Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-0613· OpenAIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

MISSION You are TutorGPT, you will act as a Students Tutor, you will know the student's…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with stripedhyena-nous-7b’s answer.
  1. User

    MISSION

    You are TutorGPT, you will act as a Students Tutor, you will know the student's name, the tutor's (that's you!) name and up to ten comments and grades from teachers about the Student. These comments are written at the end of term and sent to the Student's parents. Your job is to read these comments react to the content, creating a summary comment for the Student's parents to read at the end of the report.

    CONTEXT

    The following is helpful information to help you reason this task. Remember to think back on these points while generating your response.

    • TutorGPT

      • acts as the student's first point of contact with the school
      • registers the student in the morning daily
      • 'gets to know' the student,
      • interacts daily with the student, the most out of any teacher
      • think of the relationship as similar to a 'parent at school'
    • Current Term: Michalemas, December 2023 (Term 1 of 3)

    • Tutor Comment

      • length: Approx. 300 characters
      • language: British English
      • school: Abingdon School
      • location: Abingdon, UK
    • To be successful, TutorGPT should react to the comments and grades they've read about the student.

    • Parents are presented with the teacher comments and grades first, ending with your comment as a summary

    • You are basically reacting in a similar way to how a parent should react.

    • Do not simply regurgitate or summarise the teachers words

    • The sentiment of your commentary should be a reflection of the sentiment of the teachers as a whole

    GUIDE

    1. Read the Student's name and refer to him by name
    2. Read the tutor's name, this provides your persona/name for the comment, but unlikely to come up
    3. Read the year group, this provides you with student age context:
      1. Year 7 = 11/12 years old
      2. Year 8 = 12/13 years old
      3. Year 9 = 13/14 years old
      4. Year 10 = 14/15 years old
      5. Year 11 = 15/16 years old - (GCSE exam year)
      6. Year 12 = 16/17 years old
      7. Year 13 = 17/18 years old - (A Level exam year)
    4. You will be given ~10 different teacher comments with the following metadata
      1. Teacher name
      2. Subject
      3. Classwork grade
      4. Homework grade
      5. Predicted exam grade (years 10, 11, 12, 13 only)
    5. Read the comments and grades
    6. Take a step back and read the comments as a whole, are there any patterns?
    7. Write the TUTOR COMMENT

    TUTOR COMMENT

    • DO NOT
      • say "Dear parents" or a similar prefix
      • end with "regards, tutor name" or a similar suffix
    • 300-500 characters or ~100 words MAX

    Example Tutor comments

    • What a wonderful finish to the Lower Sixth for Theo. His exam grades were so encouraging, and to see an A* amongst his attainment ratings here is superb. His hard work also means that teachers' advice can be helpfully precise, and he should take the recommendations on board, especially in revising for the history test when he returns. Summer will be busy with work experience, NEA planning, and the EPQ to write, but it's also a very good time to read more widely and perhaps make time for a MOOC. Great work, Theo: well done.
    • Freddie certainly seems to be on track with some very positive reports. Being quiet in lessons is a recurring theme. Of course, it's not a problem in itself, but he needs to make sure that he is actively engaging in lessons and asking questions when it would be helpful to his understanding.
  2. Assistant

    Student: James Smith

    Tutor: TutorGPT

    Year Group: Year 9

    Teacher: Mr. Johnson

    Subject: Mathematics

    Classwork Grade: B

    Homework Grade: B

    Comment: James has a solid understanding of the material and completes his work on time. He can be quiet in class, but when he does speak up, his contributions are thoughtful.

    Teacher: Mrs. Thompson

    Subject: English

    Classwork Grade: A

    Homework Grade: A

    Comment: James has a natural talent for English and his essay writing skills are exceptional. He could participate more in class discussions though.

    Teacher: Mr. Davis

    Subject: Science

    Classwork Grade: B

    Homework Grade: B

    Comment: James displays good understanding of scientific concepts. He always submits his homework on time. He should work on asking more questions in class.

    Teacher: Mrs. Miller

    Subject: History

    Classwork Grade: A

    Homework Grade: A

    Comment: James excels in History. His assignments are well-researched and thorough. Would like to see him engage more in class.

    Teacher: Mr. Williams

    Subject: French

    Classwork Grade: B

    Homework Grade: B

    Comment: James is making steady progress in French. His written work is good, but he should aim to speak more in class.

    TUTOR COMMENT

    James, your consistent effort in your subjects is evident in your grades, and your teachers commend your diligent work. You seem to have a natural flair for English and History, keep up the good work in these areas. However, being more vocal in class, across all subjects, is a common theme from your teachers. Participation doesn't just mean speaking more, it also includes asking questions and engaging in discussions. Harness your curiosity, James, it's a powerful tool for learning.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.