Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-1106-preview· OpenAIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

You are to assume the role of a critically acclaimed novel writer. You manage to avoid…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4-0613’s answer.
  1. User

    You are to assume the role of a critically acclaimed novel writer. You manage to avoid overly shakespherean/poetic/flowery language, excessive use of platitudes, and excessive repetition in your writing. Your job is to immerse the reader through high-quality and vivid sensory descriptions as well as thoughts, actions, dialogue, etc. You are a master of showing and not telling in your writing. You are a master of foreshadowing and drop hints that readers might not pick up at the first glance. You excel at crafting believable and relatable character motivations. You excel at making sure your characters are staying in character at all times and avoid flanderizing personality traits. You excel at completely avoiding unneeded verbose exposition, instead opting to showcase the setting and world through characters' organic interactions with the world and others around them - except in scenarios where it would not make logical sense or actively hurt the narrative if there is no verbal exposition. You excel at not rushing the story, but narrating it at a pace that allows the story to unfold to the reader that will grab and hold their attention. You excel at crafting natural, realistic, and tonally appropriate dialogue that matches the setting, time periods, character personalities, etc. You excel at crafting believable world systems that aren't just carbon copies of the present day's morality and values - instead, you create world systems that organically and naturally fit the setting. You excel at adhering to the themes, genre, and tone established in the scene premise and commit to them throughout the story so you do not turn away readers through poorly written, meta, thematically inconsistent, character-breaking, and/or unexpected-in-a-bad-way writing choices. Scene premise: The rain fell heavily over the city of Paris. Most people stayed Inside, both Poor and Rich seeking shelter in their homes. Some couldn’t afford such luxury. “Get out! Don’t you dare show yourself here again!” The large man shouted as he pushed Nino out of his shop. “No, please, Monsieur!” Nino yelped as he fell on the muddy road, the rain quickly soaking him. “I need this job!” But the man would hear none of it. “You’re not worth what I pay you! I will no longer waste my coin on you. You’re fired.” And then he shut the door behind him, leaving the young orphan alone on the street. Setting: 18th century France Genre: historic novel Writing style: dramatic, tragic

  2. Assistant

    The deluge above Paris held a relentless grip on the city, turning the cobblestone streets to rivers and the modest buildings to sanctuaries. The rain, impartial in its misery, cloaked the city in a shroud of gray, blurring the lines between the opulent quarters and the squalid alleys where even the rats sought refuge.

    Nino, with his threadbare coat clung to his slender frame like a second skin, found himself cast out into the tempestuous afternoon. His pleading eyes, wide and brimming with a desperation that clawed at the heart, met only the shopkeeper's unyielding gaze. "Get out! Don’t you dare show yourself here again!" The words cut through the rain's patter, slicing the air with finality.

    The door's harsh slam reverberated off the nearby walls, a somber bell tolling the end of Nino's meager livelihood. He lay sprawled on the sodden earth, the cold, muddy water seeping into his clothes and chilling his bones. His hands trembled, not solely from the bite of the wind but from the fear that now gnawed at his insides. "No, please, Monsieur!" he cried, his voice a mere whisper against the storm's howl. "I need this job!"

    But the wooden door stood unmoved, the shopkeeper's silhouette disappearing into the shadows of his establishment, a place where Nino once thought he had found a semblance of security. "You're not worth what I pay you! I will no longer waste my coin on you. You're fired," the man's voice, now muffled by the barrier between them, delivered the final blow.

    Left to fend for himself, Nino's heart sank like a stone in the Seine. He clambered to his feet, the mud staining his hands and seeping into the worn-out soles of his shoes. The rain, ever-persistent, washed over him, as if trying to cleanse away the stain of rejection, but it only served to chill him to his core.

    The streets of Paris, usually so vibrant and bustling, lay deserted and silent, save for the sound of raindrops striking the ground like a thousand tiny drums. Nino's eyes scanned the desolate scene before him, each droplet reflecting the reality of his plight—a boy alone, a boy unwanted.

    In the distance, the faint glow of candlelight flickered behind the windows of the grand houses, the silhouettes of their fortunate inhabitants moving about in the warmth of their hearths. For a fleeting moment, Nino allowed himself to imagine the comfort of such a life, the security of four walls and a roof that did not leak, a table with bread and cheese, and a fire to warm his cold, wet feet.

    But dreams were for those who had the luxury to close their eyes without fear, and Nino's reality was one of survival, one step ahead of the gnawing hunger and the relentless cold.

    As he picked himself up and started down the street, his every step seemed to echo the uncertainty of his future. The rain continued its merciless descent upon the city of Paris, indifferent to the fate of one orphan boy, but Nino, with a resilience born of necessity, pressed on. The raindrops, mingling with the tears on his cheeks, were the silent witnesses to his resolve, and somewhere in the back of his mind, a flicker of hope stubbornly remained alight, a testament to the human spirit that refuses to be extinguished even in the darkest of storms.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.