Skip to content
The Chat Archive
claude-1· Anthropic Arena Human Preference 55K

Please give me a summary of the text I give you. Ask for the first text.

  1. User

    Please give me a summary of the text I give you. Ask for the first text.

  2. Assistant

    Okay, please provide the first text you would like me to summarize.

  3. User

    3.1.1. Results – global measures 3.1.1.1. Mean f0

    In general, the normalized mean f0 was highest in the unconfident level, and gradually decreased over the confident, the close-to-confident and the neutral level (F(3, 1552) = 64.25, p < .0001, Fig. 2a). Speaker Sex and Level of Confidence interacted significantly, suggesting that mean f0 was always the highest in unconfident expressions and lowest in neutral expressions for both the female and male speakers (F(3, 1552) = 1.84, p < .0001). However, results showed that mean f0 was higher for statements in the confident than close-to-confident level for female speakers, whereas it was higher in close-to-confident than confident expressions produced by male speakers (see Fig. 2b).

    Fig 2 Download : Download high-res image (384KB) Download : Download full-size image Fig. 2. The mean, the 1st and the 3rd quartile, and the range of fundamental frequency (f0 maximum vs. f0 minimum) for VOC statements in each reassigned level of confidence (a) averaged across speakers and (b) by speaker sex. The mean, the 1st and the 3rd quartile, and the range of amplitude (maximum vs. minimum amplitude) for VOC statements in each assigned level of confidence (c) averaged across speakers and (d) by speaker sex. Measures were normalized for each speaker in reference to neutral-intending expressions and then averaged across speakers within each category.

    3.1.1.2. f0 variation

    The f0 variance tended to be largest in confident statements, followed by close-to-confident, unconfident, and smallest in neutral statements (F(3, 1552) = 22.50, p < .0001, Fig. 2a). These patterns were dependent on speaker sex (Level of Confidence × Speaker Sex of Voice, F(3, 1552) = 25.70, p < .0001, Fig. 2b). For female speakers, f0 variance was highest in the confident level and gradually decreased over close-to-confident, unconfident and neutral statements (with no difference between the last two levels). For male speakers, f0 variance was the highest in unconfident expressions and gradually decreased when producing close-to-confident, confident, and neutral statements (with no significant difference between unconfident and close-to-confident expressions).

    3.1.1.3. Mean amplitude

    The mean amplitude was the largest for confident statements, followed by the close-to-confident and unconfident statements, and lowest for neutral (F(3, 1552) = 37.03, p < .0001, Fig. 2c). Mean amplitude of close-to-confident and unconfident expressions did not differ from each other overall. The difference in mean amplitude between confident statements and the other expressions was larger when produced by female than male speakers (Level of Confidence × Speaker Sex of Voice, F(3, 1552) = 26.39, p < .0001, Fig. 2d).

    3.1.1.4. Amplitude variation

    The amplitude variation was largest for statements perceived as confident, followed by close-to-confident, unconfident, and neutral (Fig. 2c). The close-to-confident and the unconfident level did not differ (F(3, 1552) = 37.03, p < .0001). Again, the difference in amplitude variation between confident expressions and the other expression types was larger in the female than in the male speakers (Level of Confidence × Speaker Sex of Voice, F(3, 1552) = 34.45, p < .0001, Fig. 2d).

    3.1.1.5. Utterance duration

    Utterance duration was the shortest for neutral statements and gradually increased for the confident, the close-to-confident, and the unconfident statements which were longest (F(3, 1552) = 155.52, p < .0001, Fig. 3a). Although the ranking of the four confidence levels was the same across sex types, female speakers in our sample spoke faster than male speakers when identified as expressing confident and unconfident meanings (Level of Confidence × Speaker Sex of Voice, F(3, 1552) = 22.50, p < .0001, Fig. 3b).

    Fig 3 Download : Download high-res image (399KB) Download : Download full-size image Fig. 3. The mean utterance duration of VOC statements in each reassigned level of confidence (a) averaged across speakers and (b) by speaker sex. Measures were normalized for each speaker in reference to neutral-intending expressions and then averaged across speakers within each category. The mean pause duration of VOC statements in each reassigned level of confidence (c) averaged across speakers and (d) by speaker sex. Measures were normalized for each speaker in reference to the mean of all expressions for that speaker and then averaged across speakers within each category.

