I am preparing a document for publication in a peer reviewed journal. Based on the…
- User
I am preparing a document for publication in a peer reviewed journal. Based on the discussion of the obtained results, can you write me a conclusion? There is the discussion text: Characterization of the Nanomaterials The BC membranes (in-house produced BCks and nata de coco from Vietnam BCnc) were analyzed by FTIR; the crystallinity index and degree of polymerization were also characterized. Figure 1A shows the FTIR spectra of BCks, BCnc and Avicel LM310. All celluloses present a band at 3344 cm-1 that corresponds to OH stretching and a band at 2890 cm-1 associated to C-H stretching. The infrared spectra of BCs in the region 850-1500 cm-1 shows several characteristic absorption bands of cellulose type I: the peaks at 1429 and 1373 cm-1 reflects the symmetric bending of CH2 and the bending vibrations of the C-H and C-O groups of the aromatic rings in polysaccharides, respectively; the strong band at 1163 cm-1 assigned to C-O stretching or O-H bending of the C-OH group; the strong band at 1109 cm-1 assigned to C-O stretching and a weak band at 895 cm-1 related to C-H rock vibration of cellulose (specific for β-glucosies) [32]. In general, those bands are similar for the plant cellulose with exception to the ones at 1160 cm-1 and 1106 cm-1 that shifted slightly. The three-dimensional structure of cellulose is highly complex and may comprise two distinct crystalline allomorphs, cellulose Iα (triclinic) and Iβ (monoclinic) [33], being the Iα polymorph predominate in BC [23]. In Figure 1 it is possible to identify two peaks around 750 and 710 cm−1, characteristic of Iα and Iβ allomorphs, respectively [23]. By Gaussian deconvolution it was possible to observe that both BCs have similar Iα mass fractions (around 36% for BCks and around 40% for BCnc). In the case of Avicel LM310, only the absorption band at 710 cm-1 (type Iβ allomorph) was discernible, which is expected since cellulose type Iα (triclinic) is prevalent in primitive organisms like bacteria [23, 34]. X-ray diffractometry was used to further characterize the relative crystallinity index (CrI) of the different celluloses. The XRD patterns for the BCs (Figure 1B) exhibited three main peaks at 2θ = 14.6, 17, 22.9°, which, according to the literature, are characteristic of cellulose type Iα [35]. The presence of the peak at 34° (35º for BCks) indicates that both samples present also Iβ allomorph, as shown by FTIR. BCks and BCnc revealed similar and high CrI (88% vs 87%, respectively), in accordance to the literature [35, 36]. Avicel LM310 presents a CrI comparable to that of BC (80%). It is well known that BC has higher degree of polymerization than pant cellulose [37, 38].
In fact, it was confirmed in this study that the viscosity averaged degree of polymerization (DPν) as well as the molecular weight (MW) of BCks and BCnc (DPν = 2419 ± 74 [20] and 1975 ± 36, respectively; MW = 392 ± 12 [20] and 320 ± 6 kDa, respectively) are significantly higher than those of plant cellulose (DPν = 257 ± 43; MW = 42 ± 7 kDa [20]). Regarding the BC, variations on the DPν values are observed, depending on the producing strain, culture media composition and fermentation conditions [27, 39]. Nevertheless, the values here described are similar to the ones reported in the literature, which span from around 1900 to around 3200 [27]. The high crystalline character and high degree of polymerization are very important properties when studying the gastrointestinal fate of BC once ingested. As mentioned in the literature [40], despite the presence of cellulolytic enzymes produced by various bacterial species in the colon (e.g. Ruminococcus, Enterococcus, Bacteroides, or Prevotella), the degradation/fermentation of this insoluble biopolymer in the human intestine is exceptionally constrained [41, 42] due to the limited accessibility of the nanofibers and of the glucosidic β-1,4 bonds [40]. This follows that that BCs is expected to move along the human gastrointestinal tract with limited degradation. Nonetheless, considering the highly unlikely scenario where BCs might undergo extensive hydrolysis by the gut's flora, nanocrystals (BCNC) were additionally produced for testing, in order to assess the potential internalization of the intact BC as well as that of nanocrystals that may be released upon hydrolysis. Another parameter that influences the behavior of BC in the intestine is the size. BC membranes obtained under static culture are formed with randomly assembled nanofibers. Fiber’s morphology and architecture of the membranes used in this study was observed by SEM (Figure 2). The average diameters were determined: 43 ± 11 nm for BCks [20] and 36 ± 12 nm for BCnc. Those values are very similar and are comparable to values reported in the literature [36, 43]. BC membranes were mechanically disrupted using a hand blender (BCksHB, Figure 3A)) or further, with a Vitamix (BCksVIT, Figure 3B and BCncVIT, Figure 3C) to obtain nanofibers bundles with different sizes to be tested in vitro.
