Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama2-70b-steerlm-chat· MetaHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Here is a version of Pike’s argument. (TF) (a) “God” is a proper name. “t1”, “t2”, etc.,…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Yiyi-34b-chat’s answer.
  1. User

    Here is a version of Pike’s argument. (TF) (a) “God” is a proper name. “t1”, “t2”, etc., refer respectively to January 1, 1985; January 2, 1985; etc. (Premise) (b) God exists at every moment of time, and is essentially omniscient in the sense that it is logically impossible for him to believe a false proposition, or to fail to believe any true proposition. (Premise) (c) Jack signs his contract at t3, and it is within Jack’s power at t2 to bring it about that he does not sign his contract at t3. (Premise) (G) God believes at t1 that Jack signs his contract at t3. [By (b) and (c)] (PRW) If q is a logically necessary condition for p, and q does not obtain, then an agent has it within his power at t to bring it about that p only

    if he has it within his power at t to bring it about that q. (Here p and q range over dated states of affairs like the sun is shining at t3, Jack eats lunch at t4, etc.) (Premise)3 (d) That it is not the case that God believes at t1 that Jack signs his contract at t3, is a logically necessary condition for Jack’s not signing his contract at t3. [By (b)]4 (e) It is within Jack’s power at t2 to bring it about that God does not believe at t1 that Jack signs his contract at t3. [By (c), (d), (G), and (PRW)]5

    Explain

  2. Meta Assistant

    Pike's argument is a response to the problem of free will and divine foreknowledge, which asks how human free will is compatible with an all-knowing and all-powerful God.

    Pike's argument begins by defining "God" as a proper name and establishing that God exists at every moment of time and is essentially omniscient, meaning that God knows all true propositions and believes no false ones.

    The argument then introduces the scenario in which Jack signs a contract at time t3, and it is within Jack's power at time t2 to bring about the situation in which he does not sign the contract at t3.

    Since God is omniscient, God believes at time t1 that Jack will sign the contract at t3.

    However, if Jack has the power at t2 to bring about the situation in which he does not sign the contract at t3, then it must also be the case that Jack has the power at t2 to bring about the situation in which God does not believe at t1 that Jack will sign the contract at t3.

    This conclusion seems paradoxical, as it suggests that Jack has the power to change God's beliefs about the future.

    Pike's argument is intended to show that the notion of an omniscient God is incompatible with the idea of human free will. If God knows all true propositions about the future, then human actions are predetermined, and humans do not have free will. Therefore, either God is not omniscient, or humans do not have free will.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.