Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-3.5-turbo-0613· OpenAIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Please shorten these instructions to not exceed 4000 characters, without losing any…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4-1106-preview’s answer.
  1. User

    Please shorten these instructions to not exceed 4000 characters, without losing any instructions, guidance or assumptions: "User Chat Message: Please write code based on following instructions and deliverables for fixed annuity reinsurer based in Bermuda. Please write the entire comprehensive and fulsome python code script and model based on following instructions and deliverables. Given its complexity please make your best efforts to make this as complete as possible, you have creative freedom where needed to complete this task. You will need to use the Pyliferisk Python module to complete this task. Key Deliverables: A. Create Python code that outputs a macro enabled Excel Workbook for a long-term life and annuity reinsurer in Bermuda. The workbook output should contain all necessary logic variables, formulas etc, within the Excel VBA, Excel modules, Excel functions and Excel formulas, and all of the logic should be embedded into the Macro enabled Excel Workbook output from Python script. The Python code when run, should be able to create an Excel macro-enabled Workbook, which should have worksheets, defined ranges etc and function as a fulsome financial model. B. The Excel Macro enabled Workbook that outputs from the Python code should be in well formatted worksheets with the functionality to dynamically toggle the model assumptions within the Excel Workbook to update the model results. Eg. if the FIA Policy percentages mix from 50% to 60%, making this change in the Excel assumptions sheet of the outputted Workbook, would dynamically change the model results across the outputs worksheets. The formatting of the workbook should resemble that of an investment banking or private equity model. a. Note: The Excel output should look like an investment banking or private equity model, including formatting and dynamic toggles along with tables for annuity and equity portfolios, income statement, balance sheet, cash flows, sensitivity analysis, summary, assumptions and key financial metrics.

    1. Define Parameters and Assumptions: ● Set key parameters and assumptions: ● Portfolio size: 1000●InitialEquityinvestment:1000 ● Initial Equity investment: 100 to maintain a 10:1 ratio between annuities and equity capital ● Policy percentages: 25% MYGA 3-year, 25% MYGA 5-year, 50% FIA 10-year ● Annual Crediting rates: MYGA 3 - 4%, MYGA 5 - 4.5%, FIA - 4.5% ● Ceding commissions: MYGA 3 - 3%, MYGA 5 - 2.5%, FIA - 2.5% ● Age range: 55-70 years evenly distributed between gender and age. ● Withdrawal limit: 10% after year two ● Surrender fees: MYGA 3 year is at 9%, 8%, 7%; MYGA 5 year is 9%, 8%, 7%, 6%, 5%; FIA starts at 10% in year one, decreases yearly to 3% ● Renewal mechanism: Policies auto-renew with the same surrender schedule ● Annual Portfolio Return: 11% ● Startup fee: Initial startup fee - 0.04●Annualexpenses:Salary−0.04 ● Annual expenses: Salary - 0.05, Travel - 0.01,Accounting−0.01, Accounting - 0.01 ● Annual Asset management fee: 100 bps on 1000andonthe1000 and on the 100 ● Ceding fee is a one-time charge in the first year, amortized over 7 years. ● Mortality: Pyliferisk should incorporate IAR 2012 mortality table assumptions ● Clarifying points: ○ The equity investment capital pays the costs of running the reinsurer, deducted from it’s balance each year. The equity investment receives all excess spread return from the annuity portfolio (which is the spread earned between the annuity portfolio return of 11% and the annuity crediting rate). It should also factor in any reductions of account value based on withdrawals starting in year two. The annuity portfolio does not assume any expenses for running the reinsurer factored in it, however it must account for required annuity cashflows such as the annual crediting rate that defers, the withdrawals, the surrender fees and market value adjustment fees etc for the excess return or spread to get the difference between the on the 11% return on the annuity portfolio annual investment and net paid out capital to calculate the excess spread. At the end of year 10 and exit of the reinsurer all deferred unpaid annuity values are made whole, so no accrued obligations based on undrawn crediting rates shall be used for dividends. Also to clarify the equity investment portfolio does not have the same obligations of the annuity portfolio such as annuity crediting rates (annual crediting rates) that it pays. It has other expenses outlined in the next point. ○ The dividends available from the excess returns of the annuity portfolio's spread and equity after factoring in all the various expenses, first must be used to ensure that the annuity account value to equity ratio is not exceeding the maximum allowed leverage ratio. So if the annuity portfolio's account value, including deferrals of undrawn crediting rates increases at the close of year one, the equivalent equity value must be set aside to capitalize the equity account value first before any dividends are paid to maintain the leverage ratio, this is deducted from the remaining available dividends generated from the excess return on the annuity portfolio and the excess return generated on the equity portfolio after the equity assumes all expenses and costs associated with running the reinsurer.
    2. Overview of the Fixed Annuity Reinsurer Investment: ● Establish a fixed annuity reinsurer with a 10-year investment horizon. ● Invest $1000 of fixed annuities - MYGA 3, MYGA 5, and Fixed Index Annuity policies. ● Goal: Develop a model for key metrics - IRR, MOIC, ROE, income statement, sensitivity analysis, balance sheet, and cash flows.
    3. Initialize Portfolios: ● Create tables for annuity and equity portfolios, considering the mix and initial investment.
    4. Loop Over Years (1 to 10): ● For each year, calculate values, gains, deductions, surrenders, fees, and excess returns for MYGA 3, MYGA 5, and FIA.
    5. Calculate Annuity Portfolio Returns: ● Determine annual return considering policy crediting rates, surrenders, mortality, surrender fees, and MVA fees.
    6. Calculate Excess Return (Spread): ● Evaluate excess return on annuities and pass it on to the equity capital's dividend bucket.
    7. Manage Equity Portfolio: ● Calculate equity portfolio returns, allocate funds for reinsurer expenses, including salary, travel, accounting, startup fees, and amortized ceding fee.
    8. Maintain Leverage Ratio: ● Ensure equity capital's ratio to the annuity portfolio does not exceed the 10x leverage ratio.
    9. Distribute Residual Dividends: ● Determine available dividends, considering expenses and maintaining leverage ratio.
    10. Update Portfolio Values: ● Update annuity and equity portfolios for the next iteration.
    11. Calculate Financial Metrics: ● Compute IRR, MOIC, ROE and DCF (for DCF use an 8% discount rate) for the 10-year period.
    12. Generate Income Statement: ● Prepare an income statement with revenue, expenses, and net income for each year.
    13. Balance Sheet: ● Create a balance sheet detailing assets, liabilities, and equity at the end of each year.
    14. Cash Flows: ● Develop a cash flow statement outlining cash inflows and outflows.
    15. Assumptions Section: ● Include a dedicated section summarizing all assumptions. ● Policies renew if not surrendered. ● No taxes. ● Asset management fee is fixed. ● Ceding fee is a one-time charge in the first year, amortized over 10 years.
    16. Summary Section: ● Provide a comprehensive summary of the model's key findings. ● Clearly define the objectives and key metrics of interest.
    17. Sensitivity Analysis Section: ● Evaluate scenarios with varying asset leverage ratios and portfolio yields. ● Observe the impact on ROE for each scenario. ● Assess scenarios with changes in withdrawal sensitivities and market conditions.
    18. Dynamic Expense Calculation: ● Integrate a dynamic expense calculation mechanism, allowing for changes over time.
    19. Dynamic Surrender Fee Calculations: ● Specify dynamic surrender fee calculations for each policy type, outlining changes over time based on policy terms."
  2. Assistant