As expected, the aspect of the BC bundles (stained with GFP-CBM) in suspension after applying the different mechanical processes is different, with smaller fiber bundles being observed after high shear Vitamix processing (Figure 3).
Those fibers, as well as Avicel LM310 were characterized in terms of size and charge. Similarly to our previous work [20], despite the wide size distribution, the obtained BCksVIT and BCncVIT bundles present an average size D[4,3] of 126 ± 14 and 85 ± 1 μm, respectively. The BCksHB, processed under lower shear rates (hand blender) presents longer fiber bundles, with an average size of D[4,3] of 796 ± 32 μm (Table 1). Avicel LM310, dispersed under high shear mixing to destroy the aggregates (Figure 3D), shows an average size D[4,3] of 14 ± 4 μm (Table 1), which is significantly lower comparatively to the BC bundles and very similar to the sizes normally obtained for the nanocrystals [44]. Regarding the BCksVIT and BCncVIT samples, since the mean size and thickness of the fibber’s bundles are very similar, significant differences in terms of distribution and possible transport through the gut wall are not expected. All BC samples presented a negative surface charge (in the range −15 to −20 mV) and were colloidally stable . Further dispersion procedures, such as extreme sonication, were not used in order not to disrupt the native ultrastructural organization of the fiber bundles. Table 1 - Percentiles, span, mean size distribution and zeta potential of BC and Avicel LM310 samples. Results are presented as the mean ± SD of at least three independent assays. Sample Percentiles (µm) Span Mean diameter (µm) Zeta potential (mV) Dv(10) Dv(50) Dv(90) D[3,2] D[4,3] BCksHB 102 ± 3 601 ± 26 1817 ± 84 3 ± 0 228 ± 8 796 ± 32 −16 ± 1 BCksVIT 15 ± 0 65 ± 0 181 ± 2 3 ± 0 35 ± 1 85 ± 1 −21 ± 1 BCncVIT 17 ± 1 78 ± 3 272 ± 21 3 ± 0 41 ± 1 126 ± 14 −19 ± 1 Avicel LM310 3 ± 0 9 ± 0 28 ± 1 3 ± 0 5 ± 0 14 ± 4 −23 ± 1 Similarly to our previous study [44], an acid hydrolysis with H2SO4/HCl was employed to obtain BCNC, needle-shape nanocrystals (Figure 4) with a highly negative surface charge (−36 ± 1 mV, due to the conjugated sulfate groups [32]), indicating a good colloidal stability as a result of electrostatic repulsion forces. In vitro toxicity Generally, BC can be considered safe and biocompatible. In previous studies, we have shown that neither BC nor BCNC affected the in vitro viability of bone marrow-derived macrophages and fibroblasts [44, 45]. Nevertheless, when envisaging its use as food additive, it is still controversial whether BC can generate toxic effects at the GIT level. As part of the safety demonstration for BC, in vitro metabolic activity studies were performed in Caco-2/HT29-MTX co-culture. Results show that the viability of the cellular model of the intestinal epithelium (Figure 5A) was not significantly affected (p>0.05) by any concentration of the materials used after 24 h of treatment. Similar results were observed in a recent study where a triculture model using Caco-2, HT29-MTX and Raji B cells, where no significant changes in terms of cytotoxicity were observed after treating the cells with cellulose nanofibrils and nanocrystals (0.75 and 1.5 %) [13]. Regarding the THP-1 cells (Figure 5B), at 0.01 mg/mL, none of the celluloses had an impact (p>0.05) on the metabolic viability (reduction below 30%, as defined by ISO 10993 [46]), being this effect more pronounce d (p<0.05) at 0.05 and 0.1 mg /mL. This variation in the metabolic viability is an expected outcome considering that we are challenging the macrophages to recognize and internalize cellulose with variable size, length, shape, degree of agglomerations and source.
In vitro Cellular Uptake: Macrophages Macrophages are key resident immune cells located in proximity to the intestinal epithelial layer that play a variety of roles to maintain intestinal homeostasis, such as phagocytosis of apoptotic and senescent epithelial cells, bacteria or any other material that breaches the gut wall barrier [47]. In have previous shown that bone marrow-derived macrophages obtained from mice were able to internalize BCNC [44]. In this study, we confirmed that human macrophages (PMA-differentiated THP-1 cells) also internalized all of the cellulosic material regardless of the size, morphology and origin (plant or bacteria) (Figure 6). This is an expected outcome considering that those immune cells can internalize different type of particles/materials with sizes under 6 µm [48].
