Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4-1106-preview· OpenAIHugging Face Arena Human Preference 55K

Make a system for Open D6 rpg rules that gives more detailed actions about melee and…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-2.1’s answer.
  1. User

    Make a system for Open D6 rpg rules that gives more detailed actions about melee and hand to hand combat. It should be a pool system where the players can decide what to focus on each round, attack, defence and or damage. It should include rules about different length weapons.

  2. Assistant

    Creating a detailed combat system for Open D6 that focuses on pool allocation for melee and hand-to-hand combat involves several elements. The core mechanic of D6 System involves rolling a number of six-sided dice equal to your skill level, trying to meet or exceed a difficulty number. Here's a proposed system that breaks down melee and hand-to-hand combat into three main areas: Attack, Defense, and Damage, with considerations for weapon reach.

    Combat Pool

    Each character has a Combat Pool derived from their relevant attributes and skills. For example, a character might have a base Combat Pool equal to their Dexterity attribute plus their Melee Combat skill level. This pool represents the total number of dice they can allocate to Attack, Defense, and Bonus Damage in a combat round.

    Phases of Combat Round

    1. Initiative: Determine the order of combat as per standard Open D6 rules.
    2. Declaration: Starting with the player with the lowest initiative, each declares how they intend to split their Combat Pool between Attack, Defense, and Bonus Damage for that round.
    3. Resolution: Resolve actions in initiative order.

    Attack

    When a character attacks, they allocate a number of dice from their Combat Pool to the Attack effort. Roll these dice against the target's defense difficulty number, typically the result of the target's own defense pool roll or a static number if they chose not to allocate dice to defense.

    Defense

    A character can allocate dice to Defense, rolling them as a reaction to incoming attacks. The total rolled becomes the difficulty number for incoming attacks this round. If a character does not allocate any dice to Defense, their static difficulty might be a base of 10 plus any applicable modifiers.

    Bonus Damage

    Any dice allocated to Bonus Damage add to the base damage of the weapon used if the Attack roll is successful. These dice are not rolled but instead directly translate to additional damage points.

    Weapon Reach

    To add depth to combat, consider weapon length:

    • Short (Knives, clubs): No reach advantage.
    • Medium (Swords, maces): Can engage short weapons without penalty, but suffers a -1D penalty when attacking long weapons as they close in.
    • Long (Spears, polearms): Gain a +1D bonus on the first round of combat against medium or short weapons due to reach but suffer a -1D penalty in subsequent rounds if the opponent is using a shorter weapon and has closed the distance.

    Additional Rules

    • Simultaneous Actions: If two characters have the same initiative, they resolve their actions simultaneously.
    • Movement: A character can move a short distance as part of their action. More significant movement requires allocation of dice from the Combat Pool.
    • Disarm/Grapple: Special maneuvers like disarming or grappling require a successful Attack roll, with the difficulty set by the opponent's Defense roll. If successful, the maneuver occurs in place of normal damage.
    • Multiple Opponents: When facing multiple opponents, a character suffers a cumulative -1D penalty to Defense for each opponent beyond the first.

    Example:

    John's character has a Dexterity of 3D and Melee Combat skill of 4D, making his Combat Pool 7D. He's facing an opponent with a medium-length weapon, while he wields a long spear. John decides to allocate 4D to Attack, 2D to Defense, and 1D to Bonus Damage.

    His opponent, Sarah, has a Dexterity of 4D and Melee Combat of 3D, giving her a Combat Pool of 7D as well. She allocates 3D to Attack, 3D to Defense, and 1D to Bonus Damage.

    In the first round of combat, John has a reach advantage, so he gets a +1D to his Attack, rolling 5D against Sarah's defense. If he's successful, his spear's base damage plus the additional 1D from his Bonus Damage allocation is applied to Sarah.

    This system maintains the simplicity of the D6 mechanics while adding strategic depth to melee and hand-to-hand combat. Players must choose between focusing on offense, defense, or dealing significant damage, making combat more dynamic and tactical.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.