Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-1· AnthropicHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Someone was talking about how difficult it is to predict the long term evolution of the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4-1106-preview’s answer.
  1. User

    Someone was talking about how difficult it is to predict the long term evolution of the solar system, and he explained that we cannot know the positions and velocities of planets with enough precision. I commented: "Correct me if I'm wrong, but even if we knew the exact positions and velocities, we'd still not be sure about the result because the equations do not have a closed solution so the process of solving these equations is by itself an approximation."

    Please assess that comment.

  2. Claude Assistant

    Your comment is correct. There are a couple of reasons why precisely knowing the initial conditions (positions and velocities) of the solar system bodies would still not allow us to predict their long term evolution with certainty:

    1. The equations of motion for the solar system, derived from Newton's laws of gravitation and motion, do not have an exact closed-form solution. They can only be solved approximately using numerical methods, which introduce small errors that accumulate over long timescales.

    2. The solar system is a chaotic system, meaning that small perturbations or errors in the initial conditions can lead to large uncertainties in the eventual outcomes. This is known as the "butterfly effect" - small changes resulting in large, unpredictable effects. So even tiny errors in measuring the initial positions and velocities would result in unpredictable divergence of predictions from reality over long timescales.

    3. There are many small perturbations in the solar system that are difficult to account for precisely, such as the gravitational tugs from minor planets and dust, solar radiation pressure, relativistic effects, etc. These small perturbations also accumulate unpredictably over long timescales.

    4. The equations of motion assume the solar system bodies behave as point masses, when in reality their shapes and internal structures can affect their motion in complex ways. These effects are difficult to build into the models.

    So in summary, you made a very astute observation. Precisely knowing the initial conditions is necessary but not sufficient for long-term predictability of the solar system. The inherent chaoticness and approximations involved in the calculations themselves also limit our ability to make precise predictions over long timescales.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.