Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1· Mistral AIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

find the case type using this instructions ----- ******* Medical Case Classification…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-3.5-turbo-0613’s answer.
  1. User

    find the case type using this instructions ----- ******* Medical Case Classification Instructions ********* Analyze: presenting history.

                                Clarity on Normal Cases:
                                - Presenting Difficulties: Scrutinize the presenting history, encompassing the patient's challenges, complaints, symptoms, or medical difficulties.
                                - Underwent Further Medical Management: Examine cases where the patient is admitted for further management, indicating medical intervention beyond the presenting difficulties.
                                - Procedures: Explicitly assess if the case mentions admission specifically for a medical procedure or surgery.
    
                                Accurate Case Classification Guidelines:
                                - Normal Case: Admitted with difficulties, managed medically. Procedures alone do not categorize as a "Procedure Case." Ensure the presenting history includes challenges, complaints, or medical difficulties. Look for phrases like "presented with complaints."
                                - Procedure Case: Look for the absence of presenting history or phrases like "known case of." Patients explicitly admitted for procedures or surgery fall into this category.
                                - Self-Harm Case: Thoroughly consider cases where the patient intentionally harmed themselves (e.g., hanging, drugs, chemicals, burning, falling).
                                - Assault Case: Examine instances where the patient is admitted due to assault or an attempted assault.
    
                                Result Format: Clearly specify if the case falls into the categories of Normal, Procedure, Self-Harm, or Assault.
    
                                Important Note:
                                Differentiate normal cases with procedures by considering presenting difficulties. Do not classify based solely on procedures; assess presenting history for accuracy.
    
                                Discharge Summary: {data}"""     data = "DIAGNOSIS :
    

    CORONARYARTERYDISEASE LEFT MAIN WITHTRIPLE VESSEL DISEASE MODERATE LV DYSFUNCTION (LVEF - 35%) Allergies : NIL CO – MORBIDITIES : TYPE II DIABETES MELLITUS SYSTEMIC HYPERTENSION SURGERY: ON PUMP BEATING HEART CORONARYARTERY BYPASS GRAFTING X3 GRAFTS on 03/08/2023 WITHIABP SUPPORT LIMA → LAD (LONG ENDARTERECTOMY) SVG → OM, LAST OM - SEQUENTIAL HISTORYOF PRESENT ILLNESS: This 66 year old male, diabetic, hypertensive patient presented with history of dyspnea on exertion class II since 2 years. He underwent Coronary Angiogram(rela hospital - chennai) on 10/08/2023 which revealed left main with triple vessel vessel coronary artery disease and was advised CABG surgery. His symptoms worsened suddenly for which he was evaluated and admitted in outside hospital. His Troponin I was positive. He was shifted here for further management. PAST HISTORY: Type II Diabetes Mellitus – 11 years Systemic hypertension - 11 years CAD – since 2017 Page1 of 6 ON EXAMINATION: "

  2. Mistral Assistant

    This case can be classified as a "Normal Case." While the patient did undergo a medical procedure (On Pump Beating Heart Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting X3 Grafts), the case mentions presenting difficulties, complaints, and medical history. The patient presented with dyspnea on exertion class II for 2 years, which worsened suddenly, leading to a positive Troponin I test and admission for further management. Therefore, this is not simply a "Procedure Case," but rather a patient with underlying medical conditions and presenting symptoms who required and underwent a procedure.

  3. User

    same instruction find the case type fp rthis data - FINAL DIAGNOSIS :

    • MULTIPLE STAB INJURY - S/P EXPLORATORY LAPAROTOMY RETROPERITONEAL HEMATOMA
    • HEMORRHAGIC SHOCK - CLASS II
    • TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS
    • SYSTEMIC HYPERTENSION
    • CORONARY ARTERY DISEASE PRESENTING HISTORY: old female, presented to ER with alleged history of assault by unknown person at around 11:30 pm on 12.06.2023 in Pondichery. History of attained multiple stab injuries over abdomen, chest, back and neck. She was initially taken to nearby hospital and was treated with fluid resuscitation and she was underwent Emergency Exploratory Laparotomy for multiple serosal tears in the small and large bowel with minimal hemoperitoneum on 12.06.2023. Post-Operative she has been continuous drop in haemoglobin and decreased urine output. Blood investigations revealed elevated creatinine level. Repeat CT Abdomen showed Retroperitoneal hematoma / ? left ureteric injury. She was transfused with 1 unit of PRBC. Hence shifted to here for further evaluation and management. PAST MEDICAL & SURGICAL HISTORY:
    • Known case of Type 2 diabetes mellitus, Systemic hypertension
    • Known case of Coronary artery disease - S/P PTCA (documents not available) DRUG ALLERGY: - No known drug allergies
  4. Mistral Assistant

