Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
GLMchatglm3-6b· Zhipu AIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Let's solve a SAT problem. I'll tip you if you do it right. The problem is: Here is an…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Yiyi-34b-chat’s answer.
  1. User

    Let's solve a SAT problem. I'll tip you if you do it right. The problem is: Here is an array with a lot of elements in unknown order, say x1, x2,...,xn. Someone gives us his propositions(p1, p2,...,pn) about the postion information of elements. One kind of proposition is about the absolute postion, e.g. p1 = x1 at 0, p3 = xn at 1. Another is about the relative postion, e.g. "p2 = x1, x2", "p6 = x3, x1". Notably, there are one incorrect proposition. Your task is to write an efficient algorithm to determine which proposition is the wrong one, by solving (not p1) and p2 and ... and pn to p1 and p2 and ... and (not pn).

  2. GLM Assistant

    To solve this problem, we can use the concept of disjoint sets and union-find algorithms. Here's the overall approach:

    1. Initialize a collection of disjoint sets, where each set represents an element in the array.
    2. For each proposition p_i in the propositions, do the following:
      • If p_i is an absolute proposition, add the element to the corresponding disjoint set.
      • If p_i is a relative proposition, split the elements in the corresponding disjoint set into two new disjoint sets, based on the relative position.
    3. After processing all propositions, find a disjoint set that has only one element. This element is the wrong proposition.

    Here are some detailed steps for each step:

    1. Initialize a collection of disjoint sets. We can use a hashmap to store the disjoint sets, where the key is the element in the array and the value is the set of elements that have that element as their representative.
    2. For each proposition p_i in the propositions:
      • If p_i is an absolute proposition, add the proposition to the corresponding disjoint set. For example, if p1 = x1 at 0 is a proposition, we can add x1 to the disjoint set associated with the proposition p1.
      • If p_i is a relative proposition, split the elements in the corresponding disjoint set into two new disjoint sets. For example, if p2 = x1, x2 is a proposition, we can merge the disjoint set associated with x1 into the disjoint set associated with x2. We can then remove x1 from the disjoint set associated with x1 and add it to the disjoint set associated with x2.
    3. After processing all propositions, find a disjoint set that has only one element. We can do this by iterating through the disjoint sets and checking if each one has only one element. The first disjoint set we find that has only one element is the wrong proposition.

    This algorithm has a time complexity of O(|E| + |E|log|E|) + O(|E|) = O(|E|log|E|) + O(|E|), where |E| is the number of elements in the array. This is because each proposition takes constant time to process, and there are |E| propositions. The final step of finding the wrong proposition takes linear time.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.