    3.1.1.6. Pause duration

    Table 4 and Fig. 3c demonstrate the frequency and mean duration of silent pauses in each of the four expression types. The model was built on the duration of pauses in tokens that contained at least one interval of silence (n = 395). In general, confidence-intending statements contained longer pauses than neutral statements (F(3, 404) = 3.88, p = .01); there were no differences between the three levels of confidence. This general pattern was most obvious for female speakers; however, male speakers exhibited a more differentiated pattern, with longer pauses in unconfident expressions, followed by confident, and shortest pauses in close-to-confident expressions (Level of Confidence × Speaker Sex of Voice, F(3, 1552) = 3.20, p = .02, Fig. 3d).

    Table 4. Relative rankinga of differences in the acoustic measures for each reassigned level of confidence, separated by speaker sex (F = female voice, M = male voice) and for all speakers combined.

    Reassigned level of confidence Mean f0 f0 Variation Mean amplitude Amplitude variation Utterance duration Silent pause duration Mean HNR Jitter Shimmer Empty Cell F M All F M All F M All F M All F M All F M All F M All F M All F M All Confident 2 3 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 3 3 1 2 1 3 2 3 1 1 1 2 1 2 Close-to-confident 3 2 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 3 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 1 2 Unconfident 1 1 1 3 1 3 2 2 2 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 3 1 3 Neutral-intending 4 4 4 4 3 4 2 2 2 2 2 3 4 4 4 2 3 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 Notes: 

    a Significant differences are marked by different rank numbers, where smaller numbers mean higher ranking (larger value, linear mixed effects modeling).

    3.1.1.7. Linear trend of global measures

    To examine the linear trend of global acoustic measures as a function of perceived confidence levels, we recoded high to low confidence levels from 0 to 2 (confident = 0, close-to-confident = 1, unconfident = 2) and built LMEMs treating confidence level as a continuous fixed factor. The model revealed a significant predictability effect of the gradual alteration of confidence on the normalized measures of mean f0, β = .74, t = 20.72, p < .0001, f0 variation, β = −.10, t = −2.35, p = .02, mean amplitude, β = −.09, t = −2.20, p = .03, amplitude range β = −.15, t = −3.66, p = .0003, and utterance duration, β = .20, t = 5.88, p < .0001. A gradual decrease in perceived confidence was represented by increased length of an utterance, increased level of pitch, decreased level of intensity, and less changes in pitch and intensity over time.

    3.1.1.8. Summary of global measures

    The different confidence expressions exhibited unique patterns of acoustic signals at the global utterance level. In sum, the speaker expressed low to high levels of confidence with a gradual increase in mean intensity, intensity variation, and a gradual decrease in utterance duration, suggesting a linear modulation of these acoustic measures as a function of a speaker's perceived confidence level (see Table 4). The variation and mean level of amplitude of confident expressions was more different from the other levels in female than male voices. The speaker sex also revealed differential parametric modulation of perceived confidence on the variation of pitch level, with female speakers varying pitch more in unconfident statements, and male speakers more in confident statements. Confident statements sounded loudest in intensity, varied the most in pitch and intensity, and were spoken the fastest (with the exception of utterances perceived as neutral). Unconfident expressions sounded the highest in pitch and were significantly longer in duration, displaying the slowest rate of speech. Expressions that were perceived as not fully confident (close-to-confident) assumed an intermediate position for pitch and amplitude variation as well as mean amplitude and speaking rate, although these expressions were lower than both confident and unconfident expressions in mean pitch. More broadly, as compared with confidence-intending expressions, neutral-intending expressions sounded lower in pitch with less pitch variation, were less intense and less variable in loudness, and spoken at a relatively fast rate with little silence.