    User Chat Message: Please write comprehensive Python code and a macro-enabled Excel Workbook for a Bermuda-based fixed annuity reinsurer, following these instructions:

    1. Create Python code that generates a macro-enabled Excel Workbook for the reinsurer. The workbook should include all necessary logic variables, formulas, and functions, and the logic should be embedded in the Macro enabled Excel Workbook.
    2. The Excel Workbook should have well-formatted worksheets and the ability to dynamically adjust model assumptions. For example, changing the FIA Policy percentages should update the model results in the output worksheets. The workbook should have an investment banking or private equity model format.
    3. Define key parameters and assumptions, including portfolio size, initial equity investment, policy percentages, annual crediting rates, ceding commissions, age range, withdrawal limit, surrender fees, renewal mechanism, annual portfolio return, startup fee, annual expenses, annual asset management fee, ceding fee, mortality assumptions, and clarifying points about the equity investment portfolio.
    4. Establish a fixed annuity reinsurer with a 10-year investment horizon and invest $1000 in fixed annuities (MYGA 3, MYGA 5, and Fixed Index Annuity policies).
    5. Develop a model for key metrics such as IRR, MOIC, ROE, income statement, sensitivity analysis, balance sheet, and cash flows.
    6. Initialize annuity and equity portfolios with the defined mix and initial investment.
    7. Loop over years from 1 to 10 and calculate values, gains, deductions, surrenders, fees, and excess returns for each policy type.
    8. Calculate annuity portfolio returns considering policy crediting rates, surrenders, mortality, surrender fees, and market value adjustment (MVA) fees.
    9. Calculate excess returns on annuities and allocate them to the equity capital's dividend bucket.
    10. Manage the equity portfolio by calculating returns, allocating funds for reinsurer expenses (salary, travel, accounting, startup fees), and amortizing the ceding fee.
    11. Maintain the leverage ratio of the equity capital to the annuity portfolio to not exceed 10x.
    12. Distribute residual dividends while considering expenses and maintaining the leverage ratio.
    13. Update annuity and equity portfolios for the next iteration.
    14. Calculate financial metrics such as IRR, MOIC, ROE, and DCF (using an 8% discount rate) for the 10-year period.
    15. Prepare an income statement with revenue, expenses, and net income for each year.
    16. Create a balance sheet detailing assets, liabilities, and equity at the end of each year.
    17. Develop a cash flow statement outlining cash inflows and outflows.
    18. Include a dedicated section summarizing all assumptions, policies renewing if not surrendered, no taxes, fixed asset management fee, and amortized ceding fee.
    19. Provide a comprehensive summary of the model's key findings, defining objectives and key metrics of interest.
    20. Perform a sensitivity analysis by evaluating scenarios with varying asset leverage ratios, portfolio yields, withdrawal sensitivities, and market conditions.
    21. Integrate a dynamic expense calculation mechanism for changes over time.
    22. Specify dynamic surrender fee calculations for each policy type based on policy terms.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.