Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmixtral-8x7b-instruct-v0.1· Mistral AIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

MIA = Missions to Interstellar Asteroids As far as we currently know, all life or…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-3.5-turbo-1106’s answer.
  1. User

    MIA = Missions to Interstellar Asteroids

    As far as we currently know, all life or intelligence in the universe is located on Earth.
    It would be nice to see some life headed far away from Earth.
    However, we don't really have the tech to do that now. The key MIA idea is to send off a minimal probe to a passing interstellar asteroid with near current tech and then to transmit upgraded tech to it over the coming years. With enough upgrades it could get to where it could survive the long journey to some distant star system and spread life there.

    An interstellar asteroid already has a huge amount of resources heading out of our solar system. If a probe could use these it could have plenty of material to make spare parts and new things during its long journey. There have been 2 interstellar asteroids that we know of that pass through our solar system in the last decade. As we get better telescopes I expect we will see interstellar asteroids even more often. The MIA mission is to send probes to such passing asteroids from time to time.

    The interstellar asteroids we have seen so far, and expect to see in the future, are moving at speeds such that it will take them thousands of years to get to another star system. If civilization on Earth is not destroyed, they will make newer probes that pass these interstellar asteroids and get to the other star systems long before they do. By the time the asteroid based probes reach there will be millions of people at their destination, if all goes well. So these probes will pose no danger to humans if all goes well. If something destroys all life on Earth, these probes might be the only chance of life in the Universe.

    The machines in the probes would have AI. Although AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) may not be available at the time of launch, the probe could likely be upgraded to incorporate AGI at a later stage.

    Initially power could come from an RTG (radioisotope thermoelectric generator).
    Depending on what is found on the asteroid and what tech comes along on Earth a fusion or fission reactor could eventually be built on the asteroid.

    It seems that Direct Fusion Drive (DFD) nuclear-fusion rocket engines might be available on a time frame that fits with this project. If so, they could be ideal for this project. It is a very high ISP rocket and could get the probe to the speeds needed to land on an interstellar asteroid.

    The machines would spend most of their time inside tunnels in the asteroid to avoid radiation, limit temperature fluctuation, and minimize risk of hitting small things during the trip.

    The initial system would need to be able to refine materials from the asteroid and use a 3D printer to make things. Later, instructions could be sent for making all sorts of things.

    The reusable and huge SpaceX StarShip will soon greatly reduce the cost of getting things to space. So much larger space projects will be feasible soon.

    One of the first things to be made from asteroid materials would be a large antenna to communicate back to Earth at a higher data-rate.

    Some things, like computer chips, would not be manufactured on the asteroid for a long time, so many spare chips would be included in the original cargo.

    It might be possible someday to send tech on how to make seeds for plants starting with digital information. So while it will not launch with any biological life, it may be possible to seed planets with organic life. It will carry DNA information for a variety of life. So this might spread both organic life and AI life.

    Eventually it would be possible to make everything needed to replace anything needed for the mission. Once achieved, the mission could survive until it reaches another star system. With data scrubbing and unlimited spare parts the mission could last over 1,000 years.

    Some tech will advance naturally without any work by MIA over the coming years. Some tech would not be developed till after the probe has been launched and then transmitted later. But some tech would need to be developed by MIA to enable this project.

    Before there is enough funds raised to start work on the probes funds will be used to create prizes, similar to the Xprizes, for accomplishments of tech useful for this project.

    Please write a two page proposal seeking donations from the general public to support MIA. Give the motivation, the reasoning, estimates for the time-frame, the yearly cost, the manpower needed, and the key technical areas that MIA would have to develop, possible prizes, etc. Feel free to ignore anything above or add any related ideas as long as you keep the key idea of sending probes to passing interstellar asteroids. Do include that the MIA website is at http://mia.voyage

  2. Mistral Assistant

    Proposal for the Missions to Interstellar Asteroids (MIA) Project

    Dear Future Space Explorers and Supporters of Interstellar Travel,

    We are excited to announce the MIA project, an ambitious initiative to send probes to passing interstellar asteroids, using near-current technology and upgrading it over time. Our goal is to harness the resources of these asteroids to create a self-sustaining spacecraft that can survive the long journey to other star systems and potentially spread life there. You can learn more about our project at http://mia.voyage.

    Motivation:

    The search for extraterrestrial life has long been a source of fascination and inspiration. While we have not yet discovered life beyond Earth, we believe that the key to unlocking the mysteries of the universe lies in taking decisive steps towards interstellar travel. By utilizing passing interstellar asteroids as stepping stones, we can gradually build up the technology and resources necessary for long-distance space exploration.

    Time-frame and Cost:

    We estimate that the development phase of the MIA project will take approximately 5-7 years, with the first probe launch occurring around 2030. The annual cost of the project is projected to be around $100 million, which will be used for research and development, personnel, and the creation of prizes for technological advancements.

    Manpower:

    The MIA project will require a dedicated team of engineers, scientists, and technicians, with an estimated initial team size of 50 individuals. As the project progresses, we expect the team to grow to around 150 members.

    Key Technical Areas:

    Several key technological advancements are necessary for the success of the MIA project. These include:

    1. Direct Fusion Drive (DFD) nuclear-fusion rocket engines: These high-ISP engines are crucial for achieving the necessary speeds to land on interstellar asteroids and for long-distance space travel.
    2. Asteroid mining and resource utilization: Developing the technology to refine asteroid materials and create spare parts and new components using 3D printing.
    3. Artificial General Intelligence (AGI): While not initially required, the integration of AGI into the probe's AI system will greatly enhance its ability to adapt and respond to unforeseen challenges during the long journey.
    4. Interstellar communication: Creating a large antenna and improving data-rate communication between the probe and Earth.

    Prizes:

    Before the project begins, we will create a series of prizes to incentivize technological advancements in the following areas:

    1. DFD nuclear-fusion rocket engine development
    2. Asteroid mining and resource utilization
    3. Advancements in AI and AGI
    4. Interstellar communication technology

    Spreading Life:

    The MIA project aims to carry DNA information for a variety of life forms, with the potential to seed planets with organic life using digital information. This would allow us to spread both organic life and AI life throughout the universe.

    We invite you to join us on this thrilling journey by donating to the MIA project. Your support will help us develop the technology necessary for long-distance space travel and contribute to the search for extraterrestrial life. Together, we can take the first steps towards making interstellar exploration a reality.

    Visit our website at http://mia.voyage to learn more and to show your support for the MIA project.

    Sincerely,

    [Your Name] MIA Project Lead

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.