ORDER CARROLL, United States Magistrate Judge. I. INTRODUCTION On June 11, 1991, the…
- User
ORDER CARROLL, United States Magistrate Judge. I. INTRODUCTION On June 11, 1991, the plaintiff, Venus Longmire, filed this action pro se against Alabama State University ASU Joe Reed, the Chairman of the Alabama State University Board of Trustees and Leon Howard, a former president of Alabama State. Ms. Longmire alleged that the defendants had violated rights guaranteed her by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and that Dr. Howard had committed a battery upon her, had falsely imprisoned her, had intentionally inflicted emotional distress upon her, and had defamed her. On September 13, 1991, Ms. Longmire, this time through counsel, filed an amended complaint. The amended complaint added all of the university trustees as defendants and redefined the claims. The claims as redefined are 1 That Ms. Longmire was sexually harassed in violation of rights guaranteed her by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 2 That Ms. Longmire was terminated from her employment in retaliation for her filing of a charge with the EEOC in violation of rights guaranteed her by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 3 That Alabama State University and its trustees negligently and wantonly failed to supervise Dr. Howard 4 That Dr. Howard committed an assault and battery on Ms. Longmire 5 That Dr. Howard invaded Ms. Longmire's privacy 6 That Dr. Howard committed the tort of outrage against Ms. Longmire 7 That all of the defendants breached a contract which they had with Ms. Longmire. On October 13, 1991, Dr. Howard filed a counterclaim against Ms. Longmire which alleges that Ms. Longmire abused legal process and defamed him by accusing him of having attempted to rape her. Ms. Longmire, through counsel, filed a " third amended complaint" on January 13, 1992. The complaint added a claim that the sexual harassment also violated the Civil Rights Act of 1991. It also added claims under 42 U.S.C. 1983 for sexual discrimination and for violation of rights guaranteed by the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. A " fourth amended complaint" was filed on September 23, 1992. That complaint added a claim against Dr. Joe Reed alleging that Dr. Reed violated Ms. Longmire's constitutional rights by terminating her employment because she filed a complaint with the state Ethics Commission. A second amended complaint was filed which simply changed the name of one of the trustees. On July 31, 1992, United States District Judge Myron Thompson issued an order on the defendants' motions to dismiss. A supplemental order was filed on October 22, 1992. According to the terms of those orders, the only claims which Ms. Longmire may pursue against the trustees of Alabama State University are claims under 42 U.S.C. 1983 for injunctive relief in their official capacities. Alabama State University remains a defendant for purpose of the Title VII claim and Dr. Howard remains a defendant for the Title VII claims, the 1983 claims, and the state law claims for assault, invasion of privacy, and outrageous conduct. This case is currently pending on a series of discovery disputes. The issues have been briefed by the parties and the court held oral argument on the various issues on December 11, 1992. II. DISCUSSION The discovery phase of this case has been marked by hostility, anger and a general inability on the part of counsel to get along. The taking of depositions is almost always marked by scheduling problems. When the scheduling problems are resolved and the depositions commence, the court can always anticipate receiving calls from counsel to make rulings on problems which occur during the depositions. The difficulties with the depositions and the daily phone calls to the court caused the court to issue an extensive order concerning the conduct of counsel during depositions. The order was issued on October 7, 1992. The court has had to involve itself in the minutiae of the discovery process. On November 6, 1992, the court was required to issue an order concerning the length of questioning during the plaintiff's deposition because of the inability of counsel to resolve the issue. Since October 30, 1992, at least nine separate discovery motions have been filed. The court has held hearings on discovery matters on October 8, October 26, November 5, and December 11. It has issued orders on discovery matters on October 6, October 7, October 8, October 15, October 28, and November 6. A. THE ISSUES IN JUDGE THOMPSON'S ORDER OF NOVEMBER 20 The serious discovery disputes in this case began on October 6, 1992 when the parties began taking depositions. The bulk of the disputes in this case have centered around the desire of counsel for Dr. Howard and Ms. Longmire to inquire, in deposition, about each others previous sexual activity. On October 15, 1992, this court entered an order limiting that inquiry. The parties then filed various pleadings asking that the limits on the inquiry about the sexual activities be changed. On October 28, 1992, the court entered another order relating to the scope of the parties inquiry about sexual activity. Under the terms of that order, counsel for the defendants were allowed to ask Ms. Longmire about her sexual activity with other persons while she was employed at Alabama State about which Dr. Howard had knowledge. Counsel for Ms. Longmire was allowed to ask questions about sexual activities which Dr. Howard may have had with persons with whom he had a supervisor/supervisee relationship or employer/employee relationship during his most recent term at Alabama State. All of the parties appealed the October 28 order. Following a hearing on the appeal of the October 28 order, Judge Thompson, on November 20, 1992, issued an order directing the undersigned magistrate judge to review certain discovery issues which the parties had not yet presented. A hearing was held on those discovery issues on December 11, 1992. Each of those issues will be discussed in turn. The district judge's order of November 20, 1992 also requested that the magistrate judge resolve the question of whether Ms. Longmire had laid sufficient predicate to inquire into certain alleged sexual relationships of Dr. Howard. That issue was resolved during the hearing which the magistrate judge held on November 20. 