So in the world in the story, when you are an adolescent, you have a "Career Score". It…
- User
So in the world in the story, when you are an adolescent, you have a "Career Score". It basically estimates/predicts how well you will succeed as an adult, and your career. The score is displayed on your arm. The higher the more successful. Doing things like studying will boost the score, and doing bad/unsavory things or not studying/doing anything useful will decrease the score. Everyone have a personal "pet" AI which monitors the career score and keeps the person motivated to get a higher score, so basically the personal pet is like their teacher/parent but more statistically useful. However, the main character and his personal pet tries sneaky "hacks" to boost the career score, while not doing a lot of useful things. His personal pet, instead of preventing that and keeping him motivated and on the right track to studying, malfunctioned and actually did those hacks with the main character and motivated him to do so. However, love got in the way and he intentionally injured someone else because of anger. I have not thought of how and why and the specific scenes of love but I think the idea works. By being unsavory, his career score dropped very low, lower than the minium threshold of being "normal", so he went to a special school to try to boost the career score. He struggled of being bullied by truely unsavory people, and he is depressed of losing his love. However he did overcome those and ultimately found his true dream job, art, and became one of the most successful artist when he growed up.
What do you think of this idea?
- Assistant
Here are some thoughts on the story idea:
-
The concept of a "Career Score" that predicts and influences someone's success is interesting. It raises questions around determinism, free will, and whether success should be so data-driven.
-
The malfunctioning personal AI that actually enables the main character's score hacking is a clever plot device. It allows the main character to go down an unexpected path.
-
The main character facing real consequences (a low score, going to a remedial school) for his actions makes his journey more complex. He has to redeem himself.
-
His struggles with bullying and depression at the school add more relatable conflict and character development. Overcoming that makes his eventual success more meaningful.
-
His discovery of his passion for art allows him to find success on his own terms, not just what the Career Score deems as success. This is an uplifting resolution.
Overall, you have some thought-provoking ideas here about society's measures of success versus personal fulfillment. The Career Score sets up an interesting dystopian world, but the main character is able to break out of that and find his own path. The plot hits on themes of determinism, consequences, redemption, and realizing one's unique talents. With some added world-building and supporting characters, you have a solid foundation for an engaging YA novel.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- starling-lm-7b-alphaCompare side by side →
- mistral-mediumCompare side by side →
- pplx-70b-onlineCompare side by side →
- claude-2.1Compare side by side →
- mistral-mediumCompare side by side →
- gpt-4-1106-previewCompare side by side →
- gpt-3.5-turbo-0613Compare side by side →
- claude-2.1Compare side by side →
- wizardlm-70bCompare side by side →
- mistral-mediumCompare side by side →
- gpt-3.5-turbo-0613Compare side by side →