    3.2. Local (constituent) measures: pitch, loudness and duration To probe more deeply, we also evaluated acoustic variations on key sentential phrases of the same stimuli. Given that sentential constituents with different linguistic prominence/stress can affect acoustic variations relating to emotion and mental states (Pell, 2001), three key constituent positions were analyzed. These constituents (content words) represent different time points that are likely to be emphasized over the course of making a statement; for our stimuli, this began with an initial subject, followed by an intermediate verb, and terminated with a final object or subject attribute. Initial, intermediate, and final constituents of each statement were determined according to the respective lexical boundary. Acoustic measures were extracted from all constituents that lasted more than 40 ms (3 times maximum pitch periods, pitch floor = 75 Hz) to achieve accuracy (Cheang and Pell, 2008, Ueng et al., 2012). Segments with only a contracted consonant of the word (e.g. “s” in She's a dog lover) were eliminated from the analysis. Altogether 1334, 1322 and 1322 valid tokens survived the criteria for analysis of initial, intermediate and final positions respectively. The total number of qualified tokens was comparable across constituents but higher for female speakers (CS = 231–233 (38.2–38.5%), MW = 291–297 (48.2–49.2%), ST = 191–196 (31.6–32.6%)) than male speakers (CM = 124–126 (20.5–20.9%), NH = 237–239 (39.2–39.6%), SK = 239–243 (39.6–40.2%)). The mean pitch and the mean intensity were normalized for each constituent per speaker, as described for corresponding global measures. This normalization was also performed on the maximum and minimum f0 and amplitude, per constituent per speaker, to obtain measures of normalized f0 variance and amplitude variance. The duration of each constituent was calculated as the interval between the onset and the offset of articulation and was normalized against the mean full utterance duration of neutral expressions (= ).

    In order to evaluate the effect of Time Course, we fit LMEMs on constituent data which included the reassigned Level of Confidence, Speaker Sex and Constituent Position (Initial vs. Intermediate vs. Final) as fixed effects, with by-item intercept as a random effect. The Communicative Function (facts, judgments, intentions) was added as a statistical control. Pitch, intensity, and speech rate data were modeled separately as dependent factors. For the analysis of constituent duration, the number of syllables per constituent was included in the model as another covariate to control for the generally lower number of syllables in initial than intermediate and final constituents.

    3.2.1. Results – local measures The complete display of pitch, loudness, and duration measures as these acoustic features vary in time at key constituents as confidence statements unfold can be viewed in Table 5. In general terms, alteration in local acoustic measures as a function of the perceived confidence level resembles the pattern reported above for global measures. For the sake of brevity, only interactions between position and confidence level are reported.

    Table 5. Mean (standard deviation) of the normalized acoustic measures for local constituents in e

  4. Assistant

    Here is a summary of the text:

    The study examines how speakers express confidence through acoustic cues in speech. It analyzes global measures like mean pitch, pitch variation, mean amplitude, amplitude variation, utterance duration, pause duration across four levels of confidence: confident, close-to-confident, unconfident and neutral. It finds that:

    1. Mean pitch is highest in unconfident expressions and lowest in neutral expressions for both male and female speakers. Mean pitch is higher in confident than close-to-confident expressions for females but the opposite is true for males.

    2. Pitch variation is largest in confident expressions, followed by close-to-confident, unconfident and neutral expressions. For females, pitch variation is highest in confident and lowest in neutral expressions. For males, pitch variation is highest in unconfident and lowest in neutral expressions.

    3. Mean amplitude and amplitude variation are largest in confident expressions, followed by close-to-confident and unconfident expressions. Neutral expressions have the lowest mean amplitude and amplitude variation.

    4. Utterance duration is shortest in neutral expressions and longest in unconfident expressions. Confident and close-to-confident expressions have intermediate durations. Females speak faster than males in confident and unconfident expressions.

    5. Pause duration is longest in confidence-intending expressions and shortest in neutral expressions. For females, pause duration is longest in confident expressions. For males, pause duration is longest in unconfident expressions.

    6. There is a linear decrease in pitch, amplitude and amplitude variation and an increase in utterance duration as confidence decreases from confident to unconfident expressions.

    The study also examines how these acoustic cues vary over the course of an utterance by analyzing initial, intermediate and final constituents. The results show that the patterns observed in the global measures are also reflected in the local constituents.

    In summary, the study shows that speakers signal confidence through higher pitch, greater pitch and amplitude variation, higher amplitude, faster speaking rate, shorter pauses for confident expressions and the opposite pattern for unconfident expressions. Close-to-confident and neutral expressions assume intermediate patterns. Females and males also differ in some of these signaling patterns.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.