,167 - 30,000=−30,000 = -1,667

    • Year 1 to 4:

    • Cash Flow = Rent - Mortgage Payments - Insurance and Taxes

    • Rent = 1.05 * (Purchase Price * Monthly Mortgage Payment) * (1 + 3%)^Year

    • Monthly Mortgage Payment remains constant

    • Insurance and Taxes remain constant

    • Cash Flow = 54,135−54,135 - 4,167 - 30,000=30,000 = 20,968

    • Year 5:

    • Cash Flow = Sale Price - (Purchase Price + Total Down Payment + Closing Costs) + Total Cash Flow

    • Sale Price = $3000k

    • Purchase Price = $1000k

    • Total Down Payment and Closing Costs = 20% of Purchase Price = $200k

    • Total Cash Flow = Sum of Cash Flows from Year 0 to Year 4

    • Cash Flow = 3000k−(3000k - (1000k + 200k)+200k) + 83,872 = $2,083,872

    Step 2: Calculate Net IRR

    • Net IRR = (Ending Value / Initial Investment)^(1/Number of Years) - 1
    • Ending Value = Sale Price + Total Cash Flow
    • Initial Investment = Purchase Price + Total Down Payment + Closing Costs
    • Number of Years = 5
    • Net IRR = (3000k+3000k + 83,872) / (1000k+1000k + 200k)^(1/5) - 1 = 15.5%

    Therefore, the net IRR of the residential real estate investment is 15.5%.

  3. User

    The deposit is 20% of the purchase price. This is all you need, now show me your answer

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Net IRR Calculation:

    Step 1: Calculate Annual Cash Flow

    • Year 0:

      • Cash Flow = Rent - Mortgage Payments - Insurance and Taxes
      • Rent = 1.05 * (Purchase Price * Monthly Mortgage Payment)
      • Monthly Mortgage Payment = (Purchase Price * APR) / (1 - (1 + APR)^(-30 * 12))
      • Insurance and Taxes = 3% of Purchase Price
      • Cash Flow = 52,500−52,500 - 4,167 - 30,000=−30,000 = -1,667
    • Year 1 to 4:

      • Cash Flow = Rent - Mortgage Payments - Insurance and Taxes
      • Rent = 1.05 * (Purchase Price * Monthly Mortgage Payment) * (1 + 3%)^Year
      • Monthly Mortgage Payment remains constant
      • Insurance and Taxes remain constant
      • Cash Flow = 54,135−54,135 - 4,167 - 30,000=30,000 = 20,968
    • Year 5:

      • Cash Flow = Sale Price - (Purchase Price + Total Down Payment + Closing Costs) + Total Cash Flow
      • Sale Price = $3,000,000
      • Purchase Price = $1,000,000
      • Total Down Payment and Closing Costs = 20% of Purchase Price = $200,000
      • Total Cash Flow = Sum of Cash Flows from Year 0 to Year 4
      • Cash Flow = 3,000,000−(3,000,000 - (1,000,000 + 200,000)+200,000) + 83,872 = $2,083,872

    Step 2: Calculate Net IRR

    • Net IRR = (Ending Value / Initial Investment)^(1 / Number of Years) - 1
    • Ending Value = Sale Price + Total Cash Flow - Initial Investment
    • Initial Investment = Purchase Price + Total Down Payment + Closing Costs
    • Number of Years = 5
    • Net IRR = (3,000,000+3,000,000 + 83,872) / (1,000,000+1,000,000 + 200,000)^(1 / 5) - 1
    • Net IRR = 15.5%

    Therefore, the net IRR of the residential real estate investment is 15.5%.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.