Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-1106-preview· OpenAIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Company A has filed a European patent application EP-A with the EPO. Company B has…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralopenhermes-2.5-mistral-7b’s answer.
  1. User

    Company A has filed a European patent application EP-A with the EPO. Company B has negotiated with Company A the transfer of European patent application EP-A to Company B. For each of the statements 4.1–4.4, indicate on the answer sheet whether the statement is true or false: 4.1 It is possible to validly transfer EP-A from Company A to Company B only for the designated contracting states FR and DE. 4.2 The transfer of EP-A may be recorded in the European Patent Register at the request of Company B, upon production of documents providing evidence of such transfer and payment of an administration fee. 4.3 The transfer of a European patent application becomes effective vis-à-vis the EPO only when it is published in the European Patent Register. 4.4 The transfer of a European patent may be recorded in the European Patent Register during the opposition period.

  2. Assistant

    4.1 True. It is possible for a European patent application to be transferred for only some of the designated states. The EPO allows partial transfers, which means that Company A can transfer its rights in the application to Company B for the designated contracting states (FR and DE) while potentially retaining rights in other states.

    4.2 True. The transfer of a European patent application can be recorded in the European Patent Register. Company B can request such recording upon provision of evidence for the transfer, such as an assignment document, and upon payment of the prescribed administrative fee.

    4.3 False. The transfer of a European patent application is effective vis-à-vis the EPO once it is recorded in the European Patent Register. The publication of the transfer in the register is to inform the public, but the effectiveness of the transfer between the parties and with respect to the EPO does not depend on this publication.

    4.4 True. The transfer of a European patent may be recorded in the European Patent Register during the opposition period. It is important to keep the register up to date, and the EPO allows changes in the legal status of a patent, including transfers of ownership, to be recorded at any time, including during the opposition period.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.