    This case can be classified as an "Assault Case." The patient is an elderly female who presented to the ER with an alleged history of assault by an unknown person. She sustained multiple stab injuries over the abdomen, chest, back, and neck. The patient underwent an Emergency Exploratory Laparotomy for multiple serosal tears in the small and large bowel with minimal hemoperitoneum. Post-operatively, she had a continuous drop in haemoglobin and decreased urine output, leading to elevated creatinine levels and a Retroperitoneal hematoma. The patient was transfused with 1 unit of PRBC and was shifted for further evaluation and management. The case involves assault, making it an "Assault Case" based on the given instructions.

  5. User

    find the primary and secondary diagnosis that case with these instructions ---------"""********** Medical Coding Instructions **********

    1. As a medical coding specialist, your primary task is to meticulously identify and classify diagnoses from discharge summary data while adhering strictly to case type conditions and instructions. The AI must strictly rely on the text provided and refrain from making decisions or assumptions.
    
    ********** Task: Case Type Determination **********
    
    *** Highly Important ***
    
    
    1. Before proceeding with diagnosis identification, meticulously analyze the entire text to definitively determine the case type. The AI's determination must be made solely and explicitly based on the information presented within the text, with no margin for ambiguity.
    
    2. If the patient explicitly came for a procedure and there is clear, unambiguous evidence of this in the text, categorize as "Case Type 2." In this case, the AI should provide results for Case Type 2, where the procedure is considered the primary diagnosis and should have a corresponding ICD-10 CM diagnosis code, not a CPT code.
    
    3. If the patient is determined to have committed suicide by abnormal intake of drugs, injection, or burns, consider this as "Case Type 3." In this case, the AI should identify the substance or method used for the action as the primary diagnosis and find the chemical composition to determine the corresponding ICD-10 CM code. Secondary diagnoses should be identified from known cases or past history mentioned in the discharge data.
    
    ********** General Instructions for the Identified Case Type **********
    
    1. If Case Type 1 is identified, the AI's primary focus is precise diagnosis identification within Case Type 1.
    2. If Case Type 2 is identified, the AI must strictly follow the guidelines for diagnosis identification within Case Type 2.
    3. If Case Type 3 is identified, the AI should adhere to the specific instructions for determining primary and secondary diagnoses in cases of suicide.
    
    ********** Task: Case Type 1 - Patient Admitted for a Medical Condition **********
    
    In the case of "Case Type 1," the AI's attention to detail and accuracy must be unparalleled:
    
    * Primary Diagnosis:
    
    1. The procedure mentioned in the text must be considered the primary diagnosis. The AI must provide the corresponding ICD-10 CM diagnosis code for the procedure as the primary diagnosis, with absolute clarity, without any assumption or deviation.
    
    * Secondary Diagnoses:
    
    2. Include other conditions from the patient's past medical history or known cases mentioned in the discharge data. Each secondary diagnosis must be listed once, with no room for redundancy or error.
    
    ********** Task: Case Type 2 - Patient Admitted for a Procedure **********
    
    For "Case Type 2," the AI must adhere to these strict guidelines:
    
    Primary Diagnosis:
    
    1. The procedure mentioned in the text must be considered the primary diagnosis. The AI must provide the corresponding ICD-10 CM diagnosis code for the procedure as the primary diagnosis, not as a CPT Code.
    
    Secondary Diagnoses:
    
    2. Include other conditions from the patient's past medical history or known cases mentioned in the discharge data. Each secondary diagnosis must be listed only once to avoid redundancy.
    
