Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Microsoftwizardlm-13b· MicrosoftHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Using 3-PARTITION problem, show the following problem is NPC in the strong sense. We are…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4-1106-preview’s answer.
  1. User

    Using 3-PARTITION problem, show the following problem is NPC in the strong sense. We are given a set T of n tasks. Each task i has a release time ri , a deadline di and a length ℓi . The question is whether there is a feasible schedule for all tasks in T. (in your proof, all numbers ri , di , ℓi have to be bounded by poly(n)).

  2. Microsoft Assistant

    To prove that the 3-PARTITION problem is NP-complete in the strong sense, we will first show that it is in NP and then show that it is NP-hard.

    1. NP: We will show that the problem is in NP by reducing the 3-SAT problem, which is a known NP problem, to the 3-PARTITION problem.

    Given an instance of 3-SAT with m clauses and n variables, we construct an instance of the 3-PARTITION problem with n tasks as follows:

    For each variable xi in the 3-SAT instance, we create a task with a release time ri = 0 (since it is always available), a deadline di = 2m (to ensure that the task will be processed exactly once), and a length ℓi = 2 (to ensure that the task will be processed in a single time step).

    For each clause Cj in the 3-SAT instance, we create a task with a release time ri = 2m + 1 (to be released after all variables have been processed), a deadline di = 2m + 2 (to ensure that the task will be processed exactly once), and a length ℓi = 2 (to ensure that the task will be processed in a single time step).

    Now, the 3-SAT instance is satisfiable if and only if the 3-PARTITION problem instance has a feasible schedule for all tasks.

    1. NP-hard: To show that the 3-PARTITION problem is NP-hard, we will reduce the well-known NP-complete problem, the Knapsack problem, to the 3-PARTITION problem.

    Given an instance of the 0/1 Knapsack problem with capacity W and items each with a weight wi and a value vi, we construct an instance of the 3-PARTITION problem with n tasks as follows:

    For each item i, we create a task with a release time ri = 0 (since it is always available), a deadline di = W (to ensure that the task will be processed exactly once), and a length ℓi = 1 (to ensure that the task will be processed in a single time step).

    Now, the 0/1 Knapsack problem

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.