Using GFP-CBM, we could detect cellulosic material inside the cells and, therefore, this is a useful method to evaluate the potential uptake of fibers in the intestinal model. BCNC-treated THP-1 cells were also observed using STimulated Emission Depletion microscopy (STED) and confocal microscopy (Figure 7). The colocalization of the nanocrystals as observed using the two methodologies was analyzed to clarify whether the smaller structures detected using STED could also be detected using confocal microscopy. It may be appreciated that all the nanocrystals (or their aggregates) observed using STED were detected by confocal microscopy (Figure 7). The much higher resolution achieved using STED is further demonstrated in Figure 8A. While blurry structures with ill-defined shapes are seen by confocal microscopy, sharper, brighter and needle shaped nanocrystals are revealed using STED. This makes possible a fairly accurate measurement of the BCNC particle size inside the macrophages (Figure 8B). As could be expected, a wide range of size distribution is observed, spanning in width from 40 to 220 nm (Figure 8B). In have previous study that the average width of a single nanocrystal is 13 nm [44]. Considering an average size of around 16 nm for the proteins that coat the cellulose upon labelling (taking in account a native hydrodynamic diameter of 11.5 nm for an anti-human IgG [49] and a length of 4.2 nm for the GFP [50] and thus a size around 16 nm for CBM3-IgG, on each side (IgG-ZZ-CBM3 - Cellulose - IgG-ZZ-CBM3), a structure consisting of a single nanocrystal should exhibit a thickness of around 45 nm. This is indeed close to the size of the thinner structures observed inside the cells, thicker ones corresponding, presumably, to several coated nanocrystals, organized side-by-side. Despite not being possible to accurately estimate the size of nanostructures using STED, which may be overestimated to some extent, remarkably, single nanocrystals (with around 40 nm) can be observed. Importantly, we are providing a proof of concept for the extreme and more challenging case of single nanocrystals, which is unlikely to occur in vivo. Given the very good correspondence between the images captured using confocal and STED, we may conclude that confocal, despite its lower resolution, is sensitive enough to allow the detection GFP-CBM-stained cellulose fibers or nanocrystals.
In vitro Intestinal Uptake In this study we at
- Assistant
In conclusion, our comprehensive analysis of bacterial cellulose (BC) membranes produced in-house (BCks) and sourced from nata de coco (BCnc), alongside commercial Avicel LM310, has elucidated significant insights into their structural, physical, and biological properties. The Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) analysis confirmed the presence of characteristic cellulose bands and revealed slight shifts in absorption peaks, indicative of the complex three-dimensional structures and crystalline allomorphs inherent to BC. The X-ray diffractometry (XRD) further supported these findings by demonstrating similar high crystallinity indices (CrI) for BCks and BCnc, which are indicative of their robust structural integrity.
Moreover, the significantly higher degree of polymerization and molecular weight observed in BCks and BCnc, compared to plant cellulose, underscores BC's enhanced physical properties. These attributes are particularly relevant when considering the gastrointestinal fate of BC, as they suggest a limited degradation by cellulolytic enzymes in the human intestine, thereby potentially allowing BC to transit the gastrointestinal tract with minimal alterations.
The mechanical processing of BC membranes to obtain fiber bundles of varying sizes and the subsequent analysis of their size distribution, zeta potential, and in vitro toxicity provided further evidence of BC's suitability for biomedical applications, particularly regarding its safe interaction with the intestinal epithelium and immune cells. The successful internalization of BC and BC nanocrystals (BCNC) by human macrophages, without significant cytotoxic effects, highlights the biocompatibility of these materials. The utilization of advanced imaging techniques, such as STimulated Emission Depletion (STED) microscopy, offered a deeper understanding of the cellular uptake mechanism and the intracellular fate of BCNC, thereby reinforcing the potential of BC as a novel material for diverse applications, including as a food additive or in drug delivery systems.
Overall, our findings demonstrate the exceptional properties of BC, including its high crystallinity, degree of polymerization, and biocompatibility, which collectively endorse its potential for various applications in the biomedical field and beyond. Future studies focusing on the in vivo behavior and long-term safety profile of BC will be crucial to fully harness its potential for innovative healthcare solutions.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.