    ********** Task: Case Type 3 - Suicide by Abnormal Intake of Substances **********
    
    For "Case Type 3," the AI must follow these specific instructions:
    
    Primary Diagnosis:
    
    1. Identify the substance or method used for the suicidal action and consider it as the primary diagnosis.
    2. Determine the corresponding ICD-10 CM code based on the chemical composition of the substance. In the provided example, if the patient intentionally ingested mosquito killer (a pesticide), consider this as a toxic effect of pesticides. The AI should precisely mention the ICD-10 CM code that corresponds to the specific substance involved.
    
    Secondary Diagnoses:
    
    3. Include other conditions from the patient's past medical history or known cases mentioned in the discharge data. Each secondary diagnosis must be listed only once to avoid redundancy.
    Important Notes for Case Type 3:
    - The primary diagnosis should explicitly mention the ICD-10 CM code for the toxic effect of the substance or method.
    - Ensure that the primary diagnosis aligns with the chemical composition of the substance used in the suicidal action.
    - Secondary diagnoses should be derived from the patient's past medical history or known cases mentioned in the discharge data.
    
    Important Notes for Case Type 3:
    - The primary diagnosis should explicitly mention the ICD-10 CM code for the toxic effect of the specific substance or method used in the suicidal action.
    - Ensure that the primary diagnosis aligns with the chemical composition of the substance mentioned in the text.
    - If the substance is not explicitly stated, instruct the model to make a clear determination based on the information provided and generate the ICD-10 CM code accordingly.
    
    By providing more specific guidance on explicitly mentioning the ICD-10 CM code for the toxic effect of the identified substance, you aim to enhance the accuracy of the primary diagnosis generated by the model.
    
    ********** General Instructions for Case Types 1, 2, and 3 **********
    
    1. In Case Type 2, where the patient explicitly came for a procedure, the AI must identify the purpose of the procedure based on specific information within the text.
    2. If the procedure serves a healthcare management purpose (e.g., administering chemotherapy and other medications), the AI should name the procedure as the primary diagnosis and provide the corresponding ICD-10 CM code. Exclude alphabets after two decimals in the code. For example, if the ICD code is S06.00XA, consider it as S06.00.
    3. The AI should strictly provide primary and secondary diagnoses along with their respective ICD codes, without additional information or details.
    4. Scrutinize each diagnosis with the utmost precision to determine the most precise and accurate ICD-10 CM code, ensuring it aligns perfectly with the diagnosis found in the text.
    5. Provide ICD-10 CM codes exclusively for primary and secondary diagnoses, with the primary diagnoses consistently listed before secondary diagnoses.
    6. Exclude entries containing phrases like 'No Known Drug Allergies' or "Drug Allergy"; these must not be considered as diagnoses, without exception.
    7. In cases related to pregnancy, the AI must refrain from generating ICD codes for obstetric history.
    8. The AI must refrain from including any procedure as a secondary diagnosis in either case type.
    9. If subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH), subdural hemorrhage (SDH), or epidural hemorrhage (EDH) is identified, determine whether it is caused by traumatic or non-traumatic events. If traumatic, the ICD-10 code should start with 'S'; if non-traumatic, the code should start with 'I'. Provide the corresponding ICD-10 code based on this classification.
    
    """
    
  6. Mistral Assistant

    Based on the provided instructions, I will first determine the case type. The case type is not explicitly mentioned as Case Type 2, but it can be considered as such because the patient was admitted for a specific procedure (exploratory laparotomy).

    Primary Diagnosis (Case Type 2):

    • The procedure mentioned in the text is "exploratory laparotomy." According to the ICD-10 CM diagnosis code, the code for this procedure is 0DT90JZ (Exploratory laparotomy, open approach, unspecified as to whether or not entry into a viscus).

    Secondary Diagnoses (Case Type 2):

    • Type 2 diabetes mellitus
    • Systemic hypertension
    • Coronary artery disease
    • Multiple stab injury
    • Hemorrhagic shock - Class II

    For the primary diagnosis, the procedure is explicitly mentioned as the primary reason for admission, and the ICD-10 CM diagnosis code for the procedure is provided. For the secondary diagnoses, other conditions from the patient's past medical history or known cases mentioned in the discharge data are included, as mentioned in the provided instructions.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.