1. LONGMIRE'S INQUIRY INTO HOWARD'S ACTIVITIES AT JACKSON STATE Dr. Howard left Alabama State to go to Jackson State University in 1976. He returned to Alabama State in 1984. Ms. Longmire contends that she should be allowed to ask Dr. Howard questions about his sexual activity with women other than his wife while he was employed at Jackson State and during his first employment at Alabama State. These dates were provided to the court by the parties in open court during the December 11th hearing. The limits which the court has placed on the inquiry about Dr. Howard's sexual activity on the Title VII and 1983 claims by this court's order of October 28, 1992 appear appropriate under the case law. Evidence of Dr. Howard's sexual activities with women at Alabama State while Dr. Howard was employed there is relevant to the sexual harassment issues before the court. In Hicks v. Gates Rubber Co., 833 F.2d 1406, 1415 10th Cir.1987 , the court found that evidence of other acts of sexual harassment involving other employees was admissible in determining the " hostile environment" issue. See also Sowers v. Kemira, Inc., 701 F.Supp. 809, 813 S.D.Ga.1988 Weiss v. Amoco Oil Co., 142 F.R.D. 311 S.D.Iowa 1992 . It is equally clear, however, that Dr. Howard's activities outside the work place are irrelevant. Tomson v. Stephan, 705 F.Supp. 530, 536 D.Kan.1989 . The only argument which the Ms. Longmire makes is that evidence of Dr. Howard's activities at Jackson State are relevant to show that the university trustees knew or should have known that Dr. Howard engaged in improper sexual activities at Jackson State before they hired him. Unfortunately for Ms. Longmire, there is no issue before the court which requires any inquiry into what the university trustees knew when they hired Dr. Howard in 1984. The negligent supervision claim which the plaintiff raised in her amended complaint has been dismissed. The only claims remaining before the court involving either the trustees or the university are the sexual harassment claims. The trustees' knowledge of Dr. Howard's sexual activity while at Jackson State are irrelevant to those claims. The plaintiff has never specifically categorized her sexual harassment claim as either a " quid pro quo" claim or a " hostile environment" claim. If the plaintiff's claim is a " quid pro quo" claim, a theory of strict liability applies. If the plaintiff's claim is a " hostile environment" claim, she can prevail against the university defendants only if she shows that the defendants knew or should have known of the harassment and failed to take prompt remedial action against Dr. Howard. Steele v. Offshore Shipbuilding, Inc., 867 F.2d 1311, 1316 11th Cir.1989 . In either case, the trustees' knowledge of Dr. Howard's sexual activities at Jackson State or at ASU during his previous tenure is absolutely irrelevant. This case has been marked by open hostility between counsel for the parties. It is important that this court place limits on inquiries into sensitive areas such as sexual activity in order to control the case. The limitations which the court has placed on the examination of Dr. Howard are consonant with both the letter and the spirit of Rule 26 and necessary to prevent unnecessary embarrassment and invasions of Dr. Howard's private life. The court wishes to note, however, that its ruling is based on the present state of the record. If the plaintiff has actual evidence, not argument, which would establish a good faith basis for the inquiry about Dr. Howard's sexual activity at places other than Alabama State and some relevance to that inquiry, the plaintiff may make an ex parte motion under seal requesting that the court allow such inquiry. 2. HOWARD AND THE 404 B EVIDENCE The interests which Dr. Howard possesses in being free from harassment, embarrassment, and unnecessary invasions into his private life are also possessed by Ms. Longmire. She too has the right to be protected from an invasive inquiry which is irrelevant for discovery purposes. Indeed, courts need to be particularly vigilant in controlling discovery in sexual harassment cases. Priest v. Rotary, 98 F.R.D. 755, 761 N.D.Cal.1983 . In this case, Dr. Howard argues that evidence about Ms. Longmire's prior sexual activity is relevant because such evidence may be admissible under Rule 404 b of the Federal Rules of Evidence. Under Rule 404 b Evidence of other crimes, wrongs or acts is not admissible to prove the character of a person in order to show action in conformity therewith. It may, however, be admissible for other purposes, such as proof of motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or absence of mistake or accident. Dr. Howard argues that he should be allowed to inquire into Ms. Longmire's sexual history because " it is submitted that evidence of any prior instance in which the plaintiff may have been engaged in sexual relationships with individuals in authority over her, resulting in the plaintiff accepting money or favors from such individuals after they have been placed in a compromising position, would be relevant to the plaintiff's motive, plan, or scheme in this case." This sort of generalized allegation that there might be some 404 b evidence somewhere in the case is insufficient to overcome the " potential of the requested discovery to harass, intimidate and discourage
- Assistant
In the legal case of Longmire v. Alabama State University, the court had to address several discovery disputes between the parties. The main issues centered around the limits of questioning regarding the previous sexual activity of the defendants and the plaintiff. The court issued multiple orders to resolve these disputes, ultimately limiting the scope of such inquiries.
The court found that evidence of the defendants' sexual activities at Alabama State during their employment was relevant to the sexual harassment claims against them. However, evidence of their activities outside the workplace was deemed irrelevant. The court also noted that the knowledge of the university trustees regarding the defendants' sexual activity at previous employments was irrelevant to the claims against them.
The plaintiff argued that evidence of the defendants' sexual activity at other institutions was relevant to show that the university trustees knew or should have known of their improper behavior before hiring them. However, the court determined that this issue was not before the court and dismissed it.
The court emphasized the need to prevent unnecessary embarrassment and invasions of privacy during discovery, particularly in cases involving sensitive topics such as sexual activity. The court urged parties to present actual evidence with relevance to their claims, rather than making generalized allegations about potential evidence.
Overall, the court's orders aimed to balance the interests of both parties in being protected from harassment, embarrassment, and unnecessary invasions into their private lives while ensuring the relevance and admissibility of evidence during